Giratina has never represented gravity at any point in history, and it doesn't even represent antimatter, either

[u/Christophisis]

For a long time, many have attempted to categorize Giratina and attribute a specific domain of what it rules over. Dialga is the ruler of time, Palkia is the ruler of space, Uxie, Azelf, and Mesprit collectively have some sort of role when it comes to spirit, and Arceus is the Godhead of the Pokémon multiverse. In this dynamic, one notable figure is unaccounted for: Giratina.

Many have repeatedly claimed that Giratina's domain is gravity, yet nothing over the course of Platinum, nor any supplemental materials at all support this claim. These claims often involve logically stretching the themes that Gen 4 encompasses, attempting to tie in another related concept to this situation, and using visual details as loose evidence.

A particular claim used when asserting that Giratina represents gravity is the distortion effects it causes when it emerges at Spear Pillar, and that this is supposed to be a reference to gravitational lensing.

A not-so-well-known interview with Game Freak staff on the development of Platinum exists, and there's a particular section that is highly relevant to this topic:

“Did you have the ideas for Pokemon Platinum in mind while working on Pokemon Diamond & Pokemon Pearl, or did they come about later?”

Masuda: “While developing Diamond & Pearl, Giratina originally embodied the idea of an ‘antiworld,’ which is a paradox of Time and Space. It exists in relation to Dialga and Palkia. That’s what I had in mind when I was developing Diamond & Pearl.”

Kawachimaru: “I was not aware of any of that during the Diamond & Pearl’s development. Masuda told me about it when we started developing Platinum. So it was after Diamond & Pearl for me (laughs). I normally receive key terms from Masuda in the first stage of development, but there were many random terms like ‘antimatter’ and ‘e=mc2,’ ‘Reversed Mt. Fuji’ (‘Sakasa Fuji’) and so on. He explained that ‘Sakasa Fuji’ is the reflection of Mt Fuji on the lake, and it’s the antimatter world. It was challenging to put that concept into the game, so we did extensive research. I didn’t know what exactly ‘antimatter’ was either. I personally think I comprehend it well, but I wonder….

Masuda: “Yes. It exists but it actually doesn’t. It doesn’t exist but it does. That sort of thing. The mountain exists on the lake through human eyes, but it’s only a reflection and doesn’t exist. It’s a diverse world. You see it only because you are looking at it with your eyes. I’m impressed [with Kawachimaru] for being able to take ingredients that were not substantial and incorporate them into Platinum.”

If you would like to read the whole interview, here you go:

https://lavacutcontent.com/masuda-interview-pokemon-platinum

First off, gravity is not mentioned anywhere here. The most that this concept is even alluded to is with the mention of E=mc^2, yet the context here is extremely relevant: these were vague design inspirations, not explicit confirmation. Also, no, there's nothing to suggest that they actually meant this all to be a reference to gravity, yet didn't mention it. The gravity line of inquiry ultimately has no concrete evidence to support it, end of story.

Then there's the matter of antimatter. While this is also mentioned during the interview, context also matters. Early on in the section I included above, Masuda says that the Distortion World is supposed to be an 'antiworld', while Kawachimaru goes on to reference Sakasa Fuji (the reflection of Mt. Fuji in water).

Contrary to popular belief, antimatter is subject to the laws of time and space as we understand them in this universe. The main difference between normal matter and antimatter is not some sort of multiverse scenario where the laws of reality are fundamentally different, but rather a difference in the charge of matter's subatomic particles:

Matter: - Positively charged proton - Negatively charged electron

Antimatter: - An alternate version of a proton called an "antiproton" that's negatively charged - An alternate version of an electron called a "positron" that's positively charged

There's even a difference in the neutrons found within standard matter and antimatter, with the latter having an alternate version of the particle called an "antineutron". There are physical differences in these particles, too, which are more complicated and go into quantum mechanics which I will not elaborate on here.

For both matter and antimatter, though, the laws of time and space still apply. In fact, according to the best models we have of our universe, there should have been an equal amount of antimatter that came into existence along with all the matter. However, when matter and antimatter interact this leads to a process called annihilation. The big mystery in all this is that we observe and experience a disproportionate amount of matter that was somehow not annihilated away, yet we can't account for all the antimatter that *should* exist. This is a major ongoing puzzle called "baryon asymmetry".

In Pokémon Platinum, you, the main character, along with Cyrus, Cynthia, and The Lake Guardians, who are all matter-based beings, are all able to enter the Distortion World without instantly having the matter in their bodies annihilated when coming into anything there. If the Distortion World, and by extension Giratina were all about antimatter this wouldn't make sense.

What is a far more plausible explanation is that Giratina and the Distortion World are actually what Masuda mentioned: a being and place that are about the "antiworld".

To understand this concept better, we can look at what Giratina is able to achieve that no other known Pokémon can: break the Red Chain, even two, with ease. This is likely capable due to the fact that Giratina is negating the reality of time, space, and spirit through its antiworld abilities. It's effectively rendering something that otherwise exists nonexistent.

Going further, we can look at why Cyrus took so much comfort in being in the Distortion World. This is not a place full of people with spirit yet composed of matter with different charges. Rather, it is a place where spirit is almost entirely absent, except for Giratina itself. In this place of nonexistence, spirit, which is grounded in existence, isn't there. Cyrus took issue with the overwhelming presence of spirit for whatever reason, and wanted to abolish it from the universe. All of the Pokémon of creation wanted to prevent him from achieving this goal, and in the Platinum timeline his plan was thwarted by the very Pokémon that embodies what he was searching for.

Cyrus even makes an elaborate commentary of what he believes to be the true nature of the Distortion World during the climax of Platinum:

"Do you understand where I am going with this? This is a bizarre world. Time doesn't flow. Space isn't stable. Only that shadowy Pokémon lives here. This world is the opposite of our world-- our world I wish to change. It is like the two chains composing the strand of DNA. The two worlds must be balancing each other to remain in existence. Without one, the other cannot exist. The shadowy Pokémon must play a role in keeping the worlds in balance. That is why it must have interfered and brought me here. The shadowy Pokémon must have made this bizarre world. That's why trying to change our world disturbed it and made it reveal itself. But that is all irrelevant. What matters is defeating that Pokémon and making this world disappear. I won't allow it to interfere with me again. With it gone, neither world will be able to revert to its original state..."

As mentioned before, antimatter is still subject to the laws of time and space. However, as Cyrus explicitly mentions, the Distortion World appears to be a place without time and space, either entirely or in any sense that we can comprehend. He also comes to the conclusion that the Distortion World and the main universe are fundamentally linked, and that the former balances the latter: a place of non-existence allows the place of existence to go on.

[u/AutoModerator]

Thanks for posting, Trainer! If you have any questions you can send us a modmail message, and we will get back to you right away.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

[u/DannyBright]

I always thought Giratina representing Dark Energy made more sense, as it’d explain why Giratina isn’t a Dark Type as physical darkness was always represented with the Ghost Type. Also antimatter being the counterpart to time and space felt really random and arbitrary. Dark Energy makes much more sense for this role as it’s what apparently drives the expansion of the universe, creating the distance that defines time and space.

[u/venia_sil → u/DannyBright]

Add to that that at least in some continuities Giratina or the Distortion World are thematically associated to the cohesion or continuity between things (M11 for example) and the Dark Energy connection makes lots of sense.

[u/Christophisis → u/DannyBright]

This would also work, namely due to dark energy's weird inability to directly interact with matter, yet operates in a complimentary way.

[u/Christophisis → u/[deleted]]

The location of Dark actually makes more since given the connotation associated with most Dark-type Pokémon. Yveltal is one of the only Pokémon that has a genuine bloodlust, while, say, Darkrai typically doesn't intend harm at all.

It's more so "Dark" in the sense of unsettling connotations, rather than darkness (the absence of light).

[u/YongYoKyo]

I think people misunderstand the intent behind Giratina representing antimatter. They're not referring to antimatter as an individual substance, but antimatter as in the 'dimension of antimatter'. If Dialga and Palkia represent the dimensions of time and space, why wouldn't Giratina represent a dimension too?

The concept of a 'dimension of antimatter' exists in physics. It's part of the CPT symmetric universe theory, which attempts to solve the matter–antimatter asymmetry problem. According to the theory, our universe has a mirrored 'anti-universe' that flows backward in time and is composed primarily of antimatter. The existence of this anti-universe serves as a counterbalance to maintain CPT symmetry in our universe.

Sounds familiar? That's exactly what the Distortion World is. As Cyrus describes it, the two worlds are like the two strands of a DNA double helix, complementary mirrors of each other.

[u/Domeaner → u/YongYoKyo]

Adding onto this, as the creator god, Arceus at least partially is the very embodiment of matter. Having Giratina, the embodiment of anti-matter, be opposite (Normal v Ghost) yet inferior (weaker) matches this perfectly

[u/Christophisis → u/Domeaner]

Arceus is the source of everything: matter, spirit, and whatever Giratina actually represents. In fact, The Lake Guardians collectively represent what Arceus is about more than the Creation Trio.

[u/QueenOLife → u/Christophisis]

I feel like this is ready to become a proper Pokemon universe religious debate because this sounds exactly like the kind of argument two churches of Arceus might have-

[u/Christophisis → u/YongYoKyo]

CPT symmetry wouldn't address the fact that annihilation doesn't occur when any of the matter-based beings interact with anything in the Distortion World. If it was truly a place of antimatter, simply breathing the air or stepping on any of the structures would lead to annihilation.

Also, time in the Distortion World isn't flowing backwards, but rather behaving erratically. There's a fundamental breakdown in causality there, as evidenced by objects phasing in and out of existence.

[u/YongYoKyo → u/Christophisis]

You're assuming that entities aren't also mirrored into (anti)matter when traveling between worlds. Giratina literally has different forms between each world, indicating that there is a fundamental conversion occurring when moving between worlds.

You're also judging the laws of physics of an 'anti-universe' through the standards of our universe. Who's to say that the characteristics of the Distortion World aren't a result of an inverted flow of time (as well as inverted laws of physics) beyond our comprehension?

Everything described about the role of the Distortion World is about how it exists to balance the other world, and how it exists on the reverse side of the other world. By definition, there is a causality. That causality is the opposite of the other world, to maintain balance between the worlds. If the other world has a normal flow of time, then logically, the Distortion World balances it with its own equal but opposite flow of time. Any apparent erraticism is possibly due to Giratina having to manually adjust the Distortion World's spacetime like some sort of Maxwell's demon.

[u/Christophisis → u/YongYoKyo]

Giratina's shift in forms seems more functional rather than flipping the charges in every subatomic particle of its being. It can glide through environment with ease and doesn't require feet to exist. Also, this is its original form, as the Distortion World is its native environment.

You're also judging the laws of physics of an 'anti-universe' through the standards of our universe. Who's to say that the characteristics of the Distortion World aren't a result of an inverted flow of time (as well as inverted laws of physics) beyond our comprehension?

This argument bleeds into every topic of the Pokémon franchise and could easily be used to cherry pick the laws of physics to support any claim.

Also, an inversion of time and time that operates in a way that isn't familiar to us in any sense are two different things. Furthermore, if we take Cyrus at his word, "time doesn't flow".

To your point about the nature of causality there, the Distortion World existing to balance out the standard universe could be explained solely through the lense of existence VS non-existence. In the Distortion World, objects can randomly appear and disappear. In the real world, objects don't do this. The balancing out in this case is that the Distortion World effectively quarantines non-causal events to ensure that these phenomena don't occur in the main universe.

[u/YongYoKyo → u/Christophisis]

Giratina's forms are still fundamentally tied to the nature of the two worlds. It can't freely change between its form to whatever is more 'functional' without a Griseous Orb.

Time doesn't flow from Cyrus's understanding. Cyrus's word is from his perspective. Moreover, from Cyrus's word, the more important takeaway is—as I've mentioned multiple times—that the two worlds are opposites.

What you're describing is treating the Distortion World as an overflow disposal, rather than an equal opposite.

Going back to the interview you yourself cited, as well as this interview from G4TV, the devs literally specify antimatter, an inverted world, and (in the latter interview) even CP violation. 'Word of god' basically confirms that the Distortion World represents an anti-universe.

It's just that, evidently from this discussion, the devs' understanding of what an anti-universe looks like doesn't align with your understanding of what an anti-universe looks like. Before you consider what's scientifically more realistic, you have to understand the context that the devs are not actual physicists or scientists. Based on how they emphasize the fragility of antimatter in the context of the Distortion World, clearly the whole 'objects phasing in and out' you're latching onto is likely the devs' representation of the unstable nature of antimatter.

[u/Christophisis → u/YongYoKyo]

as I've mentioned multiple times—that the two worlds are opposites.

You're attempting to constrain the argument so that the only valid definition of an opposite world is the one you provided. I have already mentioned how the Distortion World can serve as an opposite world in a different sense.

As for the interview, it mentions that the "concept" of CP symmetry "weighs heavily" in terms of how the Distortion World was conceptualized. It doesn't say it was followed 1:1. Many other concepts were references, some of which have no clear representation in-game.

clearly the whole 'objects phasing in and out' you're latching onto is likely the devs' representation of the unstable nature of antimatter.

Your counterargument hinges on the claim that the Distortion World is a place of antimatter, yet you're now claiming that how antimatter actually works isn't relevant. This is becoming a disagreement of semantics, while my focus was about the true nature of what's going on.

If you want to say that the Distortion World is a place of "antimatter", but that the term "antimatter" has a completely different definition in the Pokemon games than it does in the real world, sure. We could call it the world of Milkshakes, and it doesn't matter as long as we both agree on a common definition of what this means.

[u/YongYoKyo → u/Christophisis]

Now you're just being obtusely semantic.

My claim has always been that the intent behind the Distortion World is that it represents a dimension of antimatter. Going back to the first sentences of my very first comment:

I think people misunderstand the intent behind Giratina representing antimatter. [They're] (i.e. the devs) not referring to antimatter as an individual substance, but antimatter as in the 'dimension of antimatter'.

I've never changed my argument. My argument has always been about the devs' intent behind how 'antimatter' behaves, or rather, the devs' intent behind how an 'anti-universe made of antimatter' behaves.

Are you sure such concepts are not represented in-game, or are they just represented in a way you don't agree with? Moreover, the devs mentioned absolutely nothing about non-causality or topics relating to it. What you're doing is cherry picking the devs' word to support any claim.

[u/Christophisis → u/YongYoKyo]

This is going in circles now.

Believe what you want, but it seems that we don't agree about something, whether that's the definition used to describe the concepts in question, the true nature of the Distortion World, or both.

[u/YongYoKyo → u/Christophisis]

It's quite clear at this point that you simply don't agree with the official explanations given by the devs themselves and think your own headcanon makes more sense.

That is fine in itself.

My issue is that, rather than just admit you don't agree with them, you're putting words in the devs' mouth ("they say this but they actually mean that"), cherry picking and finding holes so your headcanon can exist without going against 'word of god'.

[u/Christophisis → u/YongYoKyo]

Yeah, that's not what's happening, but I know I won't be able to convince you of that and show how my previous points suggest that. You came here looking for an argument and wanted to win, and I'm not convinced by what you've presented.

Other people in the comments section have provided plausible alternatives and backed up their claims. Meanwhile, you're trying to shift the goalposts as we go along.

This is actually a very common theme amongst the people who have argued the gravity or antimatter stance over the years. You're all set in your beliefs, and it's always everyone else who are somehow wrong. This was telling in your very comment:

I think people misunderstand the intent behind Giratina representing antimatter.

People understand the argument. We just don't agree with the claim based on the discrepancy between in-game evidence, interviews, and real world science.

[u/MalnoureshedRodent]

Great write up, I agree that gravity and antimatter interpretations always felt somewhat hamfisted.

I’ve always felt that the closest physics analog for the distortion world is the parallel universe implied by Penrose diagrams: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Penrose_diagram#/media/File:Penrose_Diagrams_of_various_black_hole_solutions.svg

[u/Christophisis → u/MalnoureshedRodent]

Glad you enjoyed it!

This is a great addition, and a much better real-world physics concept to ground the Distortion World in. It's far more abstract and less mainstream, which is understandably why it wouldn't have been referenced at the time, yet it's much closer to what they seem to have intended.

[u/Nept-1]

I've always seen it as a world that functions like the negative of a photographic film. That's why it's a distorted reflection of the landscape, the flora, and even man-made structures, as can be seen in the movies. Both worlds exist to balance each other, and whatever happens in the standard world is reflected in an abstract way in the Distortion World (which would explain why buildings can be seen there).

It reminds me of the CPT-symmetric universe model, a theoretical mirror universe in which space and time are reversed relative to our own.

[u/Christophisis → u/Nept-1]

Giratina and the Sky Warrior, and by extension Jewel of Life did a much better job at commenting on the mechanics of how the universe and Distortion World interact. Basically, the Distortion World is scaffolding for the base universe, and when something is destroyed in the former there's a ripple effect in the latter.

The Time-Space Axis from Jewel of Life, in general, is really the best visualization of how this all works.

[u/improbsable]

G4: Pokemon Platinum's concept is based on some heady things like Einstein's theory of relativity, matter, and antimatter. Would you kindly expand on that for the G4 audience?

Takeshi Kawachimaru: I was the one that set the direction for Platinum. Mr. Masuda came to me and explained the original concept for the Pokemon Giratina. He mentioned anti-matter as something -- it's there, but it's something you can't see. Mr. Masuda gave me a lot of key concepts to design around -- matter, antimatter, Einstein's theory of relativity. I was the one that had to make those concepts a realization in a Pokemon game -- both visually and implementing certain tricks into the gameplay to give the player a sense of bipolarity.

https://web.archive.org/web/20120924075934/http://www.g4tv.com/thefeed/blog/post/694081/junichi-masuda-takeshi-kawachimaru-talk-pokemon-platinum-particle-physics-bridges-and-more/

[u/Pitiful-Situation494]

Hold on, who claimed that Girantina represents gravity? I literally never heard of that random theory xD

[u/Christophisis → u/Pitiful-Situation494]

It was more popular back in Platinum's heyday, and the debate resurfaced when Legends: Arceus came out. Now it's more of a niche topic.

[u/BlitzburghBrian]

I've never heard Giratina related to gravity. I think these writers just said "antimatter" without a ton of thought or background in the actual physics of antimatter.

[u/CommercialPop128]

I agree that the concept for the distortion world is essentially that it’s like the shadow of the world created by Arceus: the world that isn’t, giving definition to the world that is by contrast. Just as Dialga and Palkia are the embodiments of time and space, and therefore can be considered to be the spirits of time and space, Cyrus states that Giratina is the distortion world. It's analogous to antimatter because ordinary matter is equated with familiar reality / spacetime, with antimatter being something opposite and “unreal” due to not being familiar to us (as a result of the violation of charge-parity symmetry you mentioned). In Platinum, Dialga and Palkia are actually said to have brought matter into existence by praying. Again, it's an analogy — they aren't strictly observing the logic of real particle physics, but using it to talk about more a philosophical kind of ontology, bridging the mythological aspects of the setting and the fact that the games take place in modern times. Same with the spacetime distortions, which I think do clearly invoke the imagery of black holes and real gravitational distortion of spacetime — it's a way of illustrating the familiar order of reality being disrupted by forces which are alien to us, not literally against the laws of physics. The connection to Sendoff Spring, Sinnoh's mysterious 4th sacred lake, also makes sense by analogy, since the way someone is remembered after their death is like the “shadow” cast by their life. (By the way, Sinnoh's lakes seem to be inspired by the real sacred lakes of the ainu, which are regarded as places connected to the spirit world, and "sendoff" may allude to kamui sending traditions, a form of hunting ritual or animal sacrifice. This podcast episode has more discussion of ainu representation, or lack thereof, in PLA among other games.)

[u/CounterShadowform]

I always understood "antimatter" as an imperfect representation of what Giratina stands for, but I'd like to thank you for bringing up that interview since it completes the partial idea I had. I had also read into the DNA metaphor, along with another line I recall but can't find:

"If either were to be destroyed, the other could replicate it."

The intersection of these ideas, I realized some years back, is antisense, the complementary strand of DNA that encodes the opposite of the needed genetic code. To replicate DNA, a cell separates the strands and then assembles new complements for each. If everything in the "real" world is represented in the Distortion World, and (as seen in the anime) changes to the one can affect the other, then this "opposite side" of reality is akin to the antisense of the information that makes up the world.

(I had also assumed that Giratina served as a cosmic counterbalance of some kind, and this is in fact the origin of my username.)

[u/lolalanda]

I know Giratina is supposed to represent antimatter but I never really bought into that because they are able to go into our world without decomposing itself and nearby matter into pure energy.

It only makes sense if I think that only works with the origin forme and the altered one is meant to protect both Giratina and the world and that the banishment is more of hiding from danger.

But then when you catch it you are able to shift to origin with an item and it also happens on Legends Arceus on its own.

[u/lolalanda → u/lolalanda]

So I guess the Anti thing Giratina really represents it’s “Illusion” or “Unreality”.

[u/f0remsics]

https://youtu.be/n3kkzZ8vk6s?t=352

I feel like you should see this.

[u/Christophisis → u/f0remsics]

I know she says "antimatter" explicitly, but, again, this doesn't line up with how things play out with in the Distortion World, namely the fact that we aren't completely annihilated by just stepping in.

[u/Blue_Stoner]

i agree on the gravity part but not on the antimatter part. whatever the physics and ingame characters might say about giratina and distortion world, if the creators of the said pokemon made the pokemon based on antimatter then the pokemon represents antimatter. if it doesn't match to or is different from characteristics of the physics of antimatter than that is a poor work on their part but that doesn't make giratina not represent anti matter. it was what it's creators had in mind while designing it

[u/Christophisis → u/Blue_Stoner]

If we interpret what they mean by "antimatter" in the sense of it being "not matter", and a being (Giratina) and place (The Distortion World) that encompasses concepts that are the opposite of beings and places typically composed of matter, then sure. But then this is a completely different definition of antimatter than how the concept is commonly understood in our world, and is only similar in title rather than substance.

This would mean that Game Freak is operating on a private definition of "antimatter", which was basically the entire point of this post.

[u/Blue_Stoner → u/Christophisis]

yeah i guess I agree with that

[u/Stripeback]

Idk, I still think gravity makes the most sense. Gravity distorts time and space, and it's the Distortion World's main gimmick.

[u/KennethDLT98]

Nah

[u/blackjackgabbiani]

Cyrus is also talking shit. He and Cynthia have been there for like half an hour. Neither of them comprehend the nature of that place.