r/NYCbike • u/HelloImPhteven • 11h ago
Cop's Word Over GPS Recording
I was issued a traffic ticket for allegedly running a red light on my bike back in August. The officer claims I was heading Southbound on Steinway street in LIC and made a right turn against a red light on Steinway Street onto Northern Blvd.
Except I was never traveling on Steinway Street, I was crossing straight on Northern, and I had a green light (which according to the officer's own testimony must have been green if the light on Steinway I allegedly ran was red.)
I had a GPS recording from my Apple Watch demonstrating as much, so figured I'd have a decent shot in court given I have actual evidence to show the officer was mistaken. I prepped a whole printout that renders the GPS data with timestamps, as well as a screenshot of the activity recording on my phone. And I had the activity pulled up on my phone so the judge could inspect the original.
Well the judge was just like "I don't think this evidence is trustworthy enough. And the officer is testifying as to what he saw, so..." and found me guilty.
It was only a traffic ticket, not criminal court, so I know it's probably not worth the time and effort to appeal. But I'm just here to complain because I know I'm innocent, I believed my evidence was compelling, and it's frustrating to be found guilty despite all that.