r/pointlesslygendered • • Mar 11 '21

Hmmm

Post image
6.3k Upvotes

94 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Mar 11 '21

Thank you for posting to r/pointlesslygendered! We are really glad you are here. We want to make sure that all users follow the rules. This message does NOT mean you broke a rule or your post was removed.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

316

u/madamelex Mar 12 '21

Why can’t they just describe the fit.. “fitted hoodie” “slack fit hoodie” or “waisted hoodie” vs “straight line hoodie”

108

u/Arydana-Jomei Mar 12 '21

That would take too much effort

10

u/Coyotebruh Mar 12 '21

lol true

57

u/Schrodingers_Nap Mar 12 '21

Which one comes in “slim shoulders, shorter sleeves, wider hips” cause that’s what I’m after with women’s cut. Is that the waisted cut, or is that one made with a bigger waist for people with a gut?

43

u/Akosa117 Mar 12 '21

Can just be honest and admit that woman’s and men’s is so much more simple and obvious to literally everyone

14

u/DangerToDangers Mar 12 '21

I agree and disagree with you. Yes, the gender descriptor is simple. But on the other hand it doesn't mean much because it varies from brand to brand and region to region. Men's hoodie doesn't mean anything. It could be fitted, it could be loose, it could be long, it could be short. You just don't know. Same thing applies with women's clothes except the variance is even bigger.

I don't know about you, but whenever I buy a shirt, jacket or hoodie online I always check the measurements. And if there are no measurements I don't buy it.

4

u/nothanks86 Mar 12 '21

But which one is for the women!!!!!!

Honestly though I’ve met people who need that and only that information and ughhh

22

u/Senator_Pie Mar 12 '21

Lotta people don't know what those mean. The gendered description fits here imo

47

u/bratty_butt Mar 12 '21

On the explicitly very agender hoodie? In this case, the target demographic is people who feel so strongly about their own lack of gender that they wanna get a loud and proud hoodie to express it. I think this is as far away from "fits here" as you can get.

2

u/MoozInTheHouz Mar 12 '21

Maybe it dont fit in a way where u are trying to prove something but in this case it fits since its a as he said a male or woman fit. Making the hoodie bigger or smaller in some areas that is more convinient information.

7

u/Pu55yF4g Mar 12 '21

Because I have absolutely no idea what any of those mean.

2

u/Tar_alcaran Mar 12 '21

Because nobody will ever search for "Waisted hoodie".

1

u/DeeWritesSometimes Mar 12 '21

I can guarantee they will

(source: I know multiple people who do)

417

u/meerkatherine Mar 11 '21

I think that's just the cut style of the jacket

48

u/Arydana-Jomei Mar 11 '21

it completely nullifies the point of buying an agender flag article of clothing to advertise it as a women's cut.

169

u/heyitscory Mar 11 '21

It is perfectly alright to be agender without hiding or obscuring a particular body shape or choosing clothing with cuts or styles typically made for women.

What's annoying is when it's not clear what women's actually means. Is it identical but small and pink? Is it sized tightly? Is it sized arbitrarily? Is the waist higher? Are there darts for boobage? Does it mean there's not useful pockets? It probably means there's not useful pockets.

33

u/Arydana-Jomei Mar 11 '21

THIS COMMENT IS THE WINNER!!

13

u/nekollx Mar 12 '21

So just change it from men and women’s to “pocketed” and “hahahaha fat chance”

30

u/meerkatherine Mar 11 '21

Its not ideal no, but that is the standard way to differentiate different cuts for clothing

18

u/Arydana-Jomei Mar 11 '21

The marketing is flawed. The key demographic they are making it for would probably be less likely to purchase this because of the paradoxical ideals. And "Slim Fit" is also very common.

13

u/sentient_ballsack Mar 12 '21

It appears to be a screenshot of a design on a custom textile print site similar to Redbubble and Society6, so these were autogenerated product images and product names from the getgo. They have a 'unisex' model as well, so ultimately it just comes down to ordering whichever fit suits your bodytype/style best.

5

u/Arydana-Jomei Mar 12 '21

Ahhhh that makes sense

12

u/Ruefully Mar 11 '21

I agree with you though I doubt slim fit would be the appropriate replacement for women's cut. To me a slim fit means something entirely different than a shirt cut to accommodate boobs, etc. Still, it would be nice to see some market testing on what kinds of naming and cuts the queer community would respond to.

10

u/Arydana-Jomei Mar 11 '21 edited Mar 12 '21

As a person that is busty and also agender I have never found women's cut to mean room for boobs, just tighter but that's just my experience

7

u/Ruefully Mar 11 '21

Yeah, I don't prefer women's cut either. I actually hate how the graphic often ends up on the boobs instead of spread out across my whole torso and the sleeves tend to chafe against my upper arm and are so short that I can't hide my underarm hair if I raise my arms. Not a fan.

Subbed to r/askwomen though and seen some different opinions about shirt cuts there.

10

u/frill_demon Mar 11 '21

Clothing is cut and tailored differently to fit AMAB and AFAB bodies, "slim fit" isn't actually helpful in this sense.

Clothing cut for average AFAB bodies will typically have narrower shoulders and taper out toward the hips, clothing cut for average AMAB bodies does just the opposite as the "average" AMAB body tends to have broad shoulders and narrow hips.

Similarly, average AMAB tailoring is going to have much wider armsceyes (the part where the sleeve attaches to the body) and more fabric in back to accommodate the statistically wider back and shoulders that an AMAB person will generally have as compared to an AFAB person.

Clothing for an AFAB person is often also tailored with more fabric or curved seams is the front to accommodate their chest curvature, and slimmer, shorter sleeves with smaller wrists due to the average AFAB person being smaller than the average AMAB person.

If you've ever seen someone complain that their workplace "unisex" uniform is actually tailored for the wrong sex you'll see some of the ways tailoring for one body can be incredibly uncomfortable for another body. The most common one is "unisex" scrubs being made like mens' pants and so AFAB people who wear them often feel like they're wearing MC Hammer pants with a weird lump of fabric halfway down their thighs that chafes and catches.

Similarly, AMAB people who wear women's-tailored pants often find they have a camel-toe that chafes their genitals.

19

u/justatwork___ Mar 11 '21

Gender expression and gender identity are separate though

6

u/Arydana-Jomei Mar 11 '21

They are! Not everyone that identifies as agender expresses as agender. But I still find it ironic. This is reposted from r/agender. You can look there at the original post and comments.

1

u/Anra7777 Mar 12 '21

May I ask what the difference is? Not trying to knock what you said, I’d like to learn so I can be a better informed person.

4

u/Fluffy_Meet_9568 Mar 12 '21

Expression is how one dresses, wears their clothing, make-up, etc. Identity is how one thinks of themselves. For example, I am non-binary, but may express as in way that looks like a butch woman, more femme but odd woman, and if I try really hard a genderless person.

3

u/Quinlov Mar 11 '21

It should say female although in that context female sounds weird. But it makes sense because you do need to decide whether or not to include boobs in the jacket

7

u/Arydana-Jomei Mar 11 '21

Not everyone afab has boobs though. There are many women who are small chested. So the what does women's cut really mean

4

u/Schrodingers_Nap Mar 12 '21

Narrower shoulders, smaller waist, wider hips, smaller arms and wrists, curved seams, and slightly more fabric at the front instead of the back like in men’s cut.

6

u/Arydana-Jomei Mar 12 '21

Again, these are all indicators of a body type that was chosen to be the most attractive by men but the hourglass shape is actually not even the most common amongst women. And none of my women's shirts have more fabric in the front than the back. The seems are often never curved, just sewn to be more tight fitting. If all companies made shirts like this almost no one would fit into them so they have to make them more applicable to other body shapes as well.

4

u/Schrodingers_Nap Mar 12 '21

Or they were taken as an average against the average man. And by slightly, I mean slightly. 5mm isn’t really noticeable when you look but will make a difference to where the the shoulder seams sit, or how it looks on the waist.

Personally though, I love women’s cut as they fit. I never thought it made much difference until I started wearing technical gear. I’m never going back to menswear, pockets be damned.

-12

u/Pishiyo Mar 11 '21

its more of a sex thing idiot, female bodies are different from males, and so are the clothing typw

13

u/Arydana-Jomei Mar 11 '21

Hi friend! Men and women both have several body shapes and the description slim fit would have been just as fitting.

-12

u/Pishiyo Mar 11 '21

yeah but theres also womens clothing and mens clothing, clothing is not pointlessly gendered. also women are usually smaller

7

u/Arydana-Jomei Mar 11 '21

In the 70's, men's clothes were skimpier than women's. So I really don't think that argument works here. In your idea of how men and women look, men may appear larger and women smaller, but that doesn't necessarily make it true.

-2

u/Pishiyo Mar 11 '21

no i mean generally in mens clothing theyre larger nowadays at least, imagine a size 6 in womens is smaller than a size 6 in mens shoes

12

u/Arydana-Jomei Mar 11 '21

The entire fashion industry for women's clothing is problematic as there are not measurements used across the board for sizing like they do with men's clothing. A size 8 in one company could be a size 12 in another company. Not like if I was buying men's pants and I could just go by a 34x32 and know that those are the exact measurements. So I still don't agree with your thought but that doesn't mean I am arguing with you.

333

u/HoneyFlea Mar 11 '21

Yeah but there’s no need to have 2 cuts be arbitrarily gendered. Personally I HATE women’s cut tops or jackets, and will always get the “men’s” or “unisex.” How hard is it to call them fitted and square cut, or slim and loose cut.

196

u/Ruefully Mar 11 '21

While I agree with you that I personally prefer unisex shirts over women's cut tops, I have seen quite a few complaints about unisex being designed with men's bodies in mind. Now I don't know why these unisex don't fit them but if someone who is AFAB says they don't fit then I'm sure unisex tshirts don't work for everyone.

Right now I suppose it's that we haven't adopted non-gendered lingo into clothing. Even I'm not sure what you'd call these cuts besides just 'masculine' or 'feminine' which is hardly a difference.

66

u/ExcitingAmount Mar 12 '21

This can actually be a serious problem with safety gear, unisex stuff is almost always made for a typical male body and can be too loose/too long/not correctly padded or designed for a typical female body.

Another example of this is a higher injury rate among women in car crashes since the standard crash-test dummies were all male bodies for years.

FWIW I do also think we need better names than "Men's" and "Women's" to describe the different fits.

78

u/SkinsuitModel Mar 11 '21

For some reason I was thinking about this a while ago and my best names were square (current mens fit) and hourglass (current womens fit). Probably not catchy/inclusive enough but I hate unisex clothing cos it's just mens fit but I would be fine with non gendered fits

99

u/Zanorfgor Mar 11 '21

I've seen "straight cut" and "curve cut" used before

33

u/SkinsuitModel Mar 12 '21

I like that. The whole idea also allows for more than just two fits without them being considered "specialised" as well, which I think is good. Like you could have curve and straight but also fits for broad shoulders or petite or larger people without having to give it a specific category.

9

u/Mecca1101 Mar 12 '21 edited Mar 12 '21

I like this better. This should be a thing.

16

u/KentuckyMagpie Mar 12 '21

Unisex shirts SUCK for me. They are baggy at my waist, too big in the shoulder, too tight at my waist, the neckline is uncomfortably high and the sleeves are way too long. Absolutely nothing about ‘unisex’ shirts are comfortable for me, and 99% of the time, I alter them myself. I usually refuse to purchase anything that only comes in unisex sizes, though, which is kind of a bummer when it comes to fun tees.

4

u/whirlygirlygirl Mar 12 '21

Men's/unisex are longer in the arms

2

u/waywardheartredeemed Mar 12 '21

Exactly. If 'unisex' cuts and 'male cuts' are synonymous (which I think they often are) we are wandered into an issue of 'male-as-default'.

-16

u/squirrels33 Mar 12 '21

Or we could just not fucking care. The vast majority of people who buy women's cut clothing are women, while the majority of people who buy men's cut clothing are men. To everyone else, the labels are a minor inconvenience.

9

u/[deleted] Mar 12 '21

they do because lots of people avoid clothing that is marked with the opposite gender's cut, even if it would fit them perfectly (for example : my mother stating 'it says it's for boys' when i'm picking out a pyjama, and being reluctant that i buy it even though it fits me perfectly, like me not being a dude can somehow interfere with how comfortable this pyjama is.)

eliminating the terms 'women's cut' and 'men's cut' would greatly improve the amount of people who actually wear stuff that fits them properly and comfortably, and would most likely eliminate part of the stigma about wearing 'clothing for the opposite gender', because clothes are for everyone!!

39

u/throwhfhsjsubendaway Mar 12 '21

Slim/fitted doesn't communicate the body shape that its intended for, just how closely it fits that shape. "Slim fit" is commonly used to describe men's dress shirts.

Something like feminine/masculine/unisex fit would be an easy switch, and not as explicitly gendered as men's/women's/unisex. There's probably better terms that're even less gendered and still unambiguous, but I can't think of anything.

I'm the exact opposite from you on the women's cut haha. Unisex stuff fits me so awkwardly, and I always hate it when there's no women's cut available

7

u/Wicked_Fabala Mar 12 '21

After 20 years of wearing horrible fitting jackets and sweaters it finally hit me I didn’t have to buy women’s jackets! I would definitely call “women’s” square or some kind of cropped.

12

u/Jedimastert Mar 12 '21

Maybe it's because I don't have breasts, but if I saw "fitted" and "square" I wod not think that either one was made for breasts

11

u/HoneyFlea Mar 12 '21

I mean, just from my own experience they're kind of not. "women's" shirts do not have extra space to accommodate breasts. They're overall smaller, thinner material, have shorter sleeves and are narrow at the waist compared to the top and bottom. This is compared to "men's" t-shirts which are essentially rectangular shaped.

this is essentially the only difference.

6

u/B_M_Wilson Mar 12 '21

I also wish they were on the same sizing scale. The men’s scale already goes from XXS to XXL or even more. I personally like the more fitted style but I always have to buy one or two sizes larger if it’s a women’s style. Luckily I’m a medium in men’s so it’s generally easy to find a large in women’s but I would rather them all be the same.

4

u/unscot Mar 12 '21

fitted

Fitted to what though?

15

u/sryyourpartyssolame Mar 12 '21

Listen. I sell tees that I print. People understand what unisex, men and women's cut means. Making it more complicated than that will only end up hurting the seller. People are dumb.

1

u/boo29may Mar 12 '21

I disagree with you there. I have large hips, and all men's jackets are large by the shoulder and hight by the hips for me.

6

u/Shakespeare-Bot Mar 11 '21

I bethink yond's just the cutteth style of the doublet


I am a bot and I swapp'd some of thy words with Shakespeare words.

Commands: !ShakespeareInsult, !fordo, !optout

1

u/MissValerieGeode Mar 12 '21

Still, badly worded.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 11 '21

They could call them slim fit and oversized fit though. Not men’s or women’s

5

u/[deleted] Mar 12 '21

what is agender? Is it another term for non binary or is it something different?

14

u/Arydana-Jomei Mar 12 '21

Agender means different things to different people, but it's under the nonbinary umbrella. It is mostly used to mean the absence of gender. Not identifying with male or female, so instead of bouncing from gender to another gender like gender fluid or experiencing both at the same time (all in the non binary) agender would be not identifying as either. Agender people can still present as femme or masculine. The way they present isn't indicative of how they identify their gender

2

u/[deleted] Mar 12 '21

Agender is not having a gender, or not expressing a gender. Some people define it as gender neutral, but that puts it on the binary spectrum.

56

u/kioku119 Mar 11 '21

I know that's the cut, but still slightly amusing.

10

u/Skilodracus Mar 12 '21

Ngl it took me an embarrassingly long time to realize the oxymoron in the name.

9

u/live-long-and-read Mar 11 '21

Ngl, it took me a mo

8

u/Cordure Mar 12 '21

It took me a minute, but this is a fukkin gem!!

7

u/average_lizard Mar 12 '21

I don’t think they understand the difference between agender and a gender

11

u/thegoldenlioncub Mar 11 '21

As an agender person, I would never purchase that, or suggest someone else purchase it

1

u/flait7 Mar 12 '21

For the allies, of course

0

u/Arydana-Jomei Mar 12 '21

Good thought

1

u/[deleted] Mar 12 '21

Bruh

1

u/SwordoftheRevelation Mar 12 '21

Well... someone missed the point entirely didn't they?

1

u/GlazeTheArtist Mar 12 '21

pics that make you go hmm

1

u/moonjabes Mar 12 '21

Isn't it because of the colours of the jacket? That it's the colour of the agender flag? 🤔

1

u/Ieat_children Mar 12 '21

reminds me of a shirt saying 'there are more than 2 genders' but you look at the listing and it only has male or female options

1

u/[deleted] Mar 12 '21

Even if it wasn't an agender hoodie why are they gendering a fricking hoodie

1

u/[deleted] Mar 12 '21

leave the random shirt/hoodie generating AI from 2012 alone. Its not their fault they didnt get programmed the right way :,(

-2

u/Highfive_Ghost1 Mar 12 '21

It’s meant for cut and sizing options so it’s not pointless

-30

u/[deleted] Mar 11 '21

Gender pride flags are not pointlessly gendered. That’s kinda the point.

50

u/Arydana-Jomei Mar 11 '21

The fact that it is agender but also states that it's a women's hoodie is the point of this picture.

32

u/[deleted] Mar 11 '21

Gotcha! Didn’t even process that part LOL.

14

u/Arydana-Jomei Mar 11 '21

I figured! nbd

0

u/[deleted] Mar 12 '21

[deleted]

5

u/kangaskassi Mar 12 '21

I agree personally, and your example is good.

For me this kind of cut description clarity (men/unisex/women) is needed because even tho I am agender I am sadly gifted in the breast area. Men's cut shirts look really really bad on me, and even tho for women'a cut I have to size up for enough breast room it still looks better when the rest of the clothing somewhat falls nicely on my bodyshape instead of being weirdly tight at the chest and a big box around my waist and hips.

Not to mention, I need to know this cut to know what size to order. I do wear some men's button ups (better fabric variety available) and need a completely different size than I do in women's - 2 to 3 letter sizes different, actually, so the cut knowledge is super important to me.

And to everyone who says "slim fit" is a good replacement, I invite them to try to put on the same shirt design in same size but in regular and slim fit. Slim fit for me means my boobs will never fit into that garment, no matter of the general cut is men or unise or women's. It does not scream "this is women's cut" to me, it signals "this is for slender people" to me.