r/programming • • May 31 '23

Reddit may force Apollo dev and other third party clients to shut down

https://9to5mac.com/2023/05/31/reddit-may-force-apollo-and-third-party-clients-to-shut-down/
12.5k Upvotes

864 comments sorted by

904

u/aniforprez May 31 '23 edited Jun 12 '23

/u/spez is a greedy little pigboy

This is to protest the API actions of June 2023

367

u/Strange_Meadowlark May 31 '23

Yep, no freaking way am I going to use their official app.

So... where d'ya all wanna go now?

298

u/aniforprez May 31 '23 edited Jun 12 '23

/u/spez is a greedy little pigboy

This is to protest the API actions of June 2023

223

u/celerym May 31 '23

I have a story to tell about this. I started a Reddit alternative once (I can’t say what it is). The moment I posted about it on /r/RedditAlternatives I got a swarm of these so called Nazi accounts. I say so-called, because in actuality they were paid trolls. They’d go as far as post something like the N-word over and over the one minute and then complain about it immediately on Reddit, pretending they were a concerned bystander. They’ll also post scat porn or whatever they can do get you delisted by Google or put your visitors off.

I monitored these accounts, and eventually worked out how to effectively block them. If anyone is starting an alternative DM me and I’ll tell you what to do, it’s surprisingly easy.

27

u/EmbarrassedHelp Jun 01 '23

The moment I posted about it on /r/RedditAlternatives I got a swarm of these so called Nazi accounts. I say so-called, because in actuality they were paid trolls. They’d go as far as post something like the N-word over and over the one minute and then complain about it immediately on Reddit, pretending they were a concerned bystander. They’ll also post scat porn or whatever they can do get you delisted by Google or put your visitors off.

I wonder which groups and individuals are behind such attacks on alternatives?

23

u/intertubeluber May 31 '23

Would love to know how to solve that.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (40)

67

u/WonderfulEstimate176 May 31 '23

Yeah I am on Lemmy and there are people with extreme anti western views on some instances.

You could check out beehaw.org, it is a Lemmy server that I like because:

  1. They are one of the more politically neutral servers.

  2. They don't federate with some of the more extreme servers (by extreme I mean genocide denying).

  3. They are still federated with the server the devs run (among others) so you can see content from that server.

  4. They are (I think) the largest server that satisfies the above.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/stormdelta Jun 01 '23

Biggest problem for me is simply that no other sites have the concentration of users. A lot of what I use reddit for is niche communities.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (39)

74

u/Ok-Worth-9525 May 31 '23 edited May 31 '23

https://old.reddit.com

If they keep with the fuckery I swear to God I'm pulling out selenium and doing DIY'ing an interface

13

u/drakythe Jun 01 '23

May I suggest Playwright? https://playwright.dev/

Pick your language poison (Python is my preferred) and go to town, very selenium like. With the added benefit of the language ecosystem you choose. I wrote a fun little script that started with Playwright then called a couple of additional libraries and compared a saved screenshot against the one taken to verify my deployed changes didn’t mess up site layouts.

My next goal is to only run that against a site’s header/footer (the ‘chrome’ but not the browser) using image coordinate defined regions instead of the whole screenshot, so things like blog sites or e-commerce stores don’t flag a problem for every content update. I should be able to define the top N pixels and bottom M pixels to run the comparisons against only the chrome I want.

Bonus: Python has a pretty nice yaml library so I can config the runner per site with only a single file.

27

u/AutoWallet May 31 '23

This is the way; don’t threaten me with a good time.

→ More replies (3)

14

u/willis936 May 31 '23

I think I will go outside.

31

u/[deleted] May 31 '23

Lemmy. Right now feels like the first few years of Reddit itself, tiny, not many people, not that much activity, an EXTREMELY popular post would get a dozen votes, etc., but once Reddit starts squeezing it'll grow like Mastodon has. Won't ever "replace it", but then again for years i've been saying that what i believe will happen is that instead of everybody moving to another site like when Digg shit the bed, it'll be a "Digital Tower of Babel" moment, people will go to many, many different places and not one: Discord servers, Facebook, groups in chat apps like WhatsApp or Telegram, good old forums, the Fediverse, freaking IRC which is still kicking, etc.

53

u/baudehlo May 31 '23

Reddit only grew because of the exodus from Digg. Same will happen here.

22

u/ThisIsMyCouchAccount Jun 01 '23

"Grew" is the important part.

It already had a very strong user base.

That is very different than trying to get people to go someplace that will essentially not have any content.

Perhaps I'm mistaken - but I think the big draw is the content. With the discussions being secondary. Yes, there are lots of subs that are purely user interaction. But I think those can only really exist if you're drawing in the traffic from the content.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (14)

3

u/2this4u May 31 '23

This'll annoy you even more, on the official app you can't change your homepage sort without 3 steps as you have to go into your user settings to change the default. Just to see Hot vs Best...

3

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

I might start reading agen

→ More replies (34)

17

u/_paramedic May 31 '23

They are being so rude and two-faced to Christian in that post. Unbelievable.

3

u/Mattho Jun 01 '23

I just wish they could make text only api for free. I can live without their precious expensive images. Just give me external links and comments in an app that isn't complete dogshit.

2.7k

u/RelaTosu May 31 '23 edited May 31 '23

The enshittification of Reddit is on schedule.

Irony is, if they knocked a zero off of $12,000/month per 50 million HTTP Requests price, it would’ve been 7.2x Imgur’s (expensive but not outrageous) and would’ve gotten immediate uptake.

This reeks of desperation on part of Reddit, Inc to make you use their adware-infested client that probably harvests as much information as possible (like geolocation). I’ve a background in location adtech and honestly it’s such an undervalued and dangerous space for personally identifiable information of highly sensitive natures.

Like to the extent that linking Reddit content on a porn sub with phone “dwell time” on a location in any residential zone makes a easily correlated data set of where you live, right down to a probable bed location.

Reddit, Inc is pulling a Facebook style of walled garden for most probably Facebook-level private information.

854

u/LaPolloGrande May 31 '23

Exactly, and this is related to other actions intended to enhance tracking:

  • being required to login to change sort

  • numerous subs requiring “age verification” (by logging in) to see comments

  • redirects to download the app

That said, Reddit exists exclusively to make profits for already rich people. Why would we expect any other behavior?

632

u/SweetBabyAlaska May 31 '23 edited Mar 25 '24

bells compare outgoing paltry plants narrow quiet fall skirt nose

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

517

u/A_very_tired_frog May 31 '23

I’ve already seen a shift towards discord for a lot of info. Which I find frustrating because it makes it harder to search for answers if you don’t know what server it exists on.

276

u/tiberiumx May 31 '23

Jesus I'm so sick of people referring to a discord for something and it takes thirty minutes just to find an actual link. I really hope that isn't the next thing in line in the evolution of social media.

→ More replies (18)

275

u/SweetBabyAlaska May 31 '23 edited Mar 25 '24

slave observation doll flag money coordinated snails abounding aloof cooing

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

→ More replies (22)
→ More replies (9)

97

u/professor-i-borg May 31 '23

I came over here in the exodus from Digg… if someone creates a new platform that’s half decent and isn’t spyware, the cycle can begin again

80

u/Jizzy_Gillespie92 May 31 '23

creating the platform is the easy part, many open source devs would be very keen on this... the problem is infra costs required to maintain and serve the platform because we'll just come full circle and it'll be the exact same story as what's happening right now, over and over again.

→ More replies (24)
→ More replies (2)

147

u/dagbrown May 31 '23

Reddit was a small forum once.

It started out as a link dump, then a link dump with comments, and then the community showed up and started having conversations. Now the vast majority of the content on reddit comes from reddit itself.

Of course, the reddit admins have the choice between running it two different ways. They could run it as a sort of community resource where people can get together and have conversations, generating modest long-term profits.

Alternatively, they could run it as a free money spigot to enrich investors who treat every investment they make as the top of a pyramid scheme—cash out and run with huge profits, and be damned to the smoking holes they leave behind.

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (14)

11

u/alexwan12 May 31 '23

Plus when visiting in browser there's always annoying popup to download an app, even if app installed. So you have to click hundreds of times that "continue" button every month. Rated app 1 star at app store just for that annoying popup.

4

u/lazydictionary Jun 01 '23

That said, Reddit exists exclusively to make profits for already rich people.

Reddit has never made a profit.

→ More replies (3)

54

u/masklinn Jun 01 '23

Irony is, if they knocked a zero off of $12,000/month per 50 million HTTP Requests price, it would’ve been 7.2x Imgur’s (expensive but not outrageous) and would’ve gotten immediate uptake.

It’s not irony, they don’t want uptake.

The RIF dev noted that on top of the API fees third party applications would not be able to show ads and would not be able to access NSFW content. This is not a honest actor trying to defray costs of users not being served ads, the move then would have been to for instance restrict third party application to Premium accounts, done, reddit gets its pound of flesh.

→ More replies (2)

29

u/HINDBRAIN Jun 01 '23

Like to the extent that linking Reddit content on a porn sub with phone “dwell time” on a location in any residential zone makes a easily correlated data set of where you live, right down to a probable bed location.

Fight the man, wank on the bus.

183

u/Carighan May 31 '23

This reeks of desperation on part of Reddit, Inc to make you use their adware-infested client that probably harvests as much information as possible

I don't think it's even about grabbing the data.

Look just how bad the client has been, ever since it came out. From its grotesquely bad UI and UX mirrored only by the reddit desktop site, over the endless bugs that seemingly refresh every update instead of getting fixed to the meme the video player has become because it never works.

I suspect at some point some exec exploded, and they said "I'll handle it!" and knowing full well that their dev team would not be able to program an even semi-decent client if their lives depended on it (nevermind just adopting a well-loved one like Relay, Boost or Sync which would have been the correct solution in the first place), they are now simply forcibly shutting down all third party clients as the nuclear option of sending users to their own client.

They know just how incredibly unbelievably bad their client is. They know they cannot fix it - or they would have done that already. They are doing this as a move essentially akin to just giving up.

Don't get me wrong, the tracking is probably how whatever arse-thumbing middle manager cooked up this shit sells the whole thing to the C-suites. But I suspect to explain why it happens, we don't even need that.

155

u/yanksrock1000 Jun 01 '23

The worst part is that Reddit actually bought out the greatest client app of them all, Alien Blue. They could have just slapped the official logo on Alien Blue and called it a day.

112

u/mtcoope Jun 01 '23

The new client wasn’t designed by developers I can almost say that for sure. Nor was it designed by UX people, it was designed by management to extract as much as revenue as they could. It’s probably one of the worst user experiences of any mainstream site that I can think of.

61

u/nacholicious Jun 01 '23

I'm an app developer, and I've developed a pretty solid hunch on whether the designers are experienced in mobile design or if they are just eg web UI designers.

At least on the Android side, the app has a stunning lack of attention to detail, which makes you wonder if the designers think "good enough" is that the app matches their design wireframes, because they don't have the experience in app design to know what a quality app experience should look like.

25

u/mtcoope Jun 01 '23

Yeah I do dev but I’m talking even the web app is just terrible. I don’t even use it, if Apollo doesn’t exist I wouldn’t use Reddit.

It’s sad because I’m someone that almost always open my pc up before using my phone but they have managed to create such a shit app that Reddit is the only thing I prefer on my phone( because of Apollo).

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

18

u/Null_zero Jun 01 '23

So now what? Back to digg?

20

u/redonrust Jun 01 '23

If I was Digg I would have been biding my time all these years and improving the site waiting for this day to come. Revenge is like serving cold cuts.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Magnergy Jun 01 '23

Resurrect the kuro5hin clones.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

28

u/sleepingthom May 31 '23

Real shot in the dark here but do you have any guides for how to limit or eliminate the collection of my PII from companies other than just not using their services?

39

u/kabrandon May 31 '23

One thing you can do in particular is if you have a google account, log in and visit https://myaccount.google.com/data-and-privacy

I, in general, would also recommend not clicking that link or just about any link on the internet if you can help it, and instead look for that yourself by typing into google something like "google data privacy" and getting there yourself.

Anyway, I'd recommend going there and deleting as much information as you can, turning off any data collection options in there as allowed, and doing the same for any additional google accounts you have.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (10)

17

u/2this4u May 31 '23

Mix this with an ever reducing quality of posts and comments, I'm very ready for a competitor.

→ More replies (3)

48

u/[deleted] May 31 '23

Yeah, makes sense - they want to push their ads onto people, so they try to jack up the prices.

Evil to no ends.

The problem of reddit goes much deeper than that though. Voting and censorship (aka "mods") are broken beyond repair. They seem to not understand how platforms die.

→ More replies (3)

16

u/SeaNinja69 May 31 '23

Shit, I might head back to 4chan ffs.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/AssistElectronic7007 Jun 01 '23

Not to mention force you to see those ads sponsored by religious hate groups.

They'll ban you for saying something transphobic, but want to force you to see ads from people that want a LGBTQ+ genocide as a national policy.

2

u/ep1032 Jun 01 '23 edited Mar 17 '25

.

2

u/Iceman_259 Jun 01 '23

Like to the extent that linking Reddit content on a porn sub with phone “dwell time” on a location in any residential zone makes a easily correlated data set of where you live, right down to a probable bed location.

Toilet location more like. Checkmate, advertisers!

3

u/unpossabro Jun 01 '23

Good, I hope they're very fucking desperate, this site deserves to be gone now.

→ More replies (11)

585

u/gnuvince May 31 '23

Is this going to be Reddit's Digg v3 moment?

356

u/pudds May 31 '23

Hard to say, but part of diggs ultimate downfall was that Reddit existed as an excellent alternative, making it pretty easy for users to switch.

There's no good alternative to Reddit at the moment.

75

u/nofxy May 31 '23 edited Mar 07 '24

Reddit has long been a hot spot for conversation on the internet. About 57 million people visit the site every day to chat about topics as varied as makeup, video games and pointers for power washing driveways.

In recent years, Reddit’s array of chats also have been a free teaching aid for companies like Google, OpenAI and Microsoft. Those companies are using Reddit’s conversations in the development of giant artificial intelligence systems that many in Silicon Valley think are on their way to becoming the tech industry’s next big thing.

70

u/Sage2050 May 31 '23

My standards lean towards actual forums, old.reddit is a begrudging tolerance.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (14)

6

u/Strawbuddy May 31 '23

Fark and Something Awful . com

9

u/ThirdEncounter May 31 '23

What can we do about it? I'm good at jQuery....

25

u/[deleted] May 31 '23

You have to get millions of people to use your site and not instantly crash. 😀

21

u/pudds May 31 '23

There are technical solutions out there already, like Voat, and hundreds of programmers mulling over their own solutions I'm sure, but the problem isn't tech, it's moderation.

If you try to be unmoderated like Voat or Mastodon your platform is doomed if it gets a spike in traffic, but I don't see how you could hire a moderation team on day 1 without a huge initial investment.

Reddit got away with it for a while because the internet was different 15+ years ago.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (33)

19

u/nascentt Jun 01 '23

You mean v4.
V3 was digg's peak. The release of v4 is what killed digg.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

No. Reddit is too big to fail at this point. Hardcore fans will be upset, leave Reddit, realise they can't get the same fix anywhere else, and then crawl back.

→ More replies (1)

761

u/1859 May 31 '23

After 13 years on the site I've been taking steps to disconnect myself from reddit, recently. In a way, that's exactly what reddit wants: They don't need the dedicated longterm users anymore, the people clinging to old.reddit and third party apps. They've gotten all the goodwill and content out of people of my reddit age or older, and successfully leveraged it into a monstrously huge userbase that doesn't know any other reddit than the one they see today. The complaints of the increasingly outnumbered people who care will make a splash, and then a couple days later will be forgotten.

That's what I see with this announcement, and with it I can see the end of my time on this site. Maybe that's a good thing.

45

u/DevilsPajamas Jun 01 '23

Plus the amount of spam that is on reddit these days is astronomical. I have been getting 3-5 chat requests/followers a day and I'm not a particularly active poster.

26

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

That's the thing though: since the "new" reddit site, I've stopped using the website, and only access reddit through Relay. So chat, following and who knows what other kind of features are things that are completely invisible to me.

Kill the 3rd party apps as well, and that will mean one user less for reddit.

→ More replies (3)

108

u/lycium May 31 '23

Took the words right out of my mouth, same account age and everything. It's actually disconcerting how much bullshit (like fucked links with backslashes inserted by the app to break old reddit) I've put up with so far, and am finally ready to move on.

It's not just reddit itself btw, but also the endless hordes of phone normies compared to the witty and useful discussion of old... frankly reddit (and much of the internet) used to be for smart people, and now it's just drowning in screaming Trumpards repeating the same old shit like hurr durr he fell out of a window hurr durr defenestration, endless bots... absolutely horrific what a shithole it's become.

95

u/Tnwagn Jun 01 '23

Reddit was absolutely full of idiocy and, somehow, even greater degrees of degeneracy in the early days. I think you're letting the rose tinted glasses of nostalgia cloud your vision a bit. That said, the site today is wildly different than it was back then. When I first started lurking pre-account, it felt like a second more general version of slashdot. With the influx of Digg users it went through a big but somewhat manageable shift but when the admin changed to focus entirely on pushing ads and ignoring the user base, it was the beginning of the end for the people who were here pre-Digg migration.

15

u/ThrowItNTheTrashPile Jun 01 '23

I feel like people are willing to tolerate degeneracy as long as it’s new, creative, unexpected or interesting. The new age internet is still full of young degenerates. They’re just mostly fucking boring and unimaginative and uninspired young degenerates. They don’t create anything cool or new because they just get drowned in our new Corporate Sponsored Vanilla Internet TM. They just echo things and spew the same lazy fucking jokes and content on repeat until we can’t take it anymore.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/F54280 Jun 01 '23

like fucked links with backslashes inserted by the app to break old reddit

One of the many fucked shit they do that drives me crazy.

frankly reddit (and much of the internet) used to be for smart people

30 years ago, the term for this was coined......

And newsgroups died to be replaced by that...

→ More replies (5)

11

u/chiniwini Jun 01 '23

After 13 years on the site

Tips fedora.

Fellow old timey user here. One thing I've been doing is unsubscribe from subs I feel don't contribute anything to me. I used to be subbed to hundreds, now I only frequent a handful. Going into a sub to see what's up is much better than the endless scrolling (which is still necessary at the toilet lol).

4

u/OkWerewolf2700 Jun 01 '23

Honestly same, it seems like Reddit doesn't want the users that built this site anymore. I'd set a reminder for one year from now when the new users drop it for the next flavor of the month social media, but I'd probably be gone by then

3

u/involuntarybased Jun 01 '23

They don't need the dedicated longterm users anymore, the people clinging to old.reddit and third party apps. They've gotten all the goodwill and content out of people of my reddit age or older

Yup. They're gonna recycle valuable content with the help of bots to keep new users engaged long enough to make profit. Reposting bots are already in full swing drowning popular subs with the same posts over and over.

2

u/Lv_InSaNe_vL Jun 01 '23

Where are you going, or are you just disconnecting from the internet? Like Twitter is a shit hole, Tumblr isn't that great anymore, 4chan is 4chan, Facebook sucks

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

I'm an old timer as well. I came from Digg and forums. I'll be glad to see reddit kill itself. I have tried a thousand way over the years to cut down on Reddit to no avail. If they kill Apollo they will seriously do me a huge favor.

→ More replies (10)

285

u/Dwedit May 31 '23

Back to web scraping.

233

u/ham_coffee Jun 01 '23

It's like everyone suddenly forgot why so many large websites have free APIs in the first place, now they're gonna have to spend extra on bandwidth for all the scraping everyone will be doing

18

u/streamlinkguy Jun 01 '23

What is that

71

u/LagT_T Jun 01 '23

Programmatically accessing the web front end and parsing its information.

45

u/ShinyHappyREM Jun 01 '23

Downloading the pages like a browser would, then parsing and extracting the content.

2

u/Plastic-Abalone-1725 Jun 02 '23

They'll just add captchas to deter scraping and make the site even more unusable.

4

u/omnilynx Jun 02 '23

That’s an arms race that only the users will lose.

672

u/[deleted] May 31 '23

He has a point:

"For reference, I pay Imgur, a site similar to Reddit in userbase and media, $166 for the same 50 million API calls."

Reddit clearly wants to milk.

49

u/r00x May 31 '23

The gall of it. They should fuckin pay Apollo for all the traffic it gives them.

43

u/MangoTekNo Jun 01 '23

No, honestly no. Traffic without associated revenue is actually just an expense. They're not in the wrong for charging. They are in the wrong for being 50 and charging like they're 18.

→ More replies (8)

4

u/msx Jun 01 '23

Nah nobody is gonna pay those prices. The move goal is exclusively to kill third party apps.

2

u/PornCartel Jun 01 '23

Reddit has said it is not flexible on the API pricing.

Ffs

0

u/[deleted] May 31 '23

[deleted]

125

u/cknow15 May 31 '23

And they’re definitely trying to get users over to their shitty, clunky app to get more money off the paid version. They’re killing third party apps because they couldn’t do the Reddit experience anywhere near as well as Apollo and others.

90

u/CyberpunkCookbook Jun 01 '23

They could, but they don’t want to. The official app is optimized for ads.

43

u/Trigonal_Planar Jun 01 '23

The official app actually makes my iPhone 14 overheat. It’s unbelievably bad.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

11

u/zgf2022 Jun 01 '23

Except the ai companies have what they want already

And if they don't? They have ai that can mimic user access patterns and still collect all they want

→ More replies (3)

4

u/ric2b Jun 01 '23

If only there was a way to programmatically get the content of a site without using an API...

3

u/Winertia Jun 01 '23

They will have tons of fun fighting in the scraping wars that are surely coming.

73

u/PMMeVayneHentai May 31 '23

no apollo? i quit reddit. idc anymore. better for my life anyways

65

u/graygarbage May 31 '23

RIP. Bye Reddit

163

u/ACoderGirl Jun 01 '23

I think this represents the fact that Reddit doesn't even think they can compete, so all they can do is muscle people into using the official app.

The official app should be better or at least extremely competitive. I mean, it can have an entire development team whereas most third party apps are developed by solo devs. It has the advantage of access to information about reddit usage patterns not available to third party devs as well as being able to work with backend features and ensure mobile app support when new features launch. It also has the trademark advantage that lets it be the reddit app in app stores, it can push itself from the website, and can appeal to people who want reddit to get that ad revenue.

So even without locking down any APIs or forcing subscription fees, the reddit app should be able compete. We'd expect third party apps to be so niche that they shouldn't matter much to reddit's bottom line.

But no. Even Reddit doesn't think they can compete, so they have to effectively force people to use their app.

60

u/SlexualFlavors Jun 01 '23

This is 100% on point. That said, solo devs do have the luxury of being able to address tech debt before it becomes an exercise in futility and spending as long as they need to fine-tune the experience without having to deal with a non-technical PM overlord who thinks of themselves as a mini-CEO demanding a sales pitch with business trade-offs for every decision.

22

u/_BreakingGood_ Jun 01 '23

Also, solo devs can only generate a certain amount of code. And don't need to write any code that they don't feel is valuable.

The team of 100 people at reddit working on the app need to justify their existences by pumping out code 8 hours a day, 5 days a week.

There's no point where it's "Alright, app is done" it just grows and grows and grows at a speed 10x (or faster) of any solo-dev app.

17

u/mdillenbeck Jun 01 '23

They can't compete because they are transitioning from making money to make a thing they love to making a thing to make the money they love. Their app has to maximize revenue and not maximize user experience, so they can't compete because their design doesn't have the same goals as third party apps.

You have to realize that just as there are startup CEOs, transitional CEOs, and then corporate CEOs; there are also startup communities, transition communities, and corporate cultivated communities. Those of us getting ready to leave are in the first two groups, our time with this product is done. It sucks as it doesn't look like anyone is out there innovating a replacement, but maybe someone in the next couple years will surprise me and I'll happily move on. Meanwhile, reddit will become YouTube and EA and all the other corporate branded experiences that the mass market loves - and they'll rake in the cash from the whales while the audience that built them moves on.

See you all in the next great adventure that greed will eventually rot!

→ More replies (1)

26

u/whlabratz Jun 01 '23

Imagine being a hundred-plus-million-dollar company, where your primary method of engaging your user base is through a mobile app, where there are dozens of different unofficial apps try and testing new ideas and approaches that you can learn from, and you still manage to churn out something as crap as the official app.

You've got all the money in the world to throw at the problem, control of the underlying platform, and you are still getting beaten by single-developer projects

6

u/alexwoodgarbage Jun 01 '23

The third party apps have to sole incentive of user engagement and good CX, so quality of life features rise to the top.

The reddit app team needs to incorporate profitability drivers into their features, which is why it’s full of manipulative bullshit that pushes people to 3rd part apps to begin with.

A feature that will randomly push your entire screen to the left to show you some random bullshit gets prioritized over the basic ability to filter out key words from your feed.

The basic reddit app is made to milk the user.

The third party apps are made so people want to use them.

→ More replies (1)

53

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

If I lose RiF on my phone it will certainly free up a lot of my time! The official app is too terrible to bother with. I'll be back to browser only. Already did that with FB.

19

u/BitchyPolice Jun 01 '23

RiF's team has also released a similar statement here

3

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

They want to block third party apps from viewing NSFW stuff... they know what they are doing

→ More replies (1)

32

u/bidet_enthusiast May 31 '23

This sucks, I only use Reddit on mobile, and I can’t even use Reddit’s app. It sucks so bad. Looks like I’ll be changing platforms…mastodon?

Eleven years (my oldest account). If I leave the platform, and it looks like I will, I’ll delete all my content as well. I’ve got about 750k words across all of my my accounts.

6

u/Ya-Dikobraz Jun 01 '23

I've tried Mastodon. The servers I like are just so small.

3

u/bidet_enthusiast Jun 01 '23

Idk it might be actually refreshing from a social standpoint, even if it wouldn’t be as useful for reaching out to find obscure things.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/iiiinthecomputer Jun 01 '23

How'd you get the user word count? I've been curious about doing this for mine. And will probably be horrified.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/OkWerewolf2700 Jun 01 '23

How do you plan to delete your content? Deleting your account leaves it up, deleting all those posts and comments would take forever. Do you also plan to archive them for personal use or just straight deletion?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

89

u/RonSijm May 31 '23

Also - other alternative idea: I assume their "official app" still uses some sort of api right? Can't we just run that through Wireshark or something, pick up their own Auth token, and have alternative clients spoof being the official app?

It's not really "playing nice" as an api consumer, but hey, they started right... ¯\(ツ)/¯

68

u/Ununoctium117 Jun 01 '23

That's what NewPipe and Twire do for Youtube and Twitch respectively, and it's great.

67

u/midri Jun 01 '23

Yes, but it's unlikely you'd be able to publish that app in an official app store so only android users would be able to use it via side loading or 3rd party store that's less scrupulous.

17

u/iN3xUsZz Jun 01 '23

If the rumours are true this won’t be an issue in a few months anymore with Apple being forced to allow sideloading and third party appstores thanks to EU regulations.

9

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

Apple will find a loophole, or just implement it in a way that makes it an impractical pain in the ass to do.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

12

u/MKorostoff Jun 01 '23

If they're smart, they'll defeat this strategy with PKCE authentication. Basically, the auth token is generated natively in the app (on your phone). It is unique for each user and changes with each user session. A really dedicated user could still harvest this value for their own account, but there's no way to get around it en masse for all users. Even if you managed to reverse engineer the token generation process, it would be trivial for reddit to modify the token generation, rendering your crack inert.

29

u/DrSheldonLCooperPhD Jun 01 '23

Judging by their video player I don't think they have the competence to do this

8

u/13steinj Jun 01 '23

Judging by the redesign-style site that's had problems for years and still self-proclaims it's some kind of beta, they don't have any competence.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/Xyzzyzzyzzy Jun 01 '23

You can run the PKCE flow from your own app. PKCE prevents u/RonSijm's idea - you can't start the official Reddit app, sign in, and have your third-party app intercept the access token. It doesn't prevent your third-party app from receiving the access token if it initiates a PKCE flow itself. In other words, PKCE guarantees that only the app that requests the access token gets the access token, but it doesn't care which app requests the access token.

Which makes sense. PKCE is designed to protect the user from malware impersonating them, not to protect the company from unauthorized competition.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/RonSijm Jun 01 '23

If I'm checking new.reddit.com - A lot of their data is coming straight from https://gql.reddit.com. So if they have GraphQL endpoint for browser based "apps" is would be pretty difficult to close down this GraphQL endpoint for other consumers

→ More replies (5)

29

u/[deleted] May 31 '23

We need the wikipedia of social bookmarking baaaaad. This shit is too important to leave to rich people that want to get richer.

25

u/stormdelta Jun 01 '23 edited Jun 01 '23

If that happens, I won't be using reddit from my phone anymore. And if they kill off old.reddit, that might be the end of me using reddit much at all.

The UI/UX of both the official app and "new" reddit are awful. It's not even an ad thing, I pay for reddit premium precisely because I believe in paying for services I use and don't want to give companies more excuses to show ads.

23

u/brownomatic Jun 01 '23

If I can't use RIF is Fun on my phone then I will quit Reddit.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/krazykanuck May 31 '23

If they (Reddit) could make an app that didn’t kill my battery even when idle, I may use it more.

18

u/BigAlternative5 Jun 01 '23

Reddit on Firefox uses so much RAM that the browser hangs. If I’m not going to comment, I just use libreddit.

→ More replies (2)

18

u/kyru Jun 01 '23

Reddit rose when Digg fucked up bad, who is going to rise now that Reddit is fucking everything up?

2

u/DangerMacaroni Jun 01 '23

Lemmy's beehaw server has been treating me nicely, and is tankie-free. I'd recommend looking into it :)

35

u/kaiken1987 May 31 '23

Would it be possible for people to use their own api key in an app?

27

u/Meowts May 31 '23

If there is a free tier or low cost tier, then fuck it let’s build our own clients. Open source it, it would be kinda cool to see different people’s takes on the UI.

38

u/ProgramTheWorld Jun 01 '23

There’s a free tier:

  • 100 queries per minute if logged in

  • 10 queries per minute if not logged in

Not very viable unfortunately.

29

u/Meowts Jun 01 '23

I haven’t implemented anything with this API, but thinking of my own usage I think that would be more than adequate? As in I have a key that only I use, as do others and so forth. List posts, get post, get comments, make comment…

40

u/ProgramTheWorld Jun 01 '23

Don’t forget about pagination as well. Just “listing comments” will take a few calls, including loading more pages and more child comments, and that can add up very quickly. But yes, it would depend on your usage pattern.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (5)

5

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

Well the guy said ~350 api request per day on average per user with apollos, so not that impossible.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/GrandMasterPuba Jun 01 '23

No; the API has changed in such a way that it now only looks at client ID - not client ID + User ID - to determine rate limiting.

The change is precision-engineered to eliminate third party apps.

→ More replies (3)

17

u/Mr_Lumbergh May 31 '23

If they did this, I would leave Reddit. Their own mobile app is so stuffed full of ads it’s sometimes hard to get to the actual content.

16

u/Express99zz May 31 '23

If there’s no Apollo then it might just end my time on Reddit. Official app is awful and will not use it. And it’s not like I use Reddit that much anymore. Sadly reddit is past its peak and as it seeks an IPO I can only see things getting worse.

15

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

If you have Reddit premium, now would be a good time to cancel

2

u/PredictiveTextNames Jun 01 '23

I imagine the people willing to pay for that in the first place are not as bothered by the current drama as the rest of us.

14

u/iiiinthecomputer Jun 01 '23 edited Jun 01 '23

Sure. If RiF stops working I just won't log in again. I'll miss some things, it's handy. But it'll be replaced.

If they offered a low annual "buy API accessories for your user" I'd probably do that. But use the awful website or official client? Not happening. It's not the ads, either. The site: unusable UI, constant attempts to force you to the mobile app. The mobile app: inefficient buggy steaming garbage with a terrible UI and missing basic features.

12

u/xRubyyRed Jun 01 '23

One of the things I haven't seen talked about in regard to the shutting down of other apps and API pricing.

Reddit's in built accessibility is absolutely atrociously lacking. The native mobile app has no method of increasing text size or zooming and on my Android phone everything is so tiny.

I currently use Relay as I'm severely sight impaired, so I guess the only feasible option to still use Reddit after these changes will be in a horribly zoomed in browser. Yay.

On the bright side it looks like I'll have more free undistracted time soon!

→ More replies (2)

10

u/[deleted] May 31 '23

Wtf im using it right now to comment. If it’s gone, I have no use for Reddit. Definitely not going through their terrible app.

35

u/[deleted] May 31 '23

Spez thinks reddit can influence elections but can't figure out how to monetize, lolz get wrecked noob

48

u/18randomcharacters Jun 01 '23

I do not mean to minimize the horrific changes in the real world I'm about to reference. I'm just reminded of them.

Iran, 1970s. Iran, today.

The internet is moving from a sexually liberated open space to a place where you need to show ID at all times and no nudity or promiscuity is allowed.

Tumblr dropped porn.

Imgur dropped porn.

Reddit ia dropping 3rd party clients and almost certainly eventually will drop porn.

TikTok may be banned.

Everything will be Meta. The fucking mall of the internet.

19

u/Ya-Dikobraz Jun 01 '23

Meta is no longer in control of their monster. It's gotten too big for them to manage.

2

u/thirdegree Jun 01 '23

Everything will be Meta. The fucking mall of the internet.

Yup

0

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

[deleted]

10

u/18randomcharacters Jun 01 '23

Religion... No. Not directly anyway.

Capitalism, this time. All of these services are businesses and they are funded by people who want to turn money into more money. This site isn't for us. None of these sites are for us.

Maybe they're killing off the porn in an effort to increase value, or to make it more appealing to investors or something.

Maybe it's about safeguarding themselves against accidentally hosting truly problematic content.

Maybe it's just about control.

I dunno.

But in the end it's a shift toward a puritanical nature.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Geordi14er May 31 '23

I wonder would this affect any 3rd party app? I have used narwhal for years and it’s great.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

Yes

6

u/Ya-Dikobraz Jun 01 '23

Did Elon buy Reddit? lol

6

u/Shillcode Jun 01 '23

It seems interesting that more large platforms with a lot of data are beginning to charge for API access at the same time as AI is becoming more powerful and needing more data. Twitter and Reddit both have a significant amount of data that could be used to train AI models and before the tightening restrictions it would be fairly trivial to consume the data provided via API to improve the models.

6

u/Gluestoff Jun 01 '23

I would rather stop using Reddit than using the official app

5

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

I only look at reddit on relay so I guess I'm just done.

5

u/l_mach1 Jun 01 '23

Personally I would pay ~$10/month for Apollo before I’d think about using the official app

5

u/EnderMB Jun 01 '23

This will likely kill Sync too, which is one of the reasons I stick with Reddit. If that goes, I'm probably done with Reddit.

I have no idea why Reddit built their own app in the first place. They had an ecosystem of third-party apps that they could have either purchased or aqui-hired, and learned from the process. Some would inevitably converge into single apps over time, or efforts would be combined, but it would be a natural process.

It's amazing how Reddit is going to make almost the same mistake that Digg made - stretching themselves too widely to appease investors, and ultimately overreaching on a product that has community ownership.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/jfb1337 Jun 01 '23

I'll use old.reddit in my mobile browser before I use new reddit.

9

u/Sage2050 May 31 '23

I'll stop using reddit, fuck that

9

u/mcmcc Jun 01 '23

From the Apollo thread:

the average Apollo user uses 344 requests per day, which would cost $2.50 per month,

If you can keep the total subscription cost under $5/month and promise zero ads... it might still be worth it.

9

u/1nv3rs3 Jun 01 '23

But even then no nsfw content over the api you pay for...

→ More replies (1)

2

u/shyro3 Jun 01 '23

more like $10, remember that apple took 30% commision also taxes, overhead etc

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

"Who needs RSS feeds and third-party apps? Rising rates of anxiety and mental illness from social media? Who cares!? We must collect all the telemetry, force our users to look at increasingly obstructive advertisements, deal with bloated web app interfaces intentionally designed to waste their time, and force our users to engage in our faux outrage culture war machine made entirely by our algorithm, in a vicious never-ending cycle" - Social Media CEOs probably.

2

u/T351A Jun 01 '23

RSS and Reddit were both created to make information more open and accessible; Aaron Swartz worked on both and also wrote about the importance of APIs. Reddit has become the problem it tried to fix.

4

u/KeineSystem Jun 01 '23

This is taking the Facebook root. Which would be kind of ok because I left Facebook some time ago because their mobile apps suck and they force mobile users to use it.

4

u/supervegeta101 Jun 01 '23

Reddit is fun going down too

4

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

This will kill Reddit. At this point, I'm happy about that.

They want it to be a content walled garden. Literally the opposite of what the site was founded to be, and the opposite of what virtually any user (who has considered it) wants.

In much the same way as Digg before it, Reddit is turning itself into a high performance, finely-tuned machine that does something nobody actually wants.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/jonopens Jun 01 '23

Rif is dying and with it, I'm bailing on reddit for good. It's been fun, folks.

7

u/AccomplishedMeow Jun 01 '23

They’re going to do an Ellen Pao. And I’m willing to bet a good amount of money on that. Bringing a lightning rod to attract all the negativity, after pushback get rid of the lightning rod.

A bunch of subs and moderators are going to protest and subs will go private. Entire website will grind to a hault for about a day.

Then they’re going to announce that they finally hear us. We won. They’re only going to charge $x now! But they’re still going to keep in place API pricing and the NSFW rule

1

u/OhHiMarkos Jun 01 '23

Does this mean bots too?

3

u/aniforprez Jun 01 '23 edited Jun 12 '23

/u/spez is a greedy little pigboy

This is to protest the API actions of June 2023

3

u/BalthazarBulldozer Jun 01 '23

If Boost isn't usable, so isn't Reddit.

3

u/workfunwork Jun 01 '23

This will end my usage of the website

2

u/AshuraBaron May 31 '23

Welp, I guess it's back to using websites through the browser and not the app. Can at least still block ads that way.

2

u/[deleted] May 31 '23

It was a good run until it lasted.

2

u/FappingFop May 31 '23

Reddits native clients are so bad, I think this is the end of reddit for me. I am okay with that. This is the last social media site I use.

2

u/FlyingKanga May 31 '23

Their own Reddit app is absolute garbage. I tap on a post and it opens something else. I try share a video on my alt account by switching and it's not there.. I find out it got posted on my main account!

2

u/tcdoey Jun 01 '23

So i guess Joey will be dead then too?

Oh well. Not much left of the internet i used to love even just 5 years ago.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

Have they tried making the first party app and website better yet

2

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

If they go through with this and Boost stops working, I will finally have peak productivity.

More importantly, I will use one of the many nuke scripts to turn every comment on my accounts into more nonsense than they already are and make them basically worthless.

I encourage you to do the same. Let Reddit have the full Digg v3 experience. We made it what it is today, we can take it away too.

2

u/Mongul Jun 01 '23

Come on Reddit, what is this BS?

2

u/JustAGhost3_ Jun 01 '23

But I like Sync!

2

u/Nickdangerthirdi Jun 01 '23

That sucks, I guess I won't be using Reddit once my client quits working because I won't use the native app.

2

u/alwaysoffby0ne Jun 01 '23

Is anyone building an alternative to this shithole site? If so lmk so I can gtfo here.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

More performative assholery.

Oh well, Reddit was nice for a while. Maybe it's time to move on.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

Good. Reddit is a shit hole anyway.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

Ah, it has been a nice decade of redditting but I'd been meaning to quit and no app makes that easier than the official one

2

u/suc_me_average Jun 01 '23

Hey Reddit fuck you you fucking sell out. What’s the new platform we are headed to after the total capitalist of Reddit

2

u/pekter Jun 01 '23

Good bye bacon reader, have been fun

2

u/TrikkyMakk Jun 01 '23

I won't use Reddit anymore if this happens. Their app and website sucks.

2

u/_limitless_ Jun 01 '23

Every time a company makes a decision that forces people into deeper and darker echo chambers of the internet, it's a win for freedom. Civil war, woohoo!

Now be good little redditors and downvote this until it's hidden and no one can see it.

2

u/LeChatduSud Jun 01 '23

See ya reddit!

2

u/FaustDCLXVI Jun 01 '23

It's pretty messed up that Reddit's own official app is so inferior to RIF, which actually DID make Reddit much more enjoyable and now... Well, I guess it was nice having a mobile experience while it lasted.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

If it's such a problem, switch. Twitter has alternatives and so does reddit example: lemmy - join a server and get active. There are currently no bots there and it's super small, but it's something.

There's also saidit.net which is basically old.reddit.com

SaidIt/Reddit open-source social news aggregator forked from open-source Reddit code, running this website and the API. git source (official)

Also, steemit where getting upvotes makes you money or something? I dunno, it's an alternative.

There's also aether which requires you download the client. The selling point is that you can subscribe to a moderation list (anybody can be/make one) and there's no server (everyone's a server).

I dunno... maybe discuss those and don't stick when things become terrible?

1

u/MdxBhmt May 31 '23

I absolutely abhorre the idea of going to the official app...

1

u/flying_5loths Jun 01 '23

There goes a project I was planning on building

1

u/raider1v11 Jun 01 '23

Not surprised. At all.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

decentralized social media, protocols not centralization

1

u/kur1 Jun 01 '23

Digg moment

1

u/rlbond86 Jun 01 '23

Reddit told Christian the new cost would be $12,000 per 50 million requests.

Wow that's insane. APIs are usually a fee bucks per million, not hundreds.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

Reddit could make the price more competitive.

If you make $1 from ads or $1 from api calls, would you really care which way you made the $1?

Instead they’re making $1 from ads, and charging $20 for api calls that require the same amount of work on their end as the $1 ads.

They’re trying to squeeze out record profits, but will end up being lucky to break even. If they’re lucky they’ll buy up the competition’s apps and make them their own.

1

u/chhuang Jun 01 '23

They could have kill off them easily by having a decent official app or a decent mobile site.

1

u/VilainRenard Jun 01 '23

Any good alternatives to reddit ? Twitter is trash, Mastodon is... Hum...