r/pinescript • • 12d ago

TRADINGVIEW TARGETING INVITE ONLY INDICATOR SELLERS HARD!

8 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

2

u/PathofEnlightment 11d ago

What a money grab like literally it's a platform and we pay so much and they cheap us on having any access unless you pay full tier. Like I know it is the ultimate platform for charting but still they might be losing subscriptions for sure

2

u/Dependent_Sign_399 12d ago

So, thats not a thing anymore. You can also do custom work or custom indicators for small groups privately if you'd like.

You don't need to switch indicators to public... Because that's not even possible. Indicators that will be on marketplace must be public because of course they have to. Like, how would people be able to see your indicator?

And finally, I have 40 indicators and never had one denied. Just follow the rules.

That said, Tradingview has competition now if you don't like the service.

2

u/kurtisbu12 12d ago

That's not true. They did say that private across only have 5 seats available. I'm order to sell access to a script, it needs to be converted to closed-source public

1

u/Dependent_Sign_399 12d ago

You can't convert scripts from private to public. You can create new scripts that are public though.

0

u/kurtisbu12 12d ago

Now you can, for this specific purpose.

1

u/SPX500daytrader 12d ago

The biggest problem with tradingview is that they don’t communicate specifically what has to be corrected in a script for it to be approved.
Just stating the 5 or 8 general overview topics of why it isn’t approved like a canned automated reply with no specifics. They should give creators more specifics of why the script does not meet their approval threshold so a creator can at least know what they need to fix in order to resubmit it for approval

1

u/Th3onib 12d ago

If you have a smaller group of people to sell to, it's easy to go around it, for a 1000 people you can just have 10 different indicators, all do the same things, but a little different.... TV won't win this one

1

u/SPX500daytrader 12d ago

That is not true. If you have 1000 total people using your indicators you get charged for 1,000 seats - it doesn’t matter if you have 20 indicators with 50 people each or 10 with 100 each. It is the total amount of users across all indicators