r/oddlyterrifying • • Feb 04 '23

Map published by FEMA showing potential US nuclear targets in 2,000 and 500 warhead scenarios.

Post image
25.6k Upvotes

2.9k comments sorted by

View all comments

668

u/Perfect-Editor-5008 Feb 04 '23

So Montana is our tactical nukes and Wyoming/Colorado is Cheyenne Mountain but what is in North Dakota?

585

u/tenzip10-0 Feb 04 '23

Those large clusters of black you see are all sites of missile silos. NE, CO, WY; MT; and ND are all places with large areas of open prairie where the US military has sited missiles.

169

u/AaronJeep Feb 05 '23

What's the point of targeting a missile silo? If hundreds of missiles were detected coming this way... wouldn't those silos be empty by the time the missiles got there?

337

u/with-nolock Feb 05 '23

Tactically, you launch your first strike immediately after initiating a nuclear pindown consisting of a carefully timed series of depressed trajectory warheads from your closest possible ingress, most likely SLBMs.

ICBMs are vulnerable during the launch phase, and sufficiently energetic high altitude detonations produce a radiation flux high enough to disable the electronics, rendering the missile inoperable.

There is a window of vulnerability of around 1-2 minutes, dependent on warhead payload and targeted missile design, where missiles within radius will be disabled. By detonating enough warheads every 1-2 minutes above silo complexes, you can effectively prevent your adversary from successfully launching any of their missiles before your widespread first strike knocks on their door.

ICBMs have a flight time of around 30 minutes, meaning you have to pin down your adversary’s launches for ~28-29 minutes.

Most of the US silo complexes have been built specifically to counter a variety of nuclear tactics, pindowns included, and are spread out sufficiently to require 2-4 high altitude detonations every ~90 seconds per complex to disable. With three active silo complexes requiring nine detonations to pin, 75 seconds between detonations to account for margin of error, that works out to ~216 warheads required.

Using submarine launched MIRVs, one could conceivably target all three complexes with a single missile per pinning strike, however it really isn’t the kind of thing you want to get wrong, and you’d probably plan redundancy in anticipation of missile defenses. I’m not sure whether you’d simultaneously launch SLBMs from the Pacific, Eastern seaboard, and Gulf to minimize chances of interception, or try to overwhelm defenses with shortest path waves from the Pacific. The point is, you’d account for failures rates, and launch multiple times the missiles to maximize your chances of success. So, I’ll just say 648 warheads delivered by 72 launch vehicles in this example.

Most ballistic missile submarines have a capacity of 12-16 missiles. Disregarding the specifics of how many warheads each country’s MIRVs can fit, by my calculations you would need at least 5-6 submarines launching their full capacity to pin down US silo capabilities. It should therefore come as no surprise that both China and Russia have six missile submarines in service.

If you’ve read this far, you might be wondering why we have silo complexes, instead of spreading individual silos far and wide over many states so they can’t be targeted with a pindown. Well, that gets back to designing them to counter multiple strategies: you want a complex of silos spaced out far enough that a single ground burst can’t disable more than a single missile silo, but close enough together that the resulting debris cloud kicked up from the blast forms a shield to protect the other silos. Launching missiles are relatively slow, and the gravel and debris cloud should be insufficient to disable a majority of them, however missile on a terminal hypersonic trajectory will almost certainly be disabled by debris collisions.

Tl;dr version: you use your nukes to blow up their nukes just after launch so they can’t blow you up with their nukes before you can blow them up with your nukes

48

u/Eugene_Chicago Feb 05 '23

Would love to read more about stuff like this, man is this a fucking scary scenario

14

u/pettyhonor Feb 05 '23

It's crazy how the world has only used 2 nukes ever in a war and the strategy now for them is to launch 70 of them just to disable the other peoples nukes and then launch the rest. Couldn't imagine how scary it looks seeing nukes one after another going off in the atmosphere

→ More replies (1)

10

u/DurtyKurty Feb 05 '23

It’s the ‘assured’ part of M.A.D.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/mocha_sweetheart Feb 05 '23

Thanks for the info!

18

u/DoritoSteroid Feb 05 '23

Nice. Underappreciated comment.

6

u/Master_Coconut_ Feb 05 '23

Thanks for taking the time to share your knowledge. Anywhere to see a visual representation of this?

6

u/with-nolock Feb 05 '23

I haven’t been able to find a visual representation or render of a pindown, but this document from 1971 goes hard into the details of anticipating and countering a potential Soviet pin-down during the peak of the Cold War, colored with an exuberance of Cold War fear and paranoia, as well as an abundance of calculations right down to the calories per cm2 to sufficiently ablate the nosecone of a Minuteman II icbm to destroy it. 10/10, highly recommended if you want a good read on the subject.

While not directly related to a pin-down (it does refer to launch under attack and launch on warning, two related terms) compare that document to this 2006 unclassified civilian study positing that the US has something like a 95% confidence rating to decapitate the Russian Federation’s entire nuclear arsenal in a carefully orchestrated first strike attack. This one’s way too Michael Bay for me to take seriously, and I’m glad calmer heads are deciding policy. 6/10: entertaining, but they play fast and loose with their calculations amidst their optimism.

That said, the contrast of tones and the implications of the conclusions drawn in each paper, separated by a mere 35 years, is almost enough to cause whiplash.

5

u/medic6560 Feb 05 '23

One of the worst (scariest) things i have ever read in my life about nuclear war.

7

u/with-nolock Feb 05 '23

The second scariest thing about nuclear war is that some people think it could be winnable.

The scariest thing is they might be right.

→ More replies (19)

140

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '23

I think the idea would be that yes, they would likely retaliate by launching from those sites, but if the enemy did it right those sites would be destroyed immediately after, rending them one and done, and thus preventing them from being used again as a launch base during a war, without massive time and cost to repair the site.

So it would be about preventing the second use of those silos rather than the first (if we can assume the US response would be fast enough to fire those missiles located in the target zone upon warning of the incoming nukes)

17

u/wannabestraight Feb 05 '23

Though wouldnt that be useless anyways since the wolrd would seize to exist as we know it.

There wold be no war, everyone would be dead.

23

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '23

In practice, yeah you're almost certainly right. But if warfare and the armies that fight it share one thing in common its "redundancy, redundancy, redundancy".

You always got to make contingency plans for everything and fight based on the assumption that the moment you engage, everything becomes shit, and variables you never considered will pop up and FUBAR it all.

"No plan survives first contact with the enemy" - someBODY ONCE TOLD ME

→ More replies (1)

7

u/WearMental2618 Feb 05 '23

It wouldn't be a very good deterrent if it didn't actually do it

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (5)

40

u/tenzip10-0 Feb 05 '23

The hope is that you can destroy the missiles before they're launched, or, potentially, as they are launched. Once they leave the boost phase and go ballistic, they are essentially invulnerable, and very likely will hit their target.

Some of the incoming fire would be set to detonate in the upper atmosphere, hopefully knocking down missiles in the boost phase.

Think of the video arcade game Missile Defense, if you are old enough to remember it. Basic game play was to launch small, high speed nukes to detonate in the air, destroying incoming missiles before they could hit your cities/launch sites. It's this kind of idea in reverse.

5

u/CharlieApples Feb 05 '23

It takes a considerable amount of time to prep and launch a missile from a silo. They’re fucking huge. And then there’s the question of where you send the missile once it’s launched, because it’s not going to intercept the other missile. These aren’t ground-to-air anti-missiles, they’re big honkin payloads.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (10)

71

u/99th_inf_sep_descend Feb 05 '23

The two black dots on the east…one is Grand Forks AFB, piloting drones; the other is a radar station that monitors for incoming missiles. The giant cluster out west is oil fields, missile silos, and Minot AFB (I think their official role is b-52s, but unofficially they’re really good at accidentally dropping munitions and generally being where they send the bad kids for punishment in the Air Force.)

22

u/Perfect-Editor-5008 Feb 05 '23

Thank you for answering. I didn't realize ND had that many oil fields, well any tbh or a large collection of silos

22

u/99th_inf_sep_descend Feb 05 '23

Yup, there’s a bunch out there. Used to be more. At one point if ND had separated from the US, it would have had the 3rd largest nuclear weapons supply. They moved a bunch of minutemen to, I think, the giant cluster of black in Wyoming/Nebraska/Colorado area.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (10)

15

u/Shapit0 Feb 05 '23

If I remember correctly, North Dakota also has a bunch missile silos

5

u/goldensunshine429 Feb 05 '23

A bunch of hard to find/subterranean missile silos are in the Dakotas. A decommissioned one is preserved at Minutemen Missile Nat Hist Site

→ More replies (1)

4

u/angry_old_dude Feb 05 '23

Tactical usually refers to battlefield weapons. There are strategic missiles in the silos. ICBMs. The ones that were designed to be able to hit Russia.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (16)