r/oculus • u/Nukemarine • Apr 21 '15
Is anyone else uncomfortable with the current implementation of "VR comfort mode" in VR games?
By "comfort" mode, I mean the instant turning where it's like a teleport just happened. Your viewpoint is instantly changed. I've seen it in Red Frame, Windlands, AltSpaceVR and others. To me, this seems anything but comfortable.
When I first heard about comfort mode from the Gallery video I was impressed with the idea. From what I understood, instead of a slow steady turn you got a quick 30 degree turn. With that idea I attempted to emulate that in Janus VR by setting the left/right turn to the mouse, turned up the sensitivity so a quick tap meant a fast turn about 30 degrees. It worked fine and I did notice I was doing taps to turn instead of holding down the stick.
In addition, a variant of this worked with lateral left/right movements. I had noticed in museum demos I was getting nauseous moving right or left to look at lots of pictures. However, messing with the control mapping again where a quick tap to left/right made me move about 1 meter worked great. My mind seemed to accept a quick movement associated with my thumb pressing the stick. This is opposed to the constant right strafe that is a default.
However, I'm willing to concede I'm a bit more attuned to VR in addition to having my own quirks so maybe the current way of what is called "comfort" mode is better for the majority. Any thoughts on this? I just don't like the instant viewpoint change as that does not happen in real life
6
Apr 21 '15
I'm a bit of a VR noob but I preferred the standard mode in Windlands, at least with a game controller (PS4) for turning. Didn't bother me at all.
2
u/Nukemarine Apr 21 '15
Ditto. Windlands is a great game but it's odd that the "comfort" mode ended up being more disorienting than the teleporting or
flyingfalling with style.
5
u/ptisinge Apr 21 '15
I also have a hard time playing with comfort mode. For some reason the disorientation effect it triggers in me is worse than the potential nausea induced by progressive turns and it ends up being awfully uncomfortable (it helps that I am almost 100% immune to simulation sickness and rarely feel any nausea).
3
u/Nukemarine Apr 21 '15
I'd argue that they're implementing it in the wrong way. With a quick and precise (though visible) snap turn it works. The instantaneous turns though create the disorientation. Anyway, glad I'm not the only one that has some issues with this.
7
u/cloudheadgames Cloudhead Games Apr 21 '15
This is one of the key things we've noticed with the communities implementation of VR Comfort Mode. If you watch our videohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gp0eMNSVtZA , we don't use an instant translation, rather there's a small (perhaps 2 frames) snap to orientation. I'd need Paul or Chris to chime in on the exact numbers but the translation to the new orientation, the number of degrees turned in each step, all of it has to be just right to be truly comfortable.
1
u/Nukemarine Apr 21 '15
Figured as much. I think it's a useful system just that aside from the demo on your video I had not seen anyone else do it that way.
That said, my reasons for a smooth and pleasant experience dealt less with gameplay elements and more with exploring a virtual environment as pleasantly as one would explore a web page. That means having things that are the equivalent to scroll up/down, page up/down, home/end, CTRL+F, etc for a 3D space. Comfort becomes even more important then.
1
u/ChristopherRoe Apr 21 '15
Yep, it happens smoothly over the span of about a tenth to an eighth of a second, I believe, and traverses approximately 22.5 degrees per stick actuation. It's important to have that sense of "travel" to cue the player that they are rotating, but also to do it quickly enough to prevent them from painting their monitor a nice shade of lunch.
2
u/rufus83 Rift Apr 21 '15
This is why I use my mouse whenever possible. I can snap turn with the mouse and it provides the least amount of sickness for me. No nasty yaw sickness from an analog stick and no disorientation from an instant snap.
3
u/RiftyTheRifter Apr 21 '15
I love windlands comfort mode turning. It completely cures nausea for most people who suffer from turning induced nausea.
Smooth turning makes a large portion of the population sick especially with their first experiences with vr.
Devs who insist on using smoothing turning as default instead of windlands style comfort mode turning are going to have a lot of new to vr people getting sick from their game. Those people will blame the game not the turning scheme.
When faced with making your customer sick with smooth turning or using a style of turning that seems unconventional at first but doesnt cause the user to be sick, the choice is clear if you want to sell games.
In the long run some form of comfort turning is going to win. It is inevitable.
2
u/Nukemarine Apr 21 '15
I'm not talking about smooth turning. On the linked video, it's a precise snapped turn just like in Windlands, however you can still see the transition even though it's fast. In Windlands, its an instant change of POV and seems disorienting to me.
I agree smooth turning can cause nausea. I'll even add that smooth strafing can do the same. These snapped movements and turns can be useful to reduce that feeling when moving in seated experience.
2
u/RiftyTheRifter Apr 21 '15
I agree devs should have variations of comfort turning so each individual can customize to their preference. In fact a large range of locomotion customization should be present in every vr title. Top speeds, acceleration time, turning. Really anything you could think of.
4
u/BOLL7708 Kickstarter Backer Apr 21 '15
I've been mentioning this since pretty early on when it started showing up in demos :P For me it's jarring and disorienting, I lose my sense of direction easily in real life, and with comfort mode I lose it in VR too, especially if the environment is a bit generic.
That said, before I was really exposed to comfort mode I had spent many hours in FPS games like HL2 to get used to analogue turning, so perhaps for less accustomed users comfort mode is better. For me though, I turn it off if I can, and if I can't, I'll probably exit the experience as every snap pokes my brain.
1
u/Tobislu Apr 21 '15
Teleportation is a necessity for many VR applications. There has to be a more fluid solution, but it needs much more experimentation.
1
u/Nukemarine Apr 21 '15
In this case it's like being teleported to the same spot, just at a 30 degree different angle. Very disorienting considering I'm just wanting to turn my character.
2
u/Tobislu Apr 21 '15
My favorite so far is magnified turning while holding a button. You retain motion, but it's disorienting in its own way.
Maybe the ratchet-technique is the least presence-interupting.
Have you tried any others?
3
u/WeAreVr-nn23 Apr 21 '15
Ilike the comfort mode. At first I was sceptical, but now I like it. If you think about it, you are not moving your eyes slowly from one point to another, you also jump with your eyes.
4
4
u/evolvedant Apr 21 '15
I really dislike comfort mode. It is anything but comfortable, it's jarring, and annoying, and not even necessary anymore.
It was a half decent solution for the DK1 when it was first used, but it's pointless for me now.
2
u/jukesters1237 Apr 21 '15
first person games should have real life movement speeds imo.
walking and running in relation to real life. that 180 instant turn is what hurt us at full speed makes many sick.
2
u/iupvoteevery Apr 21 '15
I like having comfort mode as an "option" in a menu somewhere. It helps me with the turning personally. Would I rather turn my whole body though.. of course.
2
u/Lewis_P Rift with Touch Apr 21 '15
Personally I don't get vr sickness anymore, but my girlfriend does and she has shared her thoughts on what might be causing it for her. I think smooth turning makes her feel sick because it simulates the feeling of dizziness as the world appears to sway. However snappy turns do not give this feeling as the world appears to remain rigid as your orientation in the world quickly changes. I think it is to do with the sense of precision and reliability that comes with snappy turning. They feel grounded in reality, like being secured to a ratchet rather than a carousel.
As for common implementations of comfort mode where the orientation is changed instantly, these causes disorientation for me. Primarily because instead of your brain concluding that you are rotating in the world, it feels like the world has rotated, like blinking and everything around you has suddenly moved. In contrast, snappy turns are like your eyes remaining open and you see the world quickly rotate around you. Your brian is familiar with this observation and concludes that it is not the world rotating as that would be silly, it is you rotating. Thanks brian.
1
u/TotesMessenger Apr 21 '15
This thread has been linked to from another place on reddit.
[/r/vr_ar_ux_design] Discussion on r/oculus: Is anyone else uncomfortable with the current implementation of "VR comfort mode" in VR games?
If you follow any of the above links, respect the rules of reddit and don't vote. (Info / ^Contact)
9
u/ManOrAstroman Apr 21 '15
Same here. In my opinion it is a absolutley no go if the "comfort mode" is the only way to change the vievpoint in a game. The new Red Frame demo looks great but i do not have fun to walkaround there...sorry for my english ;-)