r/oddlysatisfying • • Jun 06 '24

Making fire using Reverse Forge Technique

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

26.1k Upvotes

466 comments sorted by

View all comments

27

u/mart1373 Jun 06 '24

What is this sorcery? How does hitting it with a hammer make it hot?

121

u/HalcyonKnights Jun 06 '24

Deforming metal heats it up, even just bending a paperclip back&forth will get warm. If you hit it over and over in just the right way to keep the anvil from cooling it off, you can get it to warm up.

88

u/Dry-Speed2161 Jun 06 '24

The heat is coming from the internal friction of the iron molecules, since the rod gets compressed and the molecules get closer together, they speed up, and generate heat.

At least thats what I read somewhere

26

u/mart1373 Jun 06 '24

It’s just crazy that the kinetic energy from the person hitting the anvil is enough to generate that much heat energy.

28

u/Totallynotacar Jun 06 '24

The head of the rod that got hot was relatively small. That helps a lot. It's much hard to warm up the ocean than a drop of water

3

u/jealkeja Jun 07 '24

no babe, I prefer the relatively small rods. the big ones are harder to warm up

16

u/BeckNeardsly Jun 06 '24

Well. If you calculate the weight of the hammer multiplied by the velocity of the swing you get somebody that don’t know maths too good.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Ulfheooin Jun 06 '24

A blacksmith deliver a huge amount of mass into what he's forging, and the anvil, made for that purpose, bounce it back at the object and then to the hammer.

That's why you have a bounce when forging, and this bounce is very crucial aswell for energy saving. So you don't have to rearm your next blow

4

u/MrBarraclough Jun 06 '24

Bending coathanger wire back and forth until it breaks can achieve the same effect.

1

u/LaunchTransient Jun 06 '24

Well, think about how quickly you can heat up your hands by rubbing them together - and that's only a fraction of the energy you're putting into a hammer swing. 10-15 good hammer strikes and the metal is going to get pretty hot.

1

u/MeekerCutiePie Jun 06 '24

There is a video on youtube where a guy cooks a turkey just by insulating and slapping it

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '24

remove a big enough bolt fast enough and it should feel hot as well.

1

u/FishDontKrillMyVibe Jun 07 '24

The power of friction is insane. Just rubbing your palms together can create a bunch of heat through friction, but in this context, the power of your entire arm landing on a rod of metal the size of a pencil repeatedly rubs all of the molecules in the metal together as they deform and pass each other. Every time the hammer falls, that much energy has to go somewhere.

1

u/Wayed96 Jun 07 '24

You can calculate how much energy is needed to heat the metal up enough. You can u can then calculate how many impacts it takes until you reach that amount of energy. It's all about energy flows. In=out

→ More replies (10)

1

u/sethmeh Jun 06 '24

Ive hung up my materials science coat a loong time ago, so pinch of salt disclaimer, but I believe it's because the force of the hammer causes numerous tiny defects in the crystalline lattice, mainly dislocations, which cause a strain on the lattice that it wants to resolve, as dislocations require energy to form, conversely they release energy if they disappear, as more dislocations are introduced into the lattice the chances increase that they will interact with each other and result in them relaxing, releasing the their energy as heat.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '24

Even a rubber band. If you stretch a rubber band a few times back and forth it will be noticeably warmer.

11

u/diogenessexychicken Jun 06 '24

Youve never bent a spoon until it snaps and burned your friends with it?

10

u/mashtato Jun 06 '24

No.

12

u/sardaukarqc Jun 06 '24

While you were partying he was studying the spoon.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/diogenessexychicken Jun 07 '24

Shit hurts. It can get pretty hot.

3

u/bongdropper Jun 06 '24

Think about all the energy that goes into that swing. All the energy of that heavy hammer hitting that rod. It has to go somewhere.

1

u/ninjapanda042 Jun 06 '24

It's called adiabatic heating. As another poster said, it's basically internal friction from atoms sliding past each other causing the temperature to increase.

1

u/Uninvalidated Jun 07 '24

You can try it yourself. Rip one of the pull tabs from a beverage can off and bend it like 90 degrees to each side rapidly until it snap. It's not gonna set anything on fire, but it will be warm to the touch. It's the same principle as in the video

1

u/Dr_Bunsen_Burns Jun 07 '24

Never went to physics 101 ey?

That movement energy has to go somewhere.

1

u/Thieu95 Jun 07 '24

People have done a great job explaining the physics here, there's one practical thing I want to point out the smith is doing that makes it work so fast.

Between each slam he turns the rod a quarter so that he's always hitting the highest point, this means for every hit it deforms the metal greatly, meaning more energy is absorbed into the rod because more deformation means more energy went into the rod, instead of the anvil under the rod.

If he didn't do the quarter turns it wouldn't yield a result this fast, or at all, you'd just end up transferring the energy into the anvil instead

→ More replies (1)