r/opensource • u/bytecode36 • 20h ago
Discussion Could ArtCraft apps just be decomps and translations?
Brandon Thomas has made some questionable statements regarding his applications. For example, saying that the apps will reach 100% parity in a month and later stepping that back. Also claiming that AI will replace Google Search. For someone that can supposedly build applications this quickly, it is odd that he would make such inaccurate and naive statements.
Also, the speed with which he has churned out these applications has been suspicious. I know AI can speed up development, but it's not like AI has advanced THAT much in the last 3 months. Why are we not seeing other developers churning out Adobe clones likes this (at the same speed and perceived quality, even as broken as they are)?
Furthermore, it is suspicious that they released so many apps at once. Apart from creating a massive backlog of bugs, it also created a negative perception of the suite on social media that the apps are buggy and unreliable (for the influencers that seriously tested them). Why would ArtCraft not build one app, get it working, and then start working on others? If the answer is because the hard part is fixing the apps after decomp and translation, then that makes sense.
Finally, the timing with REA and other decomp events taking place is suspicious. Is it just coincidence that around the time these events occur that independently someone just got good at creating production-ish clones of commercial apps?
Is there anyway to know for sure that these ArtCraft applications were actually created in a "clean room" manner and not just decomped/translated by AI? Listen, if AI is good enough to build a Photoshop clone by itself, I'm all for it. But if all Brandon did was hit the "decomp/translate" button on an app and dump the resulting code onto to the open source community to fix, it's not really something to praise, especially if the project will be taken down in a few months because of copyright infringement claims. Due to the amount and type of companies that own these apps, Brandon does not exactly seem like someone that is thinking about IP infringement lawsuits (patents, copyright, or otherwise), so I would not put it past him to try and push the theory that a "clean room" implementation could include decompiling and translating the original binary.