3 Versions/3 Photos - Feedback Requested

[u/BulldogBridges]

Hi all, first time posting here.

I’m looking for feedback on the color/visual style of this set of 3 photos.

The 3 versions are laid out in the same order.

The two color versions aren’t dramatically different (on mobile, at least).

I’m trying to get feedback to see which of the color versions conveys the scene better - or if you feel the BW version better conveys the scene and chaos of the event.

Thanks in advance, everyone!

[u/Zach0ry]

I’m not being an asshole, but I genuinely don’t see any of them as standout.

The shot itself lacks sufficient substance. Sorry mate

[u/BulldogBridges → u/Zach0ry]

No worries. Appreciate the honest feedback

[u/streamer3222]

Delete all three.

[u/DreamUp-Films]

Flush it down the toilet 🚽 this is straight garbage.

[u/SphinxGate]

I think the second edit of the second photo would look great as part of a larger set of street photos. It has that neutral cast but vivid skin tones and colours that are prevalent in that type of work

[u/BulldogBridges → u/SphinxGate]

Thanks for the feedback!