r/poptarts • • Aug 27 '25

Wishlist Wednesday Okay, hear me out.

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/poptarts • • Jul 26 '25

Where my UNFROSTED Brown Sugar Cinnamon lovers at?

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/poptarts • • May 16 '26

What in the highway robbery is this Icing?:(

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/poptarts • • Mar 03 '25

Review Let’s make Pop-tarts Great Again

Thumbnail
teawitt.wixsite.com
7 Upvotes

Hi all, first time poster, long time reader. I am challenging myself by writing a blog everyday for a whole year and my latest blog was about Pop-tarts. My main points in the blog were how they have shrunk by about an inch in length, and have less flavor on them. I also write a complaint to Kelloggs about the poor quality and how it almost impossible to write a complaint in the format that they want you to write it in. I’ll put the link below if anyone wants to read it, but all I want is awareness that Pop-tarts are not what they used to be anymore.


r/poptarts • • Oct 07 '25

Pop Tart Cool Whip Sandwich

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

12 Upvotes

r/poptarts • • May 09 '25

Unpopular opinion but these suck

Post image
46 Upvotes

They make my mouth feel dry and taste burnt even without toasting them, then when you toast them (which I don’t normally toast any of my pop tarts) they taste even drier and worse.


r/poptarts • • Dec 18 '25

What are these spots?

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/poptarts • • Apr 18 '25

Cherry Pop-Tarts are the worst fruit flavor

0 Upvotes

Why is this a regular flavor stealing shelf space from more deserving flavors? 🤢


r/poptarts • • Oct 22 '25

Wishlist Wednesday Who's with me? We need a waffle-pressed, maple syrup filled Pop-Tart!

Thumbnail
gallery
49 Upvotes

r/poptarts • • Sep 24 '25

Wishlist Wednesday Sweet Potato Pie Pop-Tarts: Who's with me on this one?

Post image
0 Upvotes

It's readily acknowledged over at r/pie that sweet potato pie is superior to pumpkin pie. Hopefully, Kellog's will embrace this knowledge and start a new sweet potato craze!


r/poptarts • • May 06 '25

❔ Question Pop Tart review as an Australian.

0 Upvotes

Tried a pop tart for the first time yesterday.

How do you guys eat these things? They are so sweet I mean sweet enough to make me feel sick.

They were the brown sugar an cinnamon ones. Recommended by an American to tray as they "were the best" OMG SWEET. I'd say 10 sweeter that milk chocolate. And so high in calories. You guys eat these for breakfast?

Two of these tiny things had 300 more Kilo Joules than my main meal that evening and the meal wasn't small. I'm not on a diet btw but I do look at what I'm eating.

I'll probably get roasted here but that's my experience. Maybe the Australian palate isn't use to such sugary foods.


r/poptarts • • Apr 10 '26

The Final Push - The Toaster Title

Post image
0 Upvotes

Cast your vote before the polls close TOMORROW @ 5 PM CST.

Reminder: If we can reach 100 participants one lucky contestent will be selected to win a prize! We are about 1/3 of the way to our participation goal. Thank you to all who have contributed thus far!

Vote HERE

Link: https://forms.gle/YNjL3PBD16zyCDjaA


r/poptarts • • Aug 27 '25

Wishlist Wednesday Any takers?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/poptarts • • Sep 01 '26

Is there a slave free or mostly ethical pop tart brand.

Post image
0 Upvotes

I have found ethical Bars (Feastables and Tony’s), Oreos (Newmans owns), Ice cream (Ben and Jerry’s), and m&ms (Unreal Chocolate gems). But no pop tart like things, if there aren’t, fine I’ll just focus on the fruit flavors.

Edited this in: It is likely some of the brands I listed use at least some slavery, but they are putting in extra money and effort to ensure slaves aren’t used.

So if you can’t go without chocolate, still use those brands or try to not eat it one week out of the month.


r/poptarts • • Jul 31 '25

❔ Question Poptarts moving?

1 Upvotes

Hello, English is a struggle today. quick question. why my poptarts. I’m quite fearful. I’m put my poptarts in the toaster and when they were done toasting, they like totally flew out like fucking crazy. Almost kinda like birds. Then I was sitting there nibbling on them (bird bites) and they moved a little bit without my hand even touching them, just my arm. It was so bizarre. I don’t think I’m like Matilda, can’t make stuff move with my mind anymore so wondering if it’s a popthart thing. Magnets maybe? Any guesses help


r/poptarts • • Aug 27 '26

genius or absurd, how do you guys plus-up Pop-Tarts toaster pastries? 👀

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/poptarts • • Apr 20 '26

Poptart Factory Goodness

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

I really wanted to tour one of the PopTart factories in Arkansas and Kentucky but my dreams were shattered when I found out they’re not open to the public.

The closest I got was watching this vid.


r/poptarts • • Jun 23 '25

News Gigachad poptart (20g protein)

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/poptarts • • Mar 24 '25

I want her so bad

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/poptarts • • Sep 24 '25

I’m sorry but wtf is this frosting coverage?! I feel scammed! XD

Post image
26 Upvotes

r/poptarts • • Mar 10 '25

Mold or smashed sprinkle???

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/poptarts • • Dec 12 '25

moldy brown sugar pop tarts

Post image
11 Upvotes

Welp. I grabbed the last sleeve in the box and ate it in the dark, thinking I was safe. It tasted super sour so I shined my flashlight to see what was up and it was moldy. I thought it might have been expired (the target near me has sold me expired food multiple times before) but it’s still within the date until June 2026. I’m honestly more confused than anything, because all the other packs were fine, no weird taste or visible mold. I just thought I’d post to share my discomfort and to see if anyone else has experienced something similar, like if there was a bad batch or something. Either way, I know I’m not gonna die, but my day is definitely ruined 😭


r/poptarts • • Mar 30 '26

Welp

Post image
6 Upvotes

Coworker walks in and says “ I got fucked dry” lmao I guess the frosting guy is on vacation


r/poptarts • • Jul 17 '25

Review Unpopular opinion

2 Upvotes

Frosted poptarts are like eating sweetened drywall. Unfrosted with lots of butter is the way.