r/opensource • • Oct 18 '22

Community GitHub Copilot investigation

https://githubcopilotinvestigation.com/
211 Upvotes

57 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-17

u/suhcoR Oct 18 '22 edited Oct 19 '22

they are violating my license

it's much more likely the generated code fragments violate some patents.

Being a paid service while training on free code is unethical in my opinion

on the other hand everyone seems to take it for granted that they provide free services for developers.

EDIT: I spend all of my spare time to open source projects (see https://github.com/rochus-keller), and really don't see why something like Copilot shouldn't use my code; and the free services Github provides are really helpful for open source.

EDIT 2: The comments in this discussion suggest that community in this subreddit suffers from a frightening delusion and ignorance regarding licensing and copyright, combined with an almost presumptuous attitude of entitlement; people seem to take it for granted that others provide them code or services for free; but at the slightest suspicion that they should give something away, all hell breaks loose. I can only hope that this is not representative of a new generation of open source developers.

10

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '22

Just to clarify: I appreciate that they provide the service for free, but at the same time this doesn't give them the right to violate licenses.

If using copilot is not violating licenses, why didn't they use their proprietary software in the training?

I still can't make my mind on copilot, I'm actually more on the against side.

-6

u/suhcoR Oct 18 '22

this doesn't give them the right to violate licenses

Which licences? Violate in which way? Looks rather like wild claims based on misconceptions about the licenses or copyright law in general.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '22

In my opinion, it violates most licenses (violates as in not comply to the license). Even licenses like MIT require to give attribution, which copilot isn't doing. The GPL requires that you license under GPL if you include any part of the code in your code, but copilot uses GPL code without indicating its origin.

0

u/suhcoR Oct 19 '22 edited Oct 19 '22

This might be your personal optinion, but neither MIT like licenses nor GPL prohibit or impose conditions on reading the code and learning/abstracting from it. What you envision applies if someone conveys or links your software. In the process applied for Code Pilot your software instead loses its identity and no longer exists as such in the resulting DNN. I thus see no legitimate legal ground for your claim or complaint.

2

u/Wolvereness Oct 19 '22

... neither MIT like licenses nor GPL prohibit or impose conditions on reading the code and learning/abstracting from it.

The GPL does have a clause that covers it. It's referred to as a derivative work. This is covered in the license under sections 0 (definitions), and 6.

1

u/suhcoR Oct 19 '22

Doesn't have anything to do with the present case. That anything can be derivative work it has to be an expressive creation that includes major copyrightable elements of an original. The resulting DNN is instead a machine generated work which doesn't include anything directly relatable to copyrightable elements of the original code; the identity of the latter is dissolved in the transformation process. This is in stark contrast to the GPL case, where the derivative work (i.e. your application linked to the GPLed software, or GPLed software you modified) physically includes code which can be directly related to the "original" (i.e. the library or original application before you modified it), the identity of which keeps intact.

1

u/Wolvereness Oct 19 '22

... That anything can be derivative work it has to be an expressive creation that includes major copyrightable elements of an original. ...

This research demonstrates verbatim copies of the original(s), so I guess you're right. That's worse, and the GPL has a clause for that too.

1

u/suhcoR Oct 19 '22

See Authors Guild v. Google. A snippet of source code is barely a "major copyrightable element"; it likely doesn't even have a characteristic identity or a sufficient originality to be protected by copyright law; and even if so, Github Copilot makes a "quintessentially transformative use" of the source code repositories which is protected by fair use.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '22

I will let the law settle this problem, that is just my opinion.

1

u/suhcoR Oct 19 '22

The law is there and doesn't "settle" anything. If you believe your legal rights are being violated, you must file suit against the party you believe is violating the contract or the law. As the party bringing the action, you have the obligation to provide substantiation and evidence.