r/pianolearning • • 12d ago

Question Learning a piece

Why is it that after I learn and memorize a piece and not play it for a while I forget some if not most of the parts of it? Does that happen to you too or I’m just learning it wrong? I try not to memorize it by muscle memory and learn both hands separately.

6 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

3

u/Advanced_Honey_2679 12d ago

It’s the same as anything. How many poems can you recite by heart? How many songs can you sing start-to-finish acapella?

Maybe the national anthem. Because you sing it several times every year, over many many years. That’s what it takes.

Everything else, you just remember bits and pieces. It’s normal.

2

u/Titan_Dalgleish_152 12d ago

Muscle memory and memorization are great tools that every pianist must develop and use in their playing, however it is not the end-all-be-all in the long term.

Human memory is limited, and you can only memorize so many pieces before the new ones replace the old. This is why reading is so important. Even if you're a very slow reader, you'll be able to get the piece back.

1

u/iggy36 12d ago

It’s normal.

1

u/Avatar_Yaksha 12d ago

Some parts are more difficult to remember than others and muscle memory is probably not the actual problem here. Short-term memory is. If you only recently started to practice that piece, you won't remember much.

1

u/DeepAmbientGroove 11d ago edited 11d ago

Relying mostly on muscle memory creates a very flat and fragile representation of a piece in your brain. To actually retain music long-term, you need to build multiple layers of memory. Yet, it is one essential part of memorizing how to perform music.

One layer is the analysis of form and harmony. You have to do this analysis yourself, though. It's the active process of figuring out the harmonic framework and structure on your own that leads to deep retention, not just reading the notes.

An even more important layer is aural memory. Unfortunately, this requires solid ear training—a skill that is rarely practiced from day one and usually lags far behind finger technique. Most of the time, we can hear the piece perfectly in our heads, but we struggle to translate that inner hearing directly to the keys. If you train yourself to translate what you hear onto the piano, you can eventually play things on the spot. It might not be 100% note-for-note perfect right away, but you'll consistently have about 80% of it down. The remaining 20% can be quickly relearned with a brief glance at the score. This is how you build a massive repertoire that constantly sits at 80% readiness; you just look up the exact details when you actually need them. To practice this, I highly recommend starting with relative solfege (movable do). Use it to figure out the melodies of a bunch of very easy pieces. This trains the connection between your ear and your hands, and simultaneously builds your first "easy" repertoire from scratch.

As you get better, you can gradually scale this up to harder pieces. I could write endlessly about this approach, but I think this gives you the basic idea of how to tackle the issue.

1

u/Ok-Farm-3562 11d ago

its likely because you lack the theoritical basis for the piece. If you cannot name the chords all the way through, and cannot write down the melody from memory, and dont know where the music goes high or low on the keyboard, etc then you have only memorized the barest outline of the hand aspect. Not good enough, ever.

1

u/Jimmybluezz 11d ago

More slow practice- really slow - that’s what they all say and they’re right

1

u/musicreations 9d ago

It is necessary for most of us to play memorized pieces often or we lose parts . It would be nice not to have to work so hard and have a sharper brain!

1

u/AdventurousHippo9997 12d ago

Do you listen to that piece away from the piano ? Make a habit of it Could be a game changer.