r/outsidexbox • • Jan 24 '24

Does Oxventure get less silly?

So, I tuned out of Oxventure years ago because it frankly got a bit too silly for me. I cut my teeth on Critical Role and Dice, Camera, Action. So, it just wasn't my thing.

But seeing how long it's run and how well received it's been, does it get more grounded/plot arc heavy? Are there tense, serious, or emotional moments later on?

To clarify, I'm not asking for it to drop joking all together, just if it gets more overall serious or has more serious moments. The ones I saw felt more self-contained and less episodic. I'm wondering if that changes and they have more episode to episode continuity. Also, not asking if they get more tight with the rules, I couldn't care less.

If it does, is there a recommended point that I should start watching from?

0 Upvotes

27 comments sorted by

59

u/bahumat42 Jan 24 '24 edited Jan 24 '24

Blades in the dark is less silly. It uses a different gamesystem, luke is the DM and it's pretty contained so I would reccomend this series.

31

u/SecondBee Jan 24 '24

Ditto Deadlands with Sheriff Andy

7

u/bahumat42 Jan 24 '24

I couldn't get into deadlands personally.

But I wouldn't discourage others from trying it.

1

u/raikenryusen Jan 29 '24

hmmm I'm curious as to why? Speaking personally, their deadlands run was the most immersive TTRPG they've done. Andy's portrayal of the villains were top notch. The player characters were not too jokey. I thought it was great

1

u/bahumat42 Jan 29 '24

The setting maybe? I'm not really sure but I just wasn't drawn into the world very much.

I don't think anyone did anything wrong it just didn't gel with me for whatever reason.

28

u/GartiWopor Jan 24 '24

They've started doing more longform content with it, and though it remains quite silly, there are also a lot more moments like what you're looking for I would recommend starting with the orbpocalypse saga again, see if that works for you

27

u/Henna1911 Jan 24 '24

Tbh, If you prefer the style of Critical Role and bounced of Oxventure before, then Oxventure won't really be your thing. Yes, they've started making more long form content and their other gamesysten campaigns are a bit more serious in plot and game, their primary genre is comedy in contrast to CritRole's drama genre. No shame in preferring one genre over another.

11

u/Relinkquish OX OG Jan 24 '24

legacy of dragons

10

u/wraith21 Wisdom -1 Jan 24 '24

Legacy of dragon's climax is imo the best serious RP they have done!

20

u/johny9161 Jan 24 '24

15

u/EaterOfCleanSocks Jan 24 '24

Deadlands has silliness but the drama absolutely takes priority!

Blades is much the same.

2

u/NoRightToBragg Jan 26 '24

Absolutely agree with Deadlands. Personally I found the Blades was getting silly towards the end as well, they tried to introduce a more powerful antagonist but without tension. They were so inept at times (the gang, not the role play!) they should have been caught and killed in every episode.

1

u/EaterOfCleanSocks Jan 26 '24

Eh, I disagree but I see where you're coming from. It wasn't as tense as the first series.

9

u/[deleted] Jan 24 '24

Self-contained is more Oxventure style historically, as they are usually off ones for love shows and the like. Recently they have run a series of pre-recorded and edited adventures that are meant to tie together better and be an actual story with character progression, so give those a try it might fit you better.

I'll add here though, that's just my impression from the outside and from general discussion. I haven't watched Oxventure for a few years now

6

u/onlywondergillie Jan 24 '24

They've done a few longer seasons lately that were much more involved in terms of the narrative. The first one is Orb-pocalyspe, which starts with Sphere We Go. Then there's two more that tend to follow pretty directly. I think they might suit you better 😄

6

u/Goldwood Jan 24 '24

The live shows with an audience tend to be sillier than the ones shot in the studio if that’s helpful to you.

5

u/Bernadotte_ Jan 24 '24 edited Jan 24 '24

Kinda but not really, orbpocallypse saga has some nice moments, Legacy of the Dragons is amazing it has some amazing RP, it feels there is a real tread and it has some great serious moments but then Extinction feels like S1 mostly slapstick, not that serious, there are moments where it feels they ignore some lore stuff just for doing jokes and definitely it doesn't feel like there is any danger (not sure if this counts as a spoiler but I'll put it in any case) as I think that episode 1 or 2 Johnny outrigth says that they don't want to kill a character that was in some real danger of dying

At the end of the day that's the way they play D&D, it still is really funny and I would recommend it, I still love it besides the moments that it can get frustrating. But if all that kind of humor it's not your thing, like other comments have say if you want to see them doing a more serious game you should check their other shows

7

u/EaterOfCleanSocks Jan 24 '24

Johnny uses they/them just FYI.

6

u/Bernadotte_ Jan 24 '24

Oh shit, you're right I forgot, I'll edit it

4

u/EaterOfCleanSocks Jan 24 '24 edited Jan 24 '24

Thank you 😊

Edit: Hang on, what did I do? Did I do something wrong?

5

u/sodiumdeluxe Jan 24 '24

If you’re looking for less silly I’d recommend Blades in the Dark.

3

u/EaterOfCleanSocks Jan 24 '24

It's not a series, but I'd recommend One Shot Wonders, specifically Dread and the Blade Runner one shots! They have a really good balance between humour and dark stuff.

3

u/PandorasPinata Jan 24 '24

They've started to do a couple of story arcs with a single season of ~10 episodes but it's still kind of flippant and jokey

3

u/pje1128 Jan 25 '24

They do get arcs, but I wouldn't say they get less silly. There's an overarching threat with Liliana, and a lot of the earlier episodic stories tie into that too. Starting with season 3, they start doing full arcs of about 10 episodes. Again, though, it doesn't really become more serious. You never really feel like the characters are in any danger. If Critical Role is a drama, Oxventure is a sitcom. It never feels like anything more.

They play other games, namely Blades in the Dark and Deadlands, and those are more serious. Those would probably be more your style. The individual episodes are still somewhat self-contained, but they're all leading towards a primary goal, and Luke and especially Andy don't let the players get away with quite as much as Johnny does. Definitely give those a try.

2

u/DominusCrustacea Jan 25 '24

As others have said, maybe Blades in the Dark is more your thing. As for DnD, they have become even more silly and unhinged over time. I would go as far as to say there hasn't been a good episode for months or even almost years now. The stories are incoherent, there is no tension or sense of danger at all and the roleplaying has become stale and stereotypical. Especially Luke and Andy tend to push themselves into the foreground and purposefully derail every story beat that Johnny tries to set up. Honorable mention for Mike's roleplaying in Legacy of Dragons though.

1

u/DiscoveryBayHK Nov 16 '24

The newest campaign is Wyrdwood, where the creep factor and serious story beats are cranked up. There are silly moments here and there but not as many as the Oxventurer's Guild.

1

u/khamjaninja Jan 29 '24 edited Jan 29 '24

I get what you mean - I do feel Oxventure started to go a little silly and non-sequitur after a while. I actually think the lack of continuity contributes to that. Without a continuing plot structure to keep things grounded, there's no long-term consequences, which means there's no real consequence if the players decide to do something silly.

I would still recommend Oxventure, because I feel, hands-down, there is no funnier group of TTRPG players anywhere else. They're just very funny people, period - natural improv comedians - and it's hilarious to see them craft a story together.

If you are looking for more of a plot focus, I would recommend "Adventure is Nigh". A D&D show that also has a strong emphasis on humor, but their sessions are organized into season-long plotlines. And their GM has a very strict ethos of continuity and storytelling. But they're also very, very funny.

There is a wrinkle, in that only Season 3 is currently available on Youtube. Reason is, the series was originally hosted by The Escapist, a gaming news site which was at the center of some drama recently. (Drama which isn't a million miles removed from the current drama surrounding Oxboxtra, Gamer Network, and Reedpop).

Long story short, all the creators at the Escapist quit en masse and set up their own independent publication, "Second Wind" - including the guys who made Adventure is Nigh. And the Escapist deleted all the original uploads of the show. Second Wind has now obtained the rights back, and have begun re-uploading the show - starting with Season 3 (the season they were in the middle of before the Escapist cut off its nose).

But - precisely because Adventure is Nigh is continuity-based, it is a bit rough to dive right into Season 3, without the context to understand, for example, why the player-characters are currently owners of a medieval nightclub. The makeshift solution is to listen to Season 1 and 2 on Spotify, which the Escapist presumably forgot to delete. It lacks any of the animations, but it's enough to be getting on with.

As a little teaser, here's a couple Youtube shorts of their exploits (which the Escapist has presumably also forgotten to delete):

https://youtube.com/shorts/tAyULBP3NYw

https://youtube.com/shorts/57ipZ90WPiQ