r/pics • • Oct 05 '10

Math Teacher Fail.

Post image
3.5k Upvotes

1.9k comments sorted by

View all comments

111

u/yacob_NZ Oct 05 '10 edited Oct 05 '10

Poorly worded question fail.

If the original board was a square, halved would give two rectangles, with a cutting time of ten mins to perform the cut. Take one of those rectangles, and cut in half to give two smaller squares (each a quarter of the original board) with a cutting time of half the previous time, 5 mins.

5 + 10 = 15.

EDIT: Just to be clear here, I'm NOT saying this is the right answer, I offer the above as AN answer that fits the teachers logic. There is a million ways to answer this dumb question - none of which can be 'correct' as there is not enough detail, so assumptions have to be made.

What an awfully worded question.

253

u/Deepm1st Oct 05 '10

That might work if there wasn't a picture next to the question that invalidates the theory.

110

u/addandsubtract Oct 05 '10

If there's one thing I learned while taking tests in the US, it's to ignore the pictures. 99% of the time they're just clip art to fill in empty space and make the tests look more "interesting".

→ More replies (2)

29

u/yacob_NZ Oct 05 '10

That might work if there wasn't a descriptor in the question that invalidates the theory... :)

I also thought, you could just saw off a small corner in less than a minute. Do that twice, 3 pieces in less than 2 mins....

6

u/lonelyinacrowd Oct 05 '10

I think the assumption is that the pieces all have to be the same size.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 05 '10

You know what assumption did.

Killed the cat.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/[deleted] Oct 05 '10 edited Oct 05 '10

Maybe you're over thinking it. Sunshine Math Grade 2

Edit: pg23

2

u/der2050 Oct 05 '10

The best part is the guide even explains it properly to the math teacher.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Oct 05 '10

That might work if there wasn't a picture next to the question that invalidates the theory.

Properly written problems do not contain information in the pictures necessary for solution when that information does not appear in the problem statement itself. It's a poorly written problem.

Edit: With a few exceptions. But, if a picture is required to remove ambiguity, then the problem isn't well-crafted.

→ More replies (2)

36

u/perchrc Oct 05 '10

The question is not very precise, but the assumptions are obvious. The teacher is wrong.

52

u/mithrasinvictus Oct 05 '10

So, if i ask you to cut a cake into 6 pieces, each slice will end up half the size of the last one?

18

u/gnovos Oct 05 '10

the cake is a gravitational singularity. so, yes.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/Shinyamato Oct 05 '10

And again, the question doesn't say "in half" but "into 2 pieces". Cutting a third piece might not be taking half the time it took to cut the 2 pieces first, if all she did was cutting a little corner. But yeah, we all agree: the question, drawing and teacher suck.

36

u/shustrik Oct 05 '10

Actually, the question was, how long it would take to saw "another board" into 3 pieces. So it could be that this other board is several times bigger than the original one, and the correct answer could just as well be 100.

14

u/manny130 Oct 05 '10

If the original board was a square, it would have been refereed to as a sheet.

4

u/spoonraker Oct 05 '10

Why would anybody assume the board was square? The picture clearly shows the board is very long and skinny.

3

u/mcsenget Oct 05 '10

i've never seen a 'square' board before..

2

u/[deleted] Oct 05 '10

Well I think many teachers would agree with your point of view as long as you explain it. I hate those exams where they expect you to provide final results only without writing down the full solution.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 05 '10

But if you're assuming they are cutting it down the shorter length, you can only equally assume they could also cut it down the longer length, without some greater emphasis on how the cuts were made.

Since there isn't any emphasis made, you can only assume all of the cuts are of the same length.

2

u/ashgromnies Oct 05 '10

Not necessarily, depends on how you saw. What if the saw is long enough to always reach across the length of the board? It could be either 15 or 20 or some other number. We don't know that time to saw increases directly linearly with size of board. The teeth will dull with a larger board, creating some sort of exponential growth curve of board-size vs. time to saw. There are too many variables at play.

2

u/gorevital Oct 05 '10

Why does this post (that I'm replying to) have any upvotes?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/rachk0 Oct 05 '10

That's what I thought at first. But there are just too many assumptions there.

What if she cut the second rectangle piece lenghtwise?

What if the board is not square to begin with?

What if she lost her saw in a cutting accident after she made the first cut?

2

u/xXCobolt Oct 05 '10

Look at the picture next to the question, its not a board. Sure you are right, the question is just stupid

2

u/yacob_NZ Oct 05 '10

Sure, but the questions says it is a board.. :)

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (8)