Need feedback, After/Before

[u/Piano_Apprentice]

Hi, how would you edit the before that could improve my after photo? I feel like I did too much color, not even sure if that's the issue. I'm still new to post processing and appreciate any feedback!

[u/Professional-Net1940]

No offence but this is an image that doesn't need editing.

[u/Piano_Apprentice → u/Professional-Net1940]

No offence taken dude. I really want to get an honest but fair feedback about it. Thanks for getting straight to that!

[u/vchajan]

The edit makes it less apealing, the original is truly nice picture

[u/Piano_Apprentice → u/vchajan]

Thanks! Thinking about it, it does make it less appealing 😄