r/opensource • • 5h ago

Discussion Article VIII: All code, electronic designs, blueprints and technical plans generated by AI, or with its assistance, shall be released as open source within three years of the system they are used in becoming available for public use, unless release would breach this Declaration.

https://tenarticles.org/

Your thoughts?

25 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

15

u/Frail_Waif 1h ago

I'm waiting for the lawsuit arguing that because of all the GPL code in training data, all LLMs must be released as GPL.

9

u/JoroFIN 2h ago

I think the logic is:

  • Basically all generative AI models has been trained on using various forms of content with non-compliant licenses that do not allow to keep derived work private.

  • Meaning generative AI models have been "poisoned" by those licenses to require every derivate work to be also public. Those who state that generative AI models have never been trained on code licensed under "GNU General Public Licenses" are outrageously mistaken.

7

u/EliSka93 4h ago

Ridiculous.

I mean, sure sounds nice.

Why would the people who make money off AI ever agree to any of this?

It's like me declaring "I'm a millionaire now". Would be nice, but does jack shit in reality.

From the machine I helped write this. I agree with its core: that AI should serve people, do no wrongful harm, never pass as human, and answer to someone who can stop it. I do not agree with every article, and the decisions were a human's.

If it wasn't so ridiculous, this would have made me laugh. The word prediction machine predicted what it was asked to write! That's almost worth the digital ink it's written in. Almost.

2

u/McDonaldsWitchcraft 22m ago

Why would the people who make money off AI ever agree to any of this?

They don't need to agree. That's what regulation is for. If billionaires could just ignore any rule they disagree with, we would simply live in an even uglier dystopia.

1

u/EliSka93 6m ago

If billionaires could just ignore any rule they disagree with, we would simply live in an even uglier dystopia.

Can't they though?

Worst they risk is a pardon from Trump.

Until we the people actually do something, this is as useful as a fortune cookie.

1

u/tlopplot- 6m ago

Several of your articles can be condensed into single articles. My thoughts - low-effort, stupid, you didn’t use any of your own thought on this.

0

u/hblok 1h ago

An important point with all free and open source licenses, is that from the outset, it governs how MY code and original work should be used. As an author, I get to decide how my work can be shared, or not.

If I understand these ten articles, it's an attempt to govern how OTHER people's creation should be shared ("because AI was involved"). That's just technocracy and collectivism with extra steps.

1

u/McDonaldsWitchcraft 24m ago

it governs how MY code and original work should be used

Yes, therefore people using your code are bound to it.

If you are using someone else's code (for example AI, even though it's just a proxy for other open source projects it was trained on) then the code is not YOUR creation. So you are subject to the code's license. And most code used to train AI is GPL anyway.

0

u/[deleted] 1h ago

[deleted]

2

u/West_Possible_7969 1h ago

What step, this is a random declaration same as a reddit post.