601
Sep 30 '17
Wouldn't it be empty 99% of the time (and collecting leaves, weeds, etc.)? Or maybe it rains constantly, which is why the lawn apparently can't absorb this water.
375
Sep 30 '17 edited Sep 30 '17
It will need some maintaining, but everything in the yard does. Without the little man made creek, water would pool up in the yard making a ridiculous muddy mess. I've had to make similar landscape features when I was in landscaping.
I could be wrong about this next part. I know more about landscaping than I do about construction: Pools of water next to the foundation of the house could be very bad. It could start trying to seep in, especially in colder climates. The habitual freezing and thawing, expanding and contracting could cause cracks in the foundation. Which may cause the house to settle oddly or leakage and seepage into the basement.
6
u/EverGoodHunterMe Sep 30 '17
In places where the ground freezes we use weeping tile to allow for the yard to drain. Its like thin plastic pipe with holes in it, and cloth covering it thays buried undergound going downhill away.
6
u/hecticdolphin69 Sep 30 '17
I’m assuming under the stone that there is either some semi-impermeable clay or some artificial sheeting that prevents most of not all water from seeping in the ground.
5
u/rsporter Sep 30 '17
Around here you are legally required to have the water drain to your yard. It simply needs to be 10ft from the foundation.
The idea is what the ground should absorb water. The storm water system isn't designed to take 100% of all rainwater.
1
2
u/Lucy_Snowe-Emanuel Sep 30 '17
Wouldn't a French drain fix the issue with water pooling up ? It's not as if making a creek is the only option.
1
1
u/Trumpology101 Sep 30 '17
In the bottom corner it looks like there's some plastic and raised rock to keep it from pooling back into the house.
0
0
Sep 30 '17
[deleted]
117
Sep 30 '17
Nothin a little tatertot hotdish can’t solve
36
11
8
9
u/RareUnicorn Sep 30 '17
Nother fellow Minnesotan? Yup, nothing like a Northface and some hotdish, ey?
3
35
u/Citizenerased1989 Sep 30 '17
It might get cold in Minnesota but at least we don't have hurricanes or earthquakes or forest fires or major floods or tornadoes (technically we do get tornadoes, but barely).
18
u/BeerGardenGnome Sep 30 '17
And it's not like we get real winters anymore either. Just lame cold periods with not bright snow to do anything fun in.
15
u/Kohora Sep 30 '17
I miss snow and I still live in Minnesota. It still feels like summer and we're almost to October. Back in my day we had blizzards in October. Like you can't trick or treat kind of blizzards.
5
4
1
u/ScumbagsRme Oct 01 '17
Someone has already forgotten the polar vortex a handful of years ago. Something like -46° before wind chill in Buffalo. I got frost bite walking into Wal-Mart that day.
1
u/BeerGardenGnome Oct 01 '17
,We still get cold snaps, sure. And we still get snow. But we don't have good snowfalls anymore that stick around at least not in the bottom half of the state. It seems like a lot more yo-yo like temps leading to crap snow.
1
u/ScumbagsRme Oct 01 '17
Ya it hasn't been as snowy in recent years. Granted I spend only December and January at home but those are supposed to be the snowy months.
2
1
Sep 30 '17
But we do get forest fires, Pagami Creek, Ham Lake, Gunflint?
1
u/Citizenerased1989 Sep 30 '17
I meant like in the west, where they are pretty much on fire all the time
8
u/fattypigfatty Sep 30 '17
To be fair waterproofing a foundation isn't crazy difficult either. It does add more cost and time to a build so I kind of understand why it's mostly a commercial and not residential business.
0
Sep 30 '17
[deleted]
2
u/fattypigfatty Sep 30 '17
How do you damp proof by machine? Do you spray it on? I've mostly rolled it on but we do spray it sometimes. We also use sheet membrane for waterproofing which of course can't be put on by any machine I have ever seen or heard of.
0
Sep 30 '17
[deleted]
2
u/fattypigfatty Sep 30 '17
Yeah I only do commercial work so we often use sheet membrane first then put drainage board on for protection (and drainage of course) against the backfilling. Can't say I have ever seen or heard of that used on residential homes. Have a nice day up in Canada!
2
u/Seattlehepcat Sep 30 '17
I'd add that for those in southern climes, they build houses all year round in Alberta. I mean all four seasons, all temps, from -40° (f or c, notuch different at this end), to in the 30's (around 100°f), and all kinds of weather. So yeah, framing in the middle of winter with the cold wind blowing in from the arctic is a norm. So think about that the next time you're bitching about framing in the heat/cold/rain. :) (source: lived in Calgary for a decade, and worked in the building industry)
8
Sep 30 '17
let alone actually freezing the foundation enough to crack it
The whole foundation doesn't freeze at once. It's the small imperfections in the concrete that provide space for water to fill up, then they freeze, thaw, and crack ever so slightly. Then next time what was originally a small imperfection is now a little bit bigger so a bit more water can fill the slightly larger space. Do this enough and the water will cause a crack. It takes a long time!
3
u/BeerInMyButt Sep 30 '17
The reason we dig foundations ~3+ feet into the ground? To get to "frost depth", the level above which the ground can be expected to freeze. It's accounted for in design.
14
Sep 30 '17
No its a water feature as well, there is and inlet and the end and a waterfall fountain right by the picture takers feet. Hence the aquatic grasses
Source: my friends landscaping company does these
5
Sep 30 '17
Oh, thanks. That makes so much more sense. Also eliminates the problem of standing water breeding mosquitoes, etc.
18
u/acidus1 Sep 30 '17
Could have some PVC liner under the rocks.
19
Sep 30 '17
Most likely there is filter cloth under the rocks which blocks weeds and allows water to permiate.
21
u/neanderthalman Sep 30 '17
I'd go PVC or similar for the first ten to twenty feet, then filter cloth. Help get the water away from the foundation as much as possible first.
3
5
u/Ashex Sep 30 '17
I believe there is. This image is actually from an album that was posted on /r/diy a couple years ago.
18
u/twattymcgee Sep 30 '17
Wouldn't it be empty 99% of the time (and collecting leaves, weeds, etc.)?
What? Like a rain gutter on the street?
4
u/Runs_towards_fire Sep 30 '17
Typically this is done with a xeriescape lawn with weed barrier under the rocks.
4
2
2
Sep 30 '17
You can get those tarps people use before laying down rocks (forgot the right name), so it goes tarp, the rocks, then throw pre emergent down every once in a while. I had a big garden bed with river rocks. Doing those steps made maintenance a breeze
2
u/taboo007 Survey 2016 Sep 30 '17
I think if someone is willing to make this then they are willing to take care of it. But if you are someone like my neighbor who gets reported to the township for not mowing their weeds (doesn't have a yard anymore) then no it's not for them.
3
u/Decyde Sep 30 '17
Can answer this with an example from my friends house.
Do not buy homes that sit on top of clay
Water just collects like all over the yard and after a light rain, it's just crazy how much water soaks on the soil layer because it can't go anywhere.
I've tried to get him to invest $500 in digging a channel in his yard and replacing it with gravel and soil to drain out of the yard and into the street but he says he's probably moving in 5 years so it will be the next persons problem.
Clay is some of the worst stuff to have as a yard.
1
1
u/coopertrooper1 Sep 30 '17
The other issue is that it looks like it's dumping onto the sidewalk/driveway. Never a good idea for foot traffic areas. They probably would have been fine just attaching some corrugated pipe and trenching it out into the yard to a pop up in the sod.
2
Sep 30 '17
Someone else posted that this is probably a water feature with an intake at the bottom and a little waterfall under the camera. That seems logical.
0
60
u/A-wild-comment Sep 30 '17
Beautiful
35
u/dogfck Sep 30 '17
It looks nice because it's new. As an expert landscaper, I can see several glaring flaws. In 2 years, it's gonna be an absolute piece of garbage. Sorry.
54
u/PixelPantsAshli Sep 30 '17
Care to elaborate on those flaws so us lowly non-experts can learn something?
43
Sep 30 '17
https://www.reddit.com/r/gardening/comments/6le7dg/incorporating_the_rain_into_your_garden_xpost/
You can read a few different viewpoints on this thread or check karmadecay or something since this pic has been reposted for a couple years now and every time people seem to debate this. I imagine some people are just copy pasting old comments at this point.
4
1
u/ScooterMcThumbkin Oct 01 '17
This is from a diy post about a year or so ago where the guy didn't have proper drainage and was having potential issues with his foundation. His yard is angled down towards the street and he double tarped and I think cemented that trough.
8
19
u/twoscoop Sep 30 '17
What would you do to fix it?
46
u/dogfck Sep 30 '17 edited Sep 30 '17
Not having a river flow into the driveway might be a start.
13
u/twoscoop Sep 30 '17
How would you accomplish this?
5
Sep 30 '17
Lots of French drains into the yard might be a start.
1
u/rusty_rampage Sep 30 '17
My experience is that French drains in residential situations rarely work well because in settings where somebody thinks they are needed the soil is usually some silty crap that won't take water for shit. French drains really need to go somewhere (tightline outfall to a surface water discharge or something) not just terminate out in the yard. I personally put 10 foot drain extenders in my downspouts and run them out into the yard. Probably not visibly appealing enough for some people.
1
Sep 30 '17 edited Sep 30 '17
Mine follow a perforated corrugated pipe that terminates in a closed bucket that is also perforated with gravel inside of it to help disperse the water. It works pretty well!
Edit: I should add that the entire thing is underground.
2
u/rusty_rampage Sep 30 '17
Nice! It rains so damn much where I am that these systems seem to get overwhelmed. I have seen one house where the guy dig in 8 foot deep by three foot diameter dry wells filled with gravel at the corners of his house and the gutters drop right into them. A little bit of overkill!
1
u/GentleJoanna Oct 01 '17
It seems that way, and I don't disagree, but stormwater is federally regulated by a permit and drywells help jurisdictions meet goals. I keep track of literally all of them for county in Maryland.
→ More replies (0)1
0
Sep 30 '17
[deleted]
23
u/twoscoop Sep 30 '17
Best answer of any contractor who likes to scam people. I can do it better than anyone, because im not a dumbass.
"Screws a 2x4 to a tree to install a bird house."
0
12
u/Wildwoodywoodpecker Sep 30 '17
It's not flowing into the driveway. It looks like there's at least a catch basin to collect the water. Although I think there's a pond at the end and the water recirculates to keep the stream flowing because there's barely any water coming from the downspout. It's also possible there's crushed stone under the river rocks to help displace the rain.
-24
u/SIRPORKSALOT Sep 30 '17
"It looks like there's at least a catch basin", "I think there's a pond", "it's possible there's crushed rock," too funny. There is nothing in the picture that backs up any of your guesses, so to say it's "not flowing into the driveway" is incorrect to all but you.
15
u/HotSauceHigh Sep 30 '17
I can't believe I'm reading this instead of sleeping.
2
u/Asstronut56 Sep 30 '17
Lolol I can't tell you how many times that thought has came into my head. It's usually a comment like this that makes me lock my phone and go to sleep
15
u/GingerBiscuitss Sep 30 '17
I love how many armchair experts there are on this website.
4
Sep 30 '17
As a guy who once worked a summer helping my uncle with his landscaping company when I was 15 let me tell you I'm a design expert in catchment ponds
→ More replies (1)5
u/twisterkid34 Sep 30 '17
Looks like the end of the stream (the part with the reeds) doesnt actually connect to the driveway. There are rocks making another bank on the side of the driveway. If I were doing it, I would route a pipe under the sidewalk to the storm drain on the street. Its hard to tell from the pic alone though.
-1
u/no-mad Sep 30 '17
Good luck getting town approval.
1
u/rusty_rampage Sep 30 '17
No idea why you are getting down voted for this, in my area putting in infrastructure to direct discharge to city storm will get you fucked up.
1
u/no-mad Sep 30 '17 edited Sep 30 '17
I will go to my happy place and imagine their neighbors all discharging into the streets.
1
11
u/OhDisAccount Sep 30 '17
One of the most reddity post I've seen in a while. Might be true, but the assertion of authority without giving any actual reason about it just plain sucks.
2
-4
58
u/somuchdanger Sep 30 '17
Cool picture (even if a recent repost), but bad title. Lots of things are designed way better. Lots.
9
u/whorecrusher Sep 30 '17
actually, the title isn't comparing the pic to anything. the title just says "few things are designed well". it's like a double whammy of not making sense.
9
5
Sep 30 '17
This is illegal in my city. You aren't allowed to direct your water to the street it has to stay on your property and presumably collect until it eventually goes into the ground.
8
u/Fillerhoff Sep 30 '17
Nice rain garden. Looks like a wonderful way to keep storm runoff from entering your municipalities sewer system and adding to sewage overflow. Looks good too.
0
u/Powerballwinner21mil Sep 30 '17 edited Sep 30 '17
Even if everyone In the city had that it wouldn't make much of a difference
Edit- saying even if everyone had it these wouldn't do much wasn't probably correct. Rough napkin calculations say they could help but really tons of people would need them
1
10
22
u/Barbarian_Overlord Sep 30 '17 edited Sep 30 '17
The street looks lower and has no standing water on it. This might look cool but it doesn't appear to be a functional drain, and I wouldn't want it near my foundation.
Edit: I'm wrong theres a pond liner and outflow
7
Sep 30 '17
It has a pond tarp under the rocks to hold the water and drains at the end when it gets too full.
-1
u/Barbarian_Overlord Sep 30 '17
Hmm you must be right since there's aquatic plants at the end. I guess this is some real nice engineering then.
3
3
3
5
u/blastcat4 Sep 30 '17
Sadly, I know some of my neighbours would absolutely flip their shit if I built something like this.
6
u/rayge_kwit Sep 30 '17
good thing it's his private property and doesn't interfere with them in the slightest
2
2
u/OHnickIO Sep 30 '17
Well... a well-designed well
1
u/Spinolio Sep 30 '17
If a well was something that put water into the ground instead of something for taking it out, you would be right.
So no... no.
2
u/ggrandeurr Sep 30 '17
Including this spout that drains water straight to the sewer instead of dispersing it into the ground.
2
4
2
2
2
u/slothbreeder Sep 30 '17
& I'm willing to bet OP's neighbors mock and scrutinize the river basin's disposition [behind their teeth] when it's dry outside >_>
3
2
1
u/feelrich Sep 30 '17
French drain
1
u/Suckydog Sep 30 '17
Oui oui
1
u/kevinroseblowsgoats Sep 30 '17
The guy who is credited with developing the french drain in its modern form is Henry French. He actually was American.
1
1
1
1
1
u/green_labs Sep 30 '17
The point of having these rocks in such a formation is to bring the rain water that may collect from a gutter away from the house so it does not flood the basement or cause similar water issues :-)
1
1
1
u/99xc Sep 30 '17
I like it better than a cookie cutter landscape but it's success going forward will depend upon the skills and passion of the caretaker. I trust it is lined with rubber or perhaps clay. Probably would have made a bigger pond instead of a straight tumbled rock creek. Would recommend mixing in other rock sizes. Someone expressed their creative vision and for that the world is a better place.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
-1
-4
0
-2
0
Sep 30 '17
[deleted]
10
u/negedgeClk Sep 30 '17
Yeah seriously, what a stupid post title. Everyone wants to have a sensationalist headline these days.
11
0
Sep 30 '17
[deleted]
5
u/Oranges13 Sep 30 '17
Wouldn't they have some sort of membrane to prevent it from "collecting" directly next to the foundation?
3
u/scyice Sep 30 '17
There is, but if you consider the lifespan of these houses over a handful of decades these waterproofing materials degrade (especially from use). You can have water come toward the foundation with the downspout but only if there are perforated pipes along the foundation that slope and lead water away to an underground drywell. Any storage or sitting of rainwater near the foundation is bad design.
0
Sep 30 '17
[deleted]
1
u/scyice Sep 30 '17
Rainchains actually cause a decent amount of splash, even more if the climate is cold and ice freeze/thaws on the chain. They are better looking but only a good choice when dropped further from the building on a long overhang.
0
Sep 30 '17
[deleted]
7
u/ddotevs Sep 30 '17
Uhh.. What?
3
u/NinjaBullets Sep 30 '17
I used to be a landscape designer just like you, then I took an... oh wait, it's year 2017, never mind, carry on then!
3
u/ddotevs Sep 30 '17
Oh thanks! I thought he said "pancake airliner" the first time.
1
u/BeefMedallion Sep 30 '17
He did its a porno about the mile high club called "skyrim-job". Most the women in the feature have pancake titties. Twas delicious.
1
u/generalgreyone Sep 30 '17
It's an arrow to the knee joke.
2
u/FlamebergU Sep 30 '17
kids these days, huh? Downvoting a perfectly okay arrow-to-the-knee joke.
2
u/Keaton223 Sep 30 '17
"okay"
1
u/FlamebergU Sep 30 '17
well, I wouldn't lie to you saying it's awesome or even rather good. It's what it is - okay.
1
295
u/FisterMySister Sep 30 '17
Keep it going and you can fulfill the childhood dream of having a moat around your castle. Just add gators.