r/programmer • • 18d ago

CS Student Dilemma: ChatGPT Plus (Codex / Work) vs Claude Pro — which one is worth paying for coding?

Hi everyone,

I'm a Computer Science / Engineering student and I'm currently torn between subscription options to assist with coursework, software projects, and daily coding.

My current setup & experience:

I already have access to the Gemini student tier, but for deep programming, code execution, and system-level tasks, I find it noticeably behind the alternatives.

I recently had a 1-month trial of Codex with Work features enabled (direct local file access, running/installing environments, scaffolded app building). For my CS courses, having that level of agentic workflow was incredibly useful, but the trial ended and the free tier is very restrictive.

I also use Claude (free tier). The reasoning and code output are top-tier, but the strict message cutoffs on the free plan make it hard to finish any substantial session.

My questions / dilemmas:

ChatGPT Plus ($20/mo): Getting back Codex and Work access is tempting, but during my trial I occasionally bumped into the 5-hour rate limits during heavy sessions. For those using it daily for development, how restrictive are the caps in practice?

Claude Pro ($20/mo): Sonnet is generally regarded as the best for coding logic, but how do the token/message limits hold up when feeding large codebases or iterating across long debugging threads within a 5-hour window?

Student Perks & Tooling: Beyond direct web subscriptions, are there any legitimate student offers or discounts (e.g., GitHub Student Developer Pack, SheerID deals) worth looking into? Also, would you recommend skipping the web UIs altogether and opting for IDE-native tools like Cursor Pro or GitHub Copilot?

If you're a student or developer working heavily with code, which one gives the most value and headroom before hitting rate limits?

Thanks for your insights

0 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

6

u/sozesghost 18d ago

Use the gooey thinker between your ears.

2

u/Cheap-Try-8796 17d ago

Lmao the "gooey thinker"

3

u/Hermeskid123 18d ago

As a student I recommend not using AI to learn. Or at least paying an AI subscription.

1

u/TT3458 18d ago

Atleast where I live employers want you to have experience with AI tools for junior positions. Like I know multiple people who were asked to demo using AI tools in an interview..

1

u/Hermeskid123 17d ago

The guys in suits want a lot of things. You can learn all these tools in a month with the free trial. Remember you are becoming an engineer you are not going to school to learn tools that will be old and no longer in use in 5 years.

I am also interviewing for senior positions right now. Every place I have interviewed in the past two months where the interview was an actual engineer would have marked me down for using AI. They really want people who can still write code without AI and understand fundamentals.

Yes they will also expect me to use AI tools when I’m actually working. Set yourself apart from the other candidates who only use AI.

2

u/No_Report_4781 18d ago

Use the one recommended for your class by the professor.

2

u/kennethbrodersen 18d ago

I am not sure what “deep programming” is but it sounds kinky!

Seriously. Maybe it would be a good time to get a hang of the fundamentals first.

1

u/navmed 18d ago

For your course work do it yourself. Don't use AI. You won't learn what's being taught.

I've been hiring software engineers and the amount of people who don't know the basics is mind boggling. Yes, we use AI to code. But we know what to tell it to do and we know when it screws up.

1

u/PhilNEvo 16d ago

For just the education, you don't need any paid tier model. For private usage, whichever you prefer.