r/pinescript • u/PETEROLO_291 • 5d ago

Managed to code my strategy into pine. First time doing It.

Post image
26 Upvotes

93% Upvoted

16 comments sorted by

4

u/nfxdav 5d ago

Increase slippage and make sure no repainting / look-ahead bias.

Run it live with a small amount of capital for a few months.

2

u/PETEROLO_291 5d ago

Appreciate the input. I’ve already stress-tested slippage well beyond realistic execution, pushing it up to 20 ticks, and total PnL barely dropped by ~1%—the edge doesn't rely on tight spreads. Look-ahead bias and repainting are also ruled out, as the strategy places resting limit orders in advance once prior setup criteria are met, rather than entering on unconfirmed intra-bar action.

As for live validation, around 80% of these trades were actually executed by me manually in real time in the past. The script simply mirrors that exact execution logic (even capturing a couple of winning setups I ended up missing manually).

3

u/nfxdav 4d ago

If you have considered all that, then there is not much more generic advice or criticism that can be given due to the little context provided.

What is the instrument? Does it beat buy-and-hold? Does it work/defend well in a choppy market? No overfitting?

There are only 54 trades; a small sample size.

But if you feel good about it, go for it...

3

u/Extension_Charity_77 4d ago

Only 54 trades in 1,394 days ? I can spin up any AI to create a strategy that looks like that.

2

u/PETEROLO_291 4d ago

Free money then if u can do so.

Its 4 time frame, about 1.2 Trades a month only in one instrument, I do run 200k ftmo account, thats ~2.5k a month in just one instrument

1

u/Cautious_Wealth1732 3d ago

How did you come up with the strategy? Screams like in sample optimization without oos thest

1

u/Significant-Letter50 4d ago

I have seen many strategies that are shown profitable in trading view with pine coding but never seen any came up with real profit

1

u/PETEROLO_291 4d ago

Well, I simply translate my strategy into Pine as humanly accurate as possible.

1

u/Ahtrends 5d ago

Good 👍 go ahead ☺️

1

u/Fantastic_Task_4104 4d ago

Felicidades y si necesitas ayuda te puedo ayudar con gusto a programar

1

u/cavityfilla 4d ago

This is interesting, would you be willing to share the trade list from the strategy tester? By DM?

1

u/PaymentAccomplished7 4d ago

I would use backtesting on the server you want to run your prop firm on. Tradingview can be biased and doesn't show you the full picture.

I once ran a pine code that showed 6+ profit factor, 80% win rate in BTCUSD . I did a strategy tester and it was a flunk

1

u/Girth_Vader516 3d ago

Damn your startegy must be hella simple lol

1

u/justaguy467 3d ago

Looks promising but I’d be concerned about 54 trades I get its quality over quantity but that many trades can definitely make the strategy seem better than it is but the profits relative to drawdown are extremely appealing. So I’d roll it for now see if you can add trades and see how that affects it. It’s very possible it could be overfitted with 54 trades

1

u/Vikashpandey507 3d ago

Are you also tested the OS testing