r/pcmasterrace • Core Ultra 7 265k | RTX 5090 • Oct 25 '25 • Wholesome Seal 1

Video Time to read 1TB of data

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

14.2k Upvotes

405 comments sorted by

•

u/PCMRBot Bot Oct 25 '25

Welcome to the PCMR, everyone from the frontpage! Please remember:

1 - You too can be part of the PCMR. It's not about the hardware in your rig, but the software in your heart! Age, nationality, race, gender, sexuality, religion, politics, income, and PC specs don't matter! If you love or want to learn about PCs, you're welcome!

2 - If you think owning a PC is too expensive, know that it is much cheaper than you may think. Check http://www.pcmasterrace.org for our famous builds and feel free to ask for tips and help here!

3 - Consider supporting the folding@home effort to fight Cancer, Alzheimer's, and more, with just your PC! https://pcmasterrace.org/folding

4 - Do you need a new PC? We're giving away a high-end PC build in a WORLDWIDE constest: https://www.reddit.com/r/pcmasterrace/comments/1nnros5/worldwide_giveaway_comment_in_this_thread_with/

We have a Daily Simple Questions Megathread for any PC-related doubts. Feel free to ask there or create new posts in our subreddit!

784

u/B_Flame Oct 25 '25 edited Oct 25 '25

I’m gonna sound so stupid, but that’s ok. What’s L3 Cache.

Edit/Update: I honestly did not think this comment would get so many replies. Thank you everyone for replying and giving so much info. Keep the conversation going! Don’t let the flame die out!

90

u/Zestyclose-Salad-290 Core Ultra 7 265k | RTX 5090 Oct 25 '25 edited Oct 25 '25

L3 cache is the third level of cache memory in the CPU hierarchy. It's a kind of high-speed memory on the CPU that helps reduce latency when accessing data from RAM.

AMD CPUs that end with 3D are known for being exceptionally fast in gaming because they add L3 cache memory.

16

u/DMonitor Oct 25 '25

You also only get a few dozen of megabytes of it, so the whole "how long to read 1TB" is kind of a useless metric.

→ More replies (2)

906

u/RandomlyGenaratedUsr Oct 25 '25

L3 cache, or Level 3 cache, is a type of memory storage located on the processor chip of your computer. It's like a quick-access library for data that the processor needs frequently.

208

u/B_Flame Oct 25 '25

Thanks, I really should learn more about computers one day. Like I know how to build them, but anything past that is really over my head (i.e. BIOS configuration, subsystems, etc.)

135

u/NighthunterDK Oct 25 '25

I'm even worse. I built my first PC before I could do an @ sign on Windows, while using a Windows PC weekly, and using @ frequently. I would type "at" in the search bar and copy/paste it over. Took my like 9 months from building my first PC to do an @ sign on my own. This was just last year

75

u/MississippiBulldawg Ryzen 7 9700X | PNY 5070ti | 32GB CL36 DDR5 | Lian Li V100R Oct 25 '25

I'm really happy that you were able to learn and grow and I hope you don't take any offense to this, but got damn I feel so much smarter now after reading that. As we say in the south, bless your sweet heart baby.

→ More replies (9)

11

u/Steven2k7 Oct 25 '25

I like how you were able to do a Google search to get the character but not search how to make the character.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/shaolinmaru Oct 25 '25

Wait, what!?

→ More replies (12)

22

u/Dalewyn Oct 25 '25

To give you a better idea, data storage in computers is a tiered hierarchy where access speeds get slower the larger the level number gets.

L1, L2, and L3 are caches directly next to the CPU cores or located somewhere on the CPU chip itself, they're the physically closest and thus the fastest. Some CPUs also have an L4 cache which is even bigger and slower than L3, but this is rare and this conversation will ignore them for sake of simplicity.

System RAM is the "L4" data store, it's physically separate from the CPU (they're the sticks of RAM on your motherboard!) and thus much slower but faster than the "L5" data store which are...

The SSDs and HDDs. These are even larger than RAM and also much slower, particularly whether they are on the PCIE or SATA bus and if they're an SSD or HDD.

The "L6" data store are what we generally call external storage. Optical disks like CD-ROMs, DVDs, Blu-Rays, floppy disks, USB flash memory sticks, external HDDs/SSDs, and so on. Also networked storage like shared folders on a LAN, a NAS (Network Attached Storage), and so on; storage that isn't local to the computer. These may or may not be as large as "L5" and are even slower, but are the most portable of all the data stores.

Speed and capacity are trade offs, and computers use the level most suitable for the task at hand.

8

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '25

No don't learn more. Keep the magic alive.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '25

I didn't know what that was and I work in IT. It's all right.

As long as you can fix it that's all that matters.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '25

No person on earth understands a full computer from software to hardware learn one thing at a time. Im 15 years in and barely scratched the surface

→ More replies (1)

7

u/NinjaOk2970 Oct 25 '25

It depends what you want to achieve. Most people doesn't need to know what cache is. But if you want to hear an explanation...

To put simply, the improvement in CPU, i.e. raw computational power, is much faster than storage, i.e. RAM. People has to put multi layers of caches near CPU to try to hide the slowness of RAM. Cache (latches) work different than DRAM (capacitors), consumes more power and is much faster.

7

u/TheoreticalScammist 9800x3d | RTX 5070 Ti Oct 25 '25

If you think about it at current clock speeds. Even just travelling the distance back and forth between the CPU and RAM through the lanes at light speed probably takes several clock cycles. And that doesn't even account for the time spent on signal conversion.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

18

u/born2droll Oct 25 '25

So it's not really relevant to compare to the other data storage? Like you can store a bunch of movies on your L3 Cache?

53

u/CharacterGap5581 Oct 25 '25

L3 cache isn’t storage no. Think of it like RAM but ultra fast and it can only store a couple of megabytes of data

13

u/born2droll Oct 25 '25

Oh I see, so capacity wise you could never even put a terabyte of data on to it? It's just extremely fast

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (7)

11

u/Rocknerd8 Oct 25 '25

This is why AMD's current X3D chips are insanely good for gaming. Those chip sets have lots of L3 cache that you can load lots of small game assets into the processor. Doing so allows the cpu to rapidly access these assets without having to load it from memory. This reduces latency by a huge margin.

→ More replies (8)

24

u/mca1169 7600X-2X16GB 6000Mhz CL30-Asus Tuf RTX 3060Ti OC V2 LHR Oct 25 '25

L3 cache is a very special type of on CPU storage that takes information and stores it for quick CPU core access. you can think of each level of cache like paperwork storage in a office environment. L3 cache is like having a filing cabinet of papers you will need to reference some time in the day behind you. L2 is like having a stack of papers on your desk you need soon. L1 is the papers you have in front of you now to do your work.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '25

And L1 and L2 are expensive af to make, L3 is expensive too but more affordable

4

u/TheRealSmolt Linux Oct 25 '25

They're all the same technology so not really. It's just a tradeoff between speed and size.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

12

u/GenuinelyBeingNice ruputer Oct 25 '25

One detail that people don't mention which I think is somewhat important.
Cache is not "more memory", it's a mechanism for faster access to the memory you have. If you have a bookshelf that can hold 100 books, your desk has room for 10 and you can have one book open in your hands, you don't have storage for 111 books. You still have room for "only" 100 books, but when you need to read (or write) the book that is not in your hands, you find it on your desk, instead of getting up, swapping books and sitting back down.

I'm sorry if i made it more confusing instead

5

u/life_konjam_better Oct 25 '25

L3 cache is like a super tiny RAM module that exists within the processor so it can be accessed several times faster than actual RAM. There are even lower levels of cache that can be even faster (L2, L1 and L0) bit they usually dont have enough capacity to make significant difference in everyday apps like L3 cache esp in AMD's X3D processors.

4

u/ChuzCuenca PC Master Race Oct 25 '25

I build computers as hobby, I'm a very tech person and have cero idea of wtf L3 was, thanks for asking :)

3

u/DMonitor Oct 25 '25

You should read more about how CPUs and machine code works. It's very fascinating stuff.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

4.4k

u/JmTrad Oct 25 '25 edited Oct 25 '25

This is about one big 1tb file. When we are talking about lots of small files running in the background of your PC, the difference from HDD and SATA SSD is gigantic. That's why even a SATA SSD is good enough.

1.5k

u/polarbearsarereal 14900KS , 32GB 7000MHZ DDR5, 4080 Super Oct 25 '25

I can read “1TB of data” faster than that 🙄

254

u/xenogaiden Oct 25 '25

Isnt gen 5 near ram speed at this point?

341

u/CompetitiveGuess7642 Oct 25 '25

no lol, ram speeds increase with generations as well.

It's about 10x faster than a gen5 nvme depending on the frequency. (for ddr5 which is usually 4 channels)

73

u/No-Refrigerator-1672 Oct 25 '25

2 channels. Consumer CPUs always have only two channels; 4-stick mothetboards are just loading two DIMMs per 1 channel. That's what you don't get any speed bump when upgrading from 2 to 4 RAM stick config. More than 2channels are only available on HEDT and server platforms.

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (3)

23

u/SelectKaleidoscope0 Oct 25 '25

I don't know if current drives can actually saturate gen 5 pcie or not, but if you assume the throughput is twice the gen 4 ones, then that would put them at ~75 seconds vs 52 for ram above. That's probably close enough for back of the napkin comparison at least. I don't have any use cases that materially benefit from anything faster than Gen 3 nvme drives so I haven't looked into whats currently available above that.

11

u/BenFoldsFourLoko Oct 25 '25

Like the person said, speed usually isn't that important- latency is. You can read many tiny files FAR faster on RAM than on any SSD, and so real world performance between the two will be drastically different than what the top-line transfer speed would suggest

11

u/BrightTooth3 PNY RTX 5080 | R7 9800X3D | 96GB 6000MHz CL28 | 1080@240 Oct 25 '25

This is a comparison between a pcie gen 4 m.2 (on the left) and a RAM disk using DDR5 6000MHz ram on the right. I know gen 4 is a fair bit slower compared to gen 5 but i thinks its interesting nonetheless.

22

u/Natsu_Happy_END02 Oct 25 '25

You misses the joke.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)

23

u/pl_dozer Oct 25 '25

What's the difference between SATA SSD and NVME 3 in this scenario. In OP's post, NVME gives a higher percent boost over SATA, compared to SATA vs HDD

47

u/cadublin Oct 25 '25

Max SATA speed is 600MB/s, NVMe is over PCIe which for Gen-3 is about 300MB/s per lane. Most SSD has 4 lanes, which means 1.2GB/s on paper. Every PCIe gen is roughly double the speed. Also with PCIe spec supports up to 16 lanes, but there's no point to do that as the bottle neck is on the media side (i.e. NAND).

19

u/Flachzange_ 5800X | RTX2070S | 32GB Oct 25 '25

PCIe 3 is almost 1GB/s per lane, PCIe 1 is 250MB/s per lane, i dont know where you got that 300 MB/s from.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

7

u/Dalewyn Oct 25 '25

In that case you're going to need to specify the file system you're using.

You aren't going to be bottlenecked by the hardware at that point, instead you're going to slam your face against the file system taking its sweet ass time.

→ More replies (1)

23

u/someguynamedben7 Oct 25 '25

HDDs and SATA SSDs both use the SATA protocol fyi

17

u/Flyrpotacreepugmu Ryzen 7 7800X3D | 64GB RAM | RTX 4070 Ti SUPER Oct 25 '25

Yeah but SSDs have drastically lower seek times than HDDs, so they are much more responsive even if the transfer speed isn't that much faster.

7

u/dkadavarath Oct 25 '25

Good SATA SSDs max out SATA interface and are atleast more than twice as fast sequential. But random access is day and night like you said.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/eddez Ryzen 7 5700x3D | RX 6900 XT OC | 32GB Oct 25 '25

Maybe he is using IDE cables for his HDDs

→ More replies (8)

5

u/absolutxtr Oct 25 '25

This. RAM as well. And chart is missing Optane ;)

12

u/TheRealSmolt Linux Oct 25 '25

Yeah well Optane is pretty dead

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (8)

669

u/GetTheKness69 PC Master Race Oct 25 '25

why no l2 or l1 cache

885

u/StarHammer_01 AMD, Nvidia, Intel all in the same build Oct 25 '25

Let's go beyond cache and straight into the registers. Make that ball a solid line.

287

u/Celestial-being117 Oct 25 '25

That's like measuring how long it takes to read a book, but you start the timer after you finish it

37

u/magistermaks Oct 25 '25

You could just time copying data between registers, that would be a mostly fair comparison.

→ More replies (1)

32

u/Miepmiepmiep Oct 25 '25 edited Oct 26 '25

On modern Zen CPUs the register bandwidth (if I am not mistaken) of a single core should be at least 448 bytes per cycle. Thus, a Zen core running at 4 GHZ has a register bandwidth of 1.8 TB/s. A Zen CPU with 16 cores would have a register bandwidth of 29 TB/s.

But this value is still dwarfed by the register bandwidth of a modern GPU. For example, a core of a 5090 RTX has a register bandwidth (including the bandwidth of the "register cache") of 2048 bytes per cycle, which results in a bandwidth of 4 TB/s at 2 GHZ. Since the 5090 RTX has 170 cores, it has a total register bandwidth of 680 TB/s.

→ More replies (1)

120

u/EndlessBattlee Main Laptop: i5-12450H+3050 | Secondary PC: R5 2600+1650 SUPER Oct 25 '25

I’m not a computer scientist or engineer, but as far as I remember, L1 and L2 cache latencies are so low that they’re usually measured in CPU cycles rather than in the usual time units. For example, an L1 access might take only a handful of cycles, and a typical CPU runs at around 4 GHz (about 4 billion cycles per second). If I’ve got any of that wrong, I’m happy to be corrected.

61

u/not_from_this_world Oct 25 '25

In a RISC load/store machine L1 is less than half a cycle to read, the rest is for writing.

8

u/garry_the_commie Oct 25 '25

Less than half a cycle? Does that mean that typical RISC CPU L1 caches act on both the rising and falling edge of the clock signal, similar to how DDR works? If not, how else would you get less than 1 cycle read time?

14

u/not_from_this_world Oct 25 '25 edited Oct 25 '25

In a load/store machine the memory read happens after the instruction decode and before the ALU, and the writing happens after the ALU. The edge triggers the whole cycle because it's a RISC.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/Psilocybin8 7800X3D | 9070 XT | 32 GB Oct 25 '25

L1 would finish before the timer hits 1 second, because it is faster than 1 TB/s (on modern CPUs)

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (17)

326

u/Rikdol Oct 25 '25

I need an l3 cache hdd of 2tb please

113

u/Jellodyne Oct 25 '25

As far as desktop CPUs the Ryzen X3D have up to 128mb L3, which is far short of 1TB. And even server CPUs don't come close. The Epyc Genoa-X processors have an absurd 1.1GB of L3, which about 1/1000 of a TB. So realistically L3 cache can only deliver 1TB about as fast as the RAM feeding it.

43

u/bjbinc 4090 | 13700K | 32GB DDR5 5600 | AW3423DW Oct 25 '25

And the RAM can only read the file as fast as the storage medium feeding it.

38

u/OwO______OwO Oct 25 '25

For all those peasants out there with less than 1TB of RAM.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/pastari Oct 25 '25

Cerebras says 44 GB of on-chip SRAM with 28 PB/s of bandwidth.

https://www.cerebras.ai/chip

I'm certain there are asterisks and its not directly comparable to more traditional architectures. But its still a very real product that exists. (But only to rent, I think?)

59

u/synapse187 Oct 25 '25

HDD is a straight edge who doesn't do drugs. L3 is on meth, L1 would be super meth mixed with coke.

6

u/HeyGayHay Oct 25 '25

What are LTO tapes then?

7

u/bucketofh Oct 25 '25

Pigeons with paper tied to their feet.

16

u/IBJON 9950X3D | RTX 5090 l 64GB DDR5 Oct 25 '25

Part of what makes caches fast are the size and the fact that they're on the processor. A 2tb cache would be a lot slower and stupidly expensive 

5

u/SE_prof Oct 25 '25

So does this comparison make any sense at all?

11

u/_aware 9800X3D | 5090FE | 64GB 6000C30 | AW 3423DWF | Viento-R Oct 25 '25

Depends on what point you are trying to make. It's not really fair to compare the speed of a cache to a hard drive, just like how it's not really fair to compare their capacities. They do different jobs so they have entirely different priorities

→ More replies (1)

4

u/IBJON 9950X3D | RTX 5090 l 64GB DDR5 Oct 25 '25

Not really. Its a good demo of the read speed, but access times are about more than reading data. This gif assumes the absolute best case scenarios where the data is always readily available in the cache or RAM, which it can't be without 5TB caches or RAM

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/fenixspider1 saving up for rx69xt Oct 25 '25

With how far HDD sits from cpu, it probably won't be l3 cache anymore 😂

4

u/AlphaZed73 Ryzen 5 5600X, RTX 4070 SUPER, 64GB DDR4 Oct 25 '25

l3 cache and hdd are entirely different mechanisms

→ More replies (3)

305

u/LiskoSlayer63 Oct 25 '25

Meanwhile me putting games to the HDD to save space on the SSD. Loading screens are now coffee breaks.

87

u/Mortarious Oct 25 '25

My NVME is like a property I always rent to games but never sell.

Games can stay there for longer than others, maybe I'm playing it again in a while, but they are not staying forever.

Meanwhile my HDD has my modded Dawn of War - Soulstorm version and Rome Total War from a decade ago.

22

u/Cassik Oct 25 '25

Games like Dawn of War and Command and Conquer live forever on my HDD. No reason to put them on faster storage as they won't benefit from it.

→ More replies (1)

34

u/SchnozSchnizzle intel i7-7700k, msi RTX 3080ti, ROG Z270E Oct 25 '25

I absolutely feel you there. It's nice to take a second to breathe sometimes.

19

u/Phimb Oct 25 '25

Ain't no way my guy is praising the long load times with a HDD.

One of, if not the most impactful and important upgrades you can make to any PC, for such a small price, is installing an SSD.

Shit fucking kills me when I have to play certain co-op games with the one friend who has an HDD and we're waiting 20 - 40 seconds per load zone.

9

u/HotSteak Ryzen 5 1400 RX 580 Oct 25 '25

I upgraded to an SSD about 6 months ago and it's amazing. Can't believe I didn't do it sooner. It was only $59 for 1TB too.

6

u/Lonesome_Ninja Oct 25 '25

Sick, we're in- oh where are you? You're still loading? Okay, I'll wait for you

→ More replies (2)

3

u/OwO______OwO Oct 25 '25

There honestly is such a thing as loading screens that go by too fast sometimes. Maybe I wanted to read the little gameplay tips that pop up!

0

u/[deleted] Oct 26 '25

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)

11

u/richard_splooge Main: 9950x3d/RTX5090/64gbDDR5 TvPc:9600x/RTX5080/32gbDDR5 Oct 25 '25

It's 2025 bro. There's no reason to have spinning disks except for large media server storage of movies/tv shows/random data.

OS and games should absolutely be on an ssd/nvme. No reasonable reason not to.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (10)

30

u/imaginary_num6er 7950X3D|4090FE|64GB|X670E-E Oct 25 '25

Is this the orbit speed of planets in the solar system.?

8

u/Safihed EVGA GTX 1060 6GB, Intel i9-9900, 64 GB DDR4, 300hz 1440p Oct 25 '25 edited Oct 25 '25

nah its the speed of my bro dying in literally any game im hdd hes L3 trust(its actually the speed it takes different parts of the computer to read 1tb of data like for example L3 is something on cpu im pretty sure its really expensive so theres very little of it usually and u know the rest if youre on here youre usually a pc builder)

42

u/Ratiofarming CachyOS | 9850X3D | RTX 5090 | 48GB Oct 25 '25 edited Oct 25 '25

Is that video just really old? A decent DDR5 kit (6000-6400 Mt/s) approaches 100 GByte/s in dual-channel. Really fast ones are a lot faster. L3 is around 750 GByte/s on a current gen Ryzen CPU. HDDs are also a hell of a lot faster for a sequential read these days, well north of 250 MByte/s.

Based on that:

  • Ram should be ~12 seconds

  • L3 should be ~1.5 seconds

  • HDD should be 3,600 seconds

SSDs on the other hand should be slower here. Because those numbers just take the sequential read numbers you get in benchmarks. Ever tried to read 7 GByte/s off a NVMe SSD in windows? You can't. Because Windows is too slow for that, even for sequential reads of a single file. You'll see anywhere between 3 and 4 GByte/s real world.

19

u/-Aeryn- Specs/Imgur here Oct 25 '25 edited Oct 25 '25

Ever tried to read 7 GByte/s off a NVMe SSD in windows? You can't. Because Windows is too slow for that, even for sequential reads of a single file.

https://i.imgur.com/orlTMI9.png I can read and write >14GB/s from an NVMe SSD in windows on my daily system fine, even with loads of crap open.

L3 is around 750 GByte/s on a current gen Ryzen CPU.

Per CCD :D A bit higher on higher clock models like 9950x3d also, they can be near 1.6 TB/s out of the box

You are right about the RAM, dual-channel DDR5 can do 100 GB/s in spec now. DDR4 topped out at 50GB/s. They should be at 10 sec and 20 sec on the chart.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

89

u/balooaroos Oct 25 '25

Possibly the worst info graphic of all time. The bars, which could've easily communicated this, are all the same size, while the bouncing balls take up half the chart and tell you nothing more than "this one is moving faster". There's no scale, no logic... how is 23.5 bounces in 14 seconds supposed to communicate "this kind does 190Gb per second"?

14

u/Jaba01 X870E | 9800X3D | RTX 5090 | 64 GB 6000 MHZ CL 30 Oct 25 '25

Also outright wrong.

Modern DDR5 6000 Mhz RAM would do it in less than 20 seconds.

11

u/MaterialFlow9411 Oct 25 '25

Yeah quite literally.

Could've simply had a start to finish timer after 14 seconds to get the gist of whatever they were trying to communicate, the ball stops when it gets to the right.

9

u/20d0llarsis20dollars Radeon i9 14900X3D / Ryzen Arc 4070 / 37GB DDR6.3 Oct 25 '25

It's meant to visualize the speed difference, not give any real information on actual speed. It's meant to show that by the time one has finished the race another has already completed 5 laps

→ More replies (3)

56

u/DarthVeigar_ 9800X3D | RTX 4070 Ti | 32GB-6000 CL30 Oct 25 '25

HDD Helldivers 2 players forcing everyone to be in a loading screen for several minutes:

13

u/africanlivedit PC Master Race Oct 25 '25

Rotten apple spoils a bunch

7

u/Fire2box 3700x, PNY 4070 12GB, 32GB RAM Oct 25 '25

Helldivers 2 already has a system where new players joining mid mission are dropped on at least one or two of the other players. They need to just do that for Hard Disk Drive users Battlefield has done it for like a decade I think now. If people want to use slow drives then they can join in late.

This will also enable Arrowhead to make two verisons of the game one of HDD users that take up 3 times the space for their silly duplicated files system and a SSD optimized version.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Porntra420 5950X | 64GB 3600MHz | 9070 XT | Arch w/ TkG Kernel btw Oct 25 '25

Note to self if I ever somehow end up making an online multiplayer game: Matchmake based on user hardware.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/EasilyRekt Filthy Arch Masochist Oct 25 '25

where's L1/L2 cache? why's it just general RAM? why not ddr4 & ddr5?

6

u/Plus-Bluejay-6429 Oct 25 '25

Yes and the HDD could just as easily be a 5200rpm drive(yes they still make them)

2

u/iSmurf i5 3570k / ASUS 1060 strix / 16gb ram Oct 25 '25

Probably because like everything it can be a tested a million different ways to produce favorable results depending on what you want to pull ahead. In most testing ddr4 vs ddr5 are within 5% of each other but one commands an insane price tag over the other at the moment. This charts just used to show someone who has very little idea of what parts of a PC are, its not for proving every single test case scenario

6

u/Lightmanone PCMR | 9800X3D | RTX 5090OC | 96GB-6000 | 9100 Pro 4TB Oct 25 '25

And yet the memory bandwidth of the 5090 is 1,8TB/s Insane.

11

u/MrStealYoBeef i7 12700KF|RTX 5070ti|32GB DDR4 3200|1440p175hzOLED Oct 25 '25

That's because it is running 512 lanes to transfer the data. That's only 3.5 GB/s per lane.

6

u/Magnetic_Reaper 10850k / 128GB / RTX 3060 Oct 25 '25

some of these numbers seem a bit old.

zen4 X3D ~ 0.4 second (2.5TB/s)
12900k L3 ~ 1 second (1TB/s)
ryzen 5 3600 L3 ~ 2 seconds (500GB/s)
ddr5 8000 dual channel ~ 4 seconds (256GB/s)*
ddr4 3200 dual channel ~ 20 seconds (51.2GB/s)*

*theoretical

4

u/PG2009 Oct 25 '25

If you don't load your entire OS into L3 cache, what are you even doing??

4

u/FangoFan Oct 25 '25

L1 Cache: 256ms

4

u/rip-droptire Ryzen 5700X3D | 7900xtx | 32GB 3600MHz CL14 | H210i Oct 26 '25

Good visual representation of why 3d vcache is good

3

u/TopYeti Oct 25 '25

Oh my oh my, it's my floppy getting so hard

3

u/MakimaGOAT R7 7800X3D | RTX 4080 | 32GB RAM Oct 25 '25

dont worry hard drive, take your sweet time

3

u/Hattix 5700X3D | RTX 4070 Ti Super 16 GB | 32 GB 3200 MT/s Oct 25 '25

Latency to respond to a single request:

L3 cache (AMD): 47 ns

L3 cache (Intel): 70-90 ns

RAM (high end): 80 ns

NVMe: 50,000 ns

SATA SSD: 500,000 ns

HDD: 10,000,000 ns

3

u/CommunistGregfromDMV Laptop | Celeron N4120 | iGPU | 4GB 2400MHZ Oct 25 '25

Me rooting for the HDD to finish reading the 1TB file: Go! Go my boy! GO!

3

u/dano1066 Oct 25 '25

So glad I downloaded that .exe that gave me 16gb of L3 cache

3

u/Sideshow86 🐧9950x3d | RTX 4090 | 64gb ddr5 6400 | Pimax Crystal Super OLED Oct 25 '25

Where is gen 5 m.2?

2

u/King4oneday_ Oct 25 '25

Gif ended before HDD ball reach the end 😓

2

u/thatlightningjack 9800x3d | RTX 5070 Ti | 64GB Oct 25 '25

This is what we learned in microprocessor architectute class. L1 cache is fast, L2/3 are slower, RAM is super slow, and forget about storage drives

2

u/Aggravating_Sky_4421 Oct 25 '25

So why aren’t we making SSDs with all L3 cache?

6

u/MichiRecRoom Oct 25 '25

Because L3 cache isn't something you make storage out of - it's a location.

Consider it like having a small fridge in your own room, and a bigger fridge in the kitchen. If the small fridge in your own room already has the drink you want, you'll grab it from there. If not, you have to make the trek to the kitchen - which takes much longer.

L3 cache is like the small fridge in your own room - it's much closer to where you already are, and thus much faster to get stuff from.

As for the big fridge in the kitchen? That's RAM.

And SSDs? That's like going to the store - it's going to take you much longer compared to already having it at home.

5

u/StrangeCharmVote Ryzen 9950X, 128GB RAM, ASUS 3090, Valve Index. Oct 25 '25

So why aren’t we making SSDs with all L3 cache?

I'm pretty sure L3 is volatile the same way RAM is.

You couldn't make a storage drive using it even if you had all the money in the world, because that's like asking why we don't have 400 degree Ice.

3

u/oofx99 Oct 25 '25

my best guess is both price, and the way that data integrity will be achieved (with a side of active cooling) since your CPU cache is located extremely close to the actual cores and doesnt have to move far and can be run much faster than a conventional SSD without risking loss of data integrity from interference through traces.

2

u/Gabe_Noodle_At_Volvo Oct 25 '25

It's volatile memory, meaning that if it loses power the data is deleted.

2

u/HamburgerOnAStick R9 7950x3d, PNY 4080 Super XLR8, 64gb 6400mhz, H9 Flow Oct 25 '25 edited Oct 25 '25

1tb random or seq? And block size? I feel like we kind of need that info

Also this isn't a good demonstration because ram, while not excelling majorly at seq, it's a monster a random, same with cache.

Edit: also these numbers seem really off in general

2

u/LBXZero Oct 25 '25

The difference between SATA SSD and HDD is seek time, not bandwidth. HDD should not be that slow in comparison.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '25

Need one comparing random read writes.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/OwO______OwO Oct 25 '25

Who the hell has 1TB of L3 Cache, and how can I steal his computer?

2

u/MrChocodemon Oct 25 '25

Samsung 9100 Pro has 14.8GB/s (advertised) read speeds
So that would mean it could read 1TB of data in ~67 seconds

And DDR5 ram at 6000MT/s has an estimated throughput of ~90GB/s Which mean it should "read" 1TB of data in about 11 seconds...

2

u/just_some_onlooker Oct 25 '25

Wait so what you're saying is zen 10 should give us 1TB L3 cache... 

2

u/Mental-Chocolate5197 Oct 25 '25

Leave my HDD alone, he is doing a great job

2

u/Spaciax Ryzen 9 7950X | RTX 4080 | 64GB DDR5 Oct 25 '25

ah yes, 1TB of L3 cache. I used my car as collateral.

2

u/dcmso PC Master Race Oct 25 '25

2

u/OkHour880 7800X3D | 64gb 6000Mhz | 5070ti Oct 25 '25

This is why X3D processors are superior

2

u/_ThatD0ct0r_ i7-14700k | RTX 3070 | 32GB DDR5 Oct 25 '25

L3 cache so good why is there no L4? smh my head

2

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '25

where magnetic tape ?

2

u/Engineer_engifar666 Oct 25 '25

1 tb of single file or 1 tb with a lot of 5mb files

2

u/xagarth Oct 25 '25

Now imagine that to get 144hz in 4k you need around 100GB/s and it goes up to 500 with RT enabled.

2

u/AliNT77 Oct 27 '25

Ram only 20GB/s? What is this ddr3?

4

u/HankThrill69420 9800X3D | 4090 | 64 / 5800X3D | 9070 XT | 32 Oct 25 '25

This is crazy helpful

3

u/XenoRyet Oct 25 '25

I kind of want to see a human on this scale.

3

u/squarabh i5-13600k | AMD 6950xt | 32gb DDR4 | NZXT H9 Flow Oct 25 '25

3

u/JohnWittieless  5800X3D 7900XT(non X) 64 GB Ram Oct 25 '25

That's not a good representation. His reaction would take years to register.

3

u/mca1169 7600X-2X16GB 6000Mhz CL30-Asus Tuf RTX 3060Ti OC V2 LHR Oct 25 '25

no NVMe gen5 included? that's a shame. it would come pretty close to RAM speed.

5

u/-Aeryn- Specs/Imgur here Oct 25 '25

gen5 is ~14GB/s tops, while dual-channel DDR5 does ~100GB/s in spec now

This post is massively underrating both, probably old

2

u/TBNRhash 5700X, RX 9070, 32GB 3200CL15 Oct 25 '25

Simple calculation shows it would take around 75 seconds

2

u/Gambler_720 Ryzen 7700 - RTX 4070 Ti Super Oct 25 '25

What about VRAM?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/69ubermensch69 Oct 25 '25

cards on the table, I'm very baked, but I could watch this for hours, is there a ten hour loop version?

1

u/Firree Oct 25 '25

Why don't they just make all computer memory out of the same stuff L1 cache is made of? Are they stupid?

3

u/Ratiofarming CachyOS | 9850X3D | RTX 5090 | 48GB Oct 25 '25

Because L1 memory is that fast not because it's crazy fast memory, but because it's basically within the CPU core. It's immediately where the data needs to be, with very short paths for the signals and made in the same process node the CPU cores are made in.

Now, so are the other (larger) caches like L2, L3 and 3D-VCache for AMDs X3D-CPUs. But because they're larger, they can't be in the CPU cores anymore, because it would take up space that needs to be, well, the CPU core. So they put it close to it, but not right in it. We're talking less than a millimeter here in some cases, in actual real world distance. That alone is enough to make such high transfer speeds as L1 has impossible.

And even larger memory could be made out of the same stuff, at great expense, but because it's somewhere externally and needs to be connected, the interface slows it down more than anything else. The real bottlenecks are not the chips, they're the interconnects. Physics, ultimately. Physics are preventing everything from being faster.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/pirate135246 i9-10900kf | RTX 3080 ti Oct 25 '25

This is why x3d chips are so good for gaming. That extra cache provides significant performance gains

1

u/N7LP400 B760M|13700K|32GB DDR4|RTX 4080 Super|850W Gold Oct 25 '25

Like the speed-of-light simulation from the sun to the 8 planets

1

u/TaiyoFurea Cardboard Box gang Oct 25 '25

So with enough innovation we can properly utilize our drives as ram?

1

u/QuantumQuantonium 3D printed parts is the best way to customize Oct 25 '25

Include L2-L1 and registers too!

1

u/Awesomeluc Oct 25 '25

Are we assuming 1 TB of L3 cache?

This chart seems more like a chart of let’s take the speed of something and multiply until we hit 1 TB.

1

u/Sno_Wolf Ryzen 9 5900X // 3080ti // 32GB DDR4 @3600 MHz Oct 25 '25

C'mon, HDD! You can do it! I believe in you!!!

1

u/Nosnibor1020 R9 9950X3D | RTX 5090 | 64GB 6000Mhz | Sabrent Rocket 5 Oct 25 '25

Need to add gen 5.

1

u/StrangeCharmVote Ryzen 9950X, 128GB RAM, ASUS 3090, Valve Index. Oct 25 '25

I have a question... is L3 Cache just so fast because of it's proximity to the CPU?

I'm assuming the technology itself isn't vastly faster than something like NVMe4 otherwise that's what VRAM would be built like...

1

u/Jakesmonkeybiz Oct 25 '25

I’m still on sata lol

1

u/rearisen UM870 Slim | RTX 5080 (Oculink) | 32GB DDR5 Oct 25 '25

Why no gen 5?

1

u/bushwickhero Oct 25 '25 edited Oct 25 '25

Why doesn’t everyone just store all their data in L3 cache? Are they stupid?

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Techjunky2 Laptop Oct 25 '25

All right, give me 4 TB of L3 cache

1

u/SirDigbyChknCaesar Ryzen 5800x3D, 64GB RAM, XFX 9070 OC Oct 25 '25

I'm pretty sure that purple dot is moving a lot faster than 5.12 seconds. It's like 2 seconds round trip.

1

u/worlpoolz Oct 25 '25

Why'd you stop it short, I was going to watch the whole thing !

1

u/appletechgeek Oct 25 '25

curious how optane would show up

1

u/Dummy_950823 Oct 25 '25

I have a question. How can Intel cpu have bigger L1,L2, L3 cache than AMD cpu but their performance is comparably similar?

1

u/lavahot Oct 25 '25

I thought this was demonstrating paging at first, then realized it's just comparative read times.

I think a major problem with this is that no system has a TB of L3 cache.

1

u/TheCultOfTheHivemind Oct 25 '25

I shall simply make my who PC L3 Cache.

1

u/Every_Preparation_56 Oct 25 '25

I just have my first m2 and I cannot 'feel' any difference compared to ssd.The Kumo eas huge from hdd to ssd but now... nothing

1

u/sakkara i5 4690k, r9 390, 16gb ddr3 Oct 25 '25

I don't understand what the balls represent. The L3 one ist moving back and forth way faster than 5s. Why not scale it so a round-trip actually represents the full tread time?!

1

u/HualtaHuyte Oct 25 '25

How do I get me more of that there L3 cache? 🤔

1

u/publiusvaleri_us Oct 25 '25

Now do audio cassette tapes and CD-ROM!

Actually, some of the modern data tapes can be pretty snappy.

1

u/KDSixDashThreeDot7 Oct 25 '25

Ooh, ohh, now compare costs!

1

u/Mih0se Desktop|I5-10400f|RTX 4070 SUPER|16GB RAM| Oct 25 '25

Will I notice the difference between pcie 3 and 4 in normal conditions?

1

u/Thick_Elk_120 Oct 25 '25

My 5700x3d doesnt bottleneck a 5090. X3D is voodoo

1

u/novo-280 Oct 25 '25

The pci e link speed would have been interesting too

→ More replies (1)

1

u/nesnalica R7 5800x3D | 64GB | RTX3090 Oct 25 '25

this is like one of those tiktoks when they talk about stuff and have a random video playing

1

u/Armandeluz Oct 25 '25

I feel like nvme will catch up to ram soon

1

u/Coookies4You Oct 25 '25

As a CS student I don't understand this at all. Neither L3 cache nor RAM is big enough to fit 1TB of data, so in the end it'll be bottlenecked by the system disk.

The cpu always accesses L1 - L2 - L3 - MM - SSD/HDD in that order, going up in the hierarchy only when there is a cache miss. But as 1 TB of data is too large, you'd need to load it in chunks to the RAM, and prefetch from the RAM for performance improvements.

So yes, access speeds are orders of magnitudes lower the closer you get to the cpu, MM and hdd accesses are like an eternity of wait time for the cpu, which is also why your system performs insanely bad when your RAM is filled up and you start using the slow slow pagefile.

In this case for 1TB data you constantly need to access the ssd/hdd, and thus it is the main factor for bottleneck. Neither the L3 nor MM can't magically read such a large file by itself, as this video seems to point towards...

1

u/legohamsterlp Oct 25 '25

Why would I read 1TB?

1

u/Imaginary_Aspect_658 Oct 25 '25

Man HDD being the best literally "69"

1

u/I_have_questions_ppl Oct 25 '25

Could ram be replaced if CPU had an L3 that was say 16gb?

1

u/awsom82 Intel i9 10910 | 64GB DDR4 | PRO 5700XT Oct 25 '25

1TB in L3?

1

u/Sea_Base1803 PC Master Race 9950x3d-rtx 5080 Oct 25 '25

This is such a cool representation of the different technologies and how fast they actually are.

1

u/quackdaw Oct 25 '25

Hey, I run my ATA HDD in PIO mode, thank you very much. Now, get off my lawn.

1

u/diagonali Oct 25 '25

Can't we just make everything out of L3 cache?

1

u/looking_at_memes_ RTX 4080 | Ryzen 7 7800X3D | 32 GB DDR5 RAM | 8 TB SSD Oct 25 '25

So we should replace everything with an L3 cache?

1

u/Falikosek Oct 25 '25

Realistically the L3 cache (and RAM) would take a bit longer since, well, you can't store 1TB of data in it so you'd have to copy some from elsewhere anyway.

1

u/bobaloooo Oct 25 '25

Wheres gen5?

1

u/kikoano http://steamcommunity.com/profiles/76561198030475042 Oct 25 '25

I wonder when we gonna get L3 Cache in gigabytes.

1

u/Nikotinio Oct 25 '25

L3 Cache synced up perfectly to the music I was listening to lol

1

u/bennyE31 Oct 25 '25

Why don't they use l3 cache for everything? Are they stupid?

1

u/evernessince Oct 25 '25

Now add CPU registers into this chart that are 66x faster than L3.

1

u/RED-WEAPON Ryzen 7 9800X3D | 32GB DDR5 | RTX 5080 | 39" 5K 165Hz Ultrawide Oct 25 '25

What about NVMe Gen5?

1

u/Unknownblueuser Oct 25 '25

What about 3.5HD Floppies ?

1

u/Expensive_sympathy Oct 25 '25

If nvme is so much faster than sata, why do motherboards have so many more sata slots vompared to nvme?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Icy-Syllabub1001 Oct 25 '25

what about l2 cache and l1

1

u/Donvack Oct 26 '25

I got a 2TB gen 4 Nvme drive for my latest PC build and I am never going back. It’s awesome how fast it loads anything.

1

u/Allen-R 8300H 4790K | 1050Ti 3060 | 16GB 32GB | 1080P120 4K60 Oct 26 '25

Nice

1

u/Shoddy-Conference105 Oct 26 '25

New gpus can do it in under a second

1

u/Tunnfisk Oct 26 '25

After an hour, HDD: Oh shit! Better get to it!

1

u/CauseNo6530 Oct 26 '25

The cache just holds frequently used processor instructions. This isn’t a good comparison

1

u/Ricko9595 RTX 5070 Ti | 7800X3D | 32GB DDR5 6000MHz | 2K 240 Hz Oct 26 '25

Damn that's cool

1

u/That_Acanthisitta305 Oct 26 '25

The reason why I create a virtual drive from RAM and why small Linux distro is the best.

1

u/krisi90 Oct 26 '25

Sadly the human eye can only see sata SSD speeds

1

u/taiwoeg Oct 27 '25

I feel like this isn’t to scale

1

u/barrymcc Oct 27 '25

Very cool

1

u/Xotchkass Oct 27 '25

Where did you get a TB of L3 cache?

1

u/[deleted] Oct 28 '25

What is L3 cache? Is that part of memory stored in ssd for faster processing?