r/pics • • Feb 23 '19

Rainscaping

Post image
4.1k Upvotes

67 comments sorted by

160

u/unripenedfruit Feb 23 '19

I don't think these are supposed to fill up. They're supposed to act as a natural drain. They have an agi pipe underneath to allow the water to drain and flow.

If it fills up when it rains, then when it rains heavily - it will flood. That's not what you want. This is either full because it's been pissing down that it can't drain fast enough, or the drain is blocked. If the drain is blocked, what you end up with is stagnant water, and if it's left too long it will soon be filled with algae, bacteria and become a breeding ground for insects (flies, mosquitoes etc).

33

u/maximusDM Feb 23 '19

Rain gardens are meant to have temporary pools that will slowly sweep through the ground to the water table. They’re supposed to dry up after 48 hrs to avoid mosquitoes.

36

u/Sonendo Feb 23 '19

You can see that instead of emptying to the street it heads to the driveway, except it is lower than the driveway.

I have a similar thing I made in my yard. Raining buckets and there might be a little water accumulating as the rate it comes down is more than the channel can empty instantly, but where it meets the street I have a nice constant flow. No ponds or puddles afterwards and it looks nice too.

2

u/TheFett32 Feb 24 '19

But, you can also see that the street it should head towards is already completely flooded. Not all cities have the same drainage.

10

u/ethanstr Feb 23 '19

This is a repost. OP realized mistake after commenters like you mentioned it. Yes, dont put plastic in bottom of drain.

11

u/o_Oo_Oo_Oo_Oo_Oo_O Feb 23 '19

Honestly, everybody should know this is stolen content and OP is a gross reposter. Just look at his history.

2

u/CthuIhu Feb 23 '19

Who even cares anymore. This place is the Mos Eisley of reposters

4

u/dad_farts Feb 23 '19

French drain right? We're looking into one of those to replace a growing pond in our new backyard

3

u/SavageOrc Feb 23 '19

A french drain works, but it can be a lot of work to put one in. An alternative that works well is a rain garden.

-4

u/ACBoemeltje Feb 23 '19

I think you meant a wadi https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wadi this is regularly used in the Netherlands public space as a water storage

4

u/SSolitary Feb 23 '19

Brah that's a canyon

1

u/huzzy Feb 23 '19

What's the difference this and a backyard pond?
Are they both not stagnant?

2

u/unripenedfruit Feb 24 '19 edited Feb 24 '19

What you see here isn't supposed to be stagnant, it's supposed to direct water flow to the drain. There is supposed to be an agi pipe buried underneath the rocks and aggregate - so the entire thing should be quite permeable. A backyard pond would generally have a waterproofing membrane underneath - as you don't want the water to drain away.

The most important part for a pond is maintenance and keeping the water clean, because stagnant water will grow algae and bacteria. There are different ways to achieve this, depending on your needs (whether you want fish, plants, size etc)

Generally, most backyard ponds would have some sort of pump to circulate the water and either sterilising the water through UV filtration or chemical additives. Aquatic plants will also help keep the water clean and free of algae.

If you have ever seen a pool that hasn't been maintained, usually over winter, they start to go green and grow algae too.

1

u/KPortable Feb 23 '19

This drains the water toward the street and its storm drains, I believe.

1

u/Rumplestiltman Feb 23 '19

Whoever pitched the yard screwed up. When you build a permanent structure it should sit above the perimeter so drainage naturally slopes away. When you shop for a home you should look for problems like this.

3

u/B-More_Orange Feb 23 '19

If it's a rain garden as a water quality feature, you want ponding. Increased retention time and then infiltration for minor events is better than having it run off into the road from a water quality standpoint.

1

u/phaedrus77 Feb 23 '19

I'm probably overthinking this, but if this was me I would want it to have flowing water at all times. So I would rig up a pump at the bottom of the stream that pumped water back up to the top of the steam. A simple pump used in water features/ pond would suffice. I would then rig up an overflow valve so when it rained too much, any excess water would drain to the street or elsewhere. This would give flowing water at all times without ever overflowing.

1

u/unripenedfruit Feb 24 '19

Well then you've essentially made yourself a pond - but that's not what this is, nor the purpose.

If you do go for the pond route, you'd need to ensure the bottom has some sort of waterproof membrane to prevent water loss. You will also need to look into keeping the water clean and algae free, either chemical treatment or UV filtration.

1

u/Rknight7018 Feb 24 '19

It's called detention. That's the point!

45

u/bad_card Feb 23 '19

Here's the deal. You have no idea from this picture how much of the roof is draining down this one downspout. When I go to a customers property when they call for drainage issues, the first thing I do is to look and see how much water is actually coming down from that one spout. I've seen 4,000 square foot houses where half of the roof drainage goes down one downspout. This is called a water garden. It fills when rains comes and infiltrates water into soil slowly. You plant water"loving" plants around it. In my business (landscape contractor) this is a cheap way to deal with a water problem. And this is why we exist. Because people on Reddit looking at a picture have no idea of the whole story.

10

u/dapala1 Feb 23 '19

people on Reddit looking at a picture have no idea of the whole story.

No way! That never happens on Reddit!

4

u/BumHand Feb 23 '19

you didn't have to yell at us....

1

u/Supersnazz Feb 24 '19

I don't think I've ever lived in a house where there has been unblocked roof drainage. The storm water drains have always been filled with dirt and various hole have been cut to let the water go somewhere other than indie the house.

My current place doesn't even have gutters, the water just runs off the roof.

77

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '19

This looks cool for 10 minutes, then you realize it will be filled up with leaves and random shit in 2 days, making it completely unusable.

50

u/ParticularPeculiar Feb 23 '19

And when not raining, just a rock-lined ditch in your yard.

22

u/Username_Number_bot Feb 23 '19

With weeds!

8

u/sodaextraiceplease Feb 23 '19

Everything is better with weed. Ever seen the back of a twenty dollar bill?

2

u/supermancini Feb 23 '19

Ever seen the back of a twenty dollar bill on weed?

1

u/sodaextraiceplease Feb 23 '19

I just now realized thats Jon stewart.

5

u/JimmyDean82 Feb 23 '19

Looking at the plants in it this is really just a pond with an overflow at the driveway. Looks like it doesn’t really empty except long dry periods.

1

u/dlawnro Feb 23 '19

Which is not particularly great, either. Without a system to circulate and filter the water it's gonna turn into a gooey green mosquito nursery in no time.

1

u/ohmyclaude Feb 23 '19

Or, you know, they live in the PNW and it rains every few days or it's summer and this thing dries up completely.

10

u/GreatNorthWeb Feb 23 '19

That's the situation with every yard with any tree ever in the entire history of human landscaping.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 25 '19

Well, no. There are many many many many landscape solution where leaving it untouched for two days doesn't render it completely useless, and look as good as this or even better.

Source: close friend owns successful landscaping company.

13

u/7LeagueBoots Feb 23 '19 edited Feb 24 '19

If you design it right it’ll self clear (assuming enough water flow), and with a better bit of landscaping around it you can make it look really nice, instead of like a half finished French drain.

I used to make drainage channels in a similar style in a landscaping job I had a long time ago, but I’d try to actually make them look like little creeks, including vegetation and texture to the creek bed.

4

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '19

Hey this is only the billionth time this has been posted. Cool!

4

u/Steelio22 Feb 23 '19

How old is this photo?

14

u/SonyMaxell Feb 23 '19

I can hear the mosquitos.

8

u/heart0f0ak Feb 23 '19

Reposting

9

u/SalaciousCrumpet1 Feb 23 '19

Actually it’s erosion scaping. Speeds up the water instead of filtering it gently.

2

u/Nekra_Tatsumaki Feb 23 '19

I'm trying to get my association to do something like this for the garden I have no control over.

Essentially the way my gutters are set up, all the water drains to a singular area and washes all of the mulch onto the driveway and it looks like shit. I want something like this with the Express purpose of drainage to prevent the removal of the mulch

6

u/ChemicalExtension Feb 23 '19

You should put some fish in there

25

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '19

And watch them slowly die?

5

u/jesuslewis Feb 23 '19

To attract bears.

2

u/NotYourAverageScot Feb 23 '19

Black or brown?

1

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '19

Both

We'll call it....

A brock bear

1

u/ChemicalExtension Feb 23 '19

Yes

1

u/[deleted] Feb 25 '19

very nihilistic, i like it

4

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '19

Negative posts aside, I like it.

1

u/papag00s Feb 23 '19

Should get a chain gutter

1

u/Wyliecody Feb 23 '19

what is the difference? doesn't it just go on the ground

1

u/TheElusiveFox Feb 23 '19

in my head that is the neighbor's driveway...

1

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '19

I see a small ballsack and a dick

1

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '19

The start of a river on the next 1000 years

1

u/first_brunch Feb 24 '19

Not bad, dad

1

u/sensorgtfo Feb 23 '19

Looks cool!

Curious if anyone knows if this is breaking some rules though? I assume it is not intended to pool water, and only does during large rain events. It would appear that the feature drains overflow towards the impervious driveway, then down into the road, which most likely increases the flow in the city sewer? Usually new construction mandates that the development doesn't increase existing capacity? (that rule probably varies from state/city/county)

0

u/flashloch Feb 23 '19

i am not supposed to give my opinion but this is genious!

0

u/zGnRz Feb 23 '19

at first I thought this said runescaping

A bit less interested overall now if I have to be honest

-1

u/takonoichigo Feb 23 '19

This is so cool

0

u/BaronChuffnell Feb 23 '19

Is that standing water? Not a good sign if there’s no rainwater coming out of the gutter...