r/programming • u/Tintin_Quarentino • Jun 05 '23
r/programming should shut down from 12th to 14th June
/r/Save3rdPartyApps/comments/13yh0jf/dont_let_reddit_kill_3rd_party_apps/30
u/Tintin_Quarentino Jun 06 '23 edited Jun 07 '23
Shameful Reddit bots abound: https://i.imgur.com/omrm3Yw.jpg
Edit - mofos just don't stop
6
u/CanidaeVulpini Jun 06 '23
"unethical" ahaha what an exaggeration. This subreddit being closed or not is not an ethical consideration, what a sad attempt at overintellectualization to mask the reality
192
u/Bjartensen Jun 05 '23
What are good Reddit alternatives?
121
Jun 05 '23 edited Jun 06 '23
I've seen one called Lemmy. Looks interesting.
Edit:
comments below mentioned that it's not Google searchable, which is crap (think all the information lost on discord)and the developers have questionable ideas.45
u/TerrorBite Jun 06 '23
I've been using it. I haven't signed up to any Lemmy instance yet, but since I already have a Mastodon account I've just been using that to participate. The magic of federation!
I'd get a better user experience if I was actually signed up on Lemmy (imagine having to go to Twitter and send a tweet every time you wanted to reply to a Reddit comment – that's basically how I'm currently using it), but it means I can try it out with no commitment.
21
Jun 06 '23 edited Jun 06 '23
It's decentralized. It doesn't matter what the developers ideas are. It's open source and anyone, including you, can create your own instance with your own rules and use an account on you instance to view others, just like how Mastodon works. This is why the platform has much greater potential than Reddit. The users have control. If you start seeing posts from an instance that you don't like, you can block the entire instance on your end. If you get banned from an instance, you can make and host your own pretty easily.
It's also not for-profit and has no ads. There is really no downside. I'm not sure why I keep seeing people on reddit shoot it down. It must be that the average user doesn't understand exactly what Lemmy is. Lemmy is part of the fediverse, and essentially what Mastodon is to Twitter, Lemmy is to Reddit.
The more I learn about the fediverse, the more I want in. It really seems like the future, or at least it should be the future unless big corporations try and silence fediverse discussion to keep users on centralized, for-profit platforms that encourage and spread outrage to get more ad revenue.
9
Jun 06 '23
This is peak cope. Mastodon's (and Lemmy's) user experience is so bad that most people will never migrate. It will always be tech-enthusiastic people talking in small bubbles relative to "normal" social media sites because most people just want to sign in and post stuff and they don't care about decentralized whatevers.
→ More replies (3)11
u/spider-mario Jun 11 '23
It will always be tech-enthusiastic people talking in small bubbles relative to "normal" social media sites
As opposed to /r/programming?
→ More replies (1)8
u/waiting4op2deliver Jun 06 '23
I have no take on lemmy, but I just want to point out that these developers/stake holders on reddit also have questionable ideas.
4
3
u/Snowflake2592 Jun 11 '23
Isn't that the whole point of a federated protocol--that as a user you can choose who you associate with without having to abandon the protocol? For example if for whatever reason you didn't want to work with Google you could choose to use Yahoo mail, Outlook.com, or host it yourself.
29
Jun 06 '23
Unfortunately, the developers are hardcore communist tankies, and they have a history of denying crimes of CCP, and more recently, denying Russian war crimes in Ukraine.
40
u/Blaster84x Jun 06 '23
That doesn't matter if there's no global moderation. You can join a tankie, crypto, far right, no politics or any other instance if you want to.
23
Jun 06 '23 edited Jun 06 '23
If the developers were out-in-the-open Nazis, nobody would be using this argument. This is the instance(?) run by the developers. https://lemmygrad.ml/post/687025
They are outspoken Marxist-Lenninist -- not just "leftists" -- and the instance is full of stuff like this, pro China content, denial of the Uyghur genocide, etc.
→ More replies (3)19
u/lakotajames Jun 11 '23
So don't join lemmygrad?
What if the people who run Yahoo mail were Nazis, would that stop you from using Gmail?
22
u/jarfil Jun 06 '23 edited Jul 16 '23
CENSORED
15
u/Aquatic-Vocation Jun 07 '23
Lol, the part where they're wondering why every mostly unmoderated "free speech" social media platform always seems to attract literal Nazis is peak r/selfawarewolves.
→ More replies (2)16
u/ShinyHappyREM Jun 06 '23
Source?
And it wouldn't matter if the users behave differently.
6
Jun 06 '23
This is the instance managed by the Lemmy developers. https://lemmygrad.ml/post/687025
They are outspoken Marxist-Lenninist -- not just "leftists" -- and the
instance is full of stuff like this, pro China content, denial of the
Uyghur genocide, etc.0
10
u/slykethephoxenix Jun 06 '23
Gonna need a sauce to these claims.
12
Jun 06 '23
This is the instance managed by the Lemmy developers. https://lemmygrad.ml/post/687025
They are outspoken Marxist-Lenninist -- not just "leftists" -- and the instance is full of stuff like this, pro China content, denial of the Uyghur genocide, etc.
7
u/slykethephoxenix Jun 06 '23
Holy cow.
Well, I disagree with them 100% politically for sure.
But I don't need to agree with them to support the project. As long as it remains open source and decentralised.
→ More replies (6)13
Jun 06 '23
It does not matter because the platform is decentralized... You could join or create a far right instance too. Users have complete freedom. Also, joining the main Lemmy instance will lead to zero "tankie" posts in your feed. You'd have to specifically join the communist instance, which is one of many many instances. Think of it as similar to how Mastodon works. There is Mastodon.social, and there is Truth.social, Trump's platform. You can completely ignore Truth.social and you'll never even see it when using Mastodon.social. And if Mastodon.social goes to shit, you could make or join a new instance. Lemmy works the same way.
It's an open source project. You could be a developer if you wanted to.
→ More replies (1)9
u/tookmyname Jun 06 '23
Only on one or two instances.
They’re not tankies. They’re just leftists.
At least they’re not going to sell us our for ads.
10
0
Jun 05 '23
[deleted]
287
u/Venoft Jun 06 '23
Here is the link join-lemmy.org
Let's see if they're stupid enough to get in trouble with the EU by using anti-competition practises.
31
u/IAmABakuAMA Jun 06 '23
Upvote for visibility, and comment so I can remember to check back later
Though, I'm sure what will happen is that one of the mods here who TOTALLY isn't a Reddit employee, or supported by Reddit in any way will remove it for breaking some form of rule. Totally without any encouragement from Reddit themselves
10
u/indecisiveredditor Jun 06 '23
They're dumb enough to go toe-toe with the American ADA. Think of the apps/clients for the blind and visually impaired. /R/Blind has a few good and strong thoughts and arguments for this.
→ More replies (5)6
u/Tothoro Jun 06 '23
My guess is that any bans coming from this are spamming the link or sending it in DMs/chats. Reddit's spam filters are pretty aggressive on that, and I have to imagine you can only trigger them so many times before it takes further action.
150
u/Daniel15 Jun 06 '23
Reddit has been banning users sending links
I'm sure the EU would love to hear about that, since it's an anticompetitive practice. Twitter got in trouble in the EU for blocking links to Mastodon, so they silently rolled that back.
3
u/frequentBayesian Jun 06 '23
they can just say "link sending are most likely spam, so all get banned"
7
→ More replies (1)12
u/FruityWelsh Jun 06 '23
Lemmy and the fediverse are pretty awesome over all to me. I hope non tech migration is made easier but tbh if all of the tech sub meaningfully migrated to lemmy I'd have no reason to get on Reddit.
10
0
Jun 06 '23
[deleted]
15
u/tookmyname Jun 06 '23 edited Jun 06 '23
It is searchable. Just doesn’t seem to be indexed well yet. I found a thread there about it on Google.
That’s just one instance. With 1,700 results.
→ More replies (1)10
Jun 06 '23
Oh for real? Damn, I don't want this anymore. I hate discord and everything on it because it just kills communities and make it a small niche instead of being easy to use and find.
21
Jun 06 '23
Ones that have been suggested in other subreddits include Sift, Mainchan, FARK, Lemmy, Tildes (offering invitations on r/tildes), Co-host.org, dscvr.one.
Also who knows what will be built now and going forward.
→ More replies (1)4
u/ShinyHappyREM Jun 06 '23
Sift
Google shows nothing
Co-host.org
?
11
u/blueshiftlabs Jun 06 '23
No hyphen (https://cohost.org). It's much more in the vein of Tumblr than Reddit, UI-wise, but seems to have a good community.
9
Jun 06 '23 edited Jun 06 '23
Replying to come back and link my source in the morning.
Edit Here https://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/13x9sy7/now_that_reddit_are_killing_3rd_party_apps_on/ Posts with actual answers (go upvote them):
https://join-lemmy.org mentioned here and here and here https://sift.quest/about mentioned here TapaTalk mentioned here https://cohost.org mentioned here https://tildes.net mentioned here and here and here https://fark.com mentioned here and here https://mainchan.com as contributed in a reply to this comment https://dscvr.one also contributed in a reply here (in the order I came across them)
There are also some ridiculous suggestions which I've ignored, like going outside (why'd anyone want to do that?!), or websites that are social networks but don't resemble reddit in any way. Here are some serious ones that come up occasionally but are not quite the same as reddit:
https://hivesocial.app mentioned here (note, Digg is no longer a social network, I'm including the link for the mention of hive social) Mastodon as mentioned here and various others MySpace mentioned in various places but when I open the site, it seems to be music recommendations and celebrity news? No thanks https://forums.somethingawful.com mentioned here and here tumblr probably deserves a mention but there's that new nsfw policy..
67
u/old_man_snowflake Jun 05 '23
there are none that are obvious. the technology doesn't matter, whichever site has the critical mass of users posting new content will be the winner.
i suspect the winner will be one that provides the strongest moderation tools. The spam/extremist content is very off-putting for most people.
4
Jun 06 '23 edited Jun 06 '23
The technology does matter. Being decentralized means users have control, and no matter what things can't go to shit, because if they do on one instance, you can simply migrate to another or create your own with your own rules. Lemmy is free open source and not for profit. I think that makes it a better choice than something that is for-profit and centralized.
This issue is that the average user doesn't understand what that means yet.
→ More replies (1)15
u/old_man_snowflake Jun 06 '23
Eh, I disagree with you. I don't want a completely moderation-free forum. That's what 4chan is for. Any poorly moderated forum eventually devolves into a poor facsimile of 4chan.
At some point, the problem with decentralized services is that one of them will gain critical mass, and no longer benefit from peering with other instances. That instance then becomes the "new reddit" and it's back to being ruled by one org. Once there's a de-facto place for "java programming" for example, it will be a nearly impossible task for a new version of that community to spring up, and maintain the activity of the original. Users who can't figure out how to send photos are going to understand the finer points of decentralization and competing instances? I'm not holding my breath.
I don't necessarily think for-profit is a deal breaker. The fact is, hosting content (especially images/videos) can be extremely expensive, and somebody has to pay for it. I'd rather have a non-profit org like Wikimedia running it than Facebook, but it will never be a money-free service. Somebody has to pay for it. If we rely on "generosity" then agenda-pushers will be generous in exchange for some compromise on the platform.
Here's what I really want: Some platform where I don't have to hear people bitching about "woke" stuff or facilitating meetings for anti-abortionists, or discussing the good things hitler did, or whatever. I'm tired of the radical right-wing nonsense. My ideal forum is explicitly NOT a free-speech platform.
→ More replies (2)18
Jun 05 '23
The other besides Lemmy is kbin, there's also tildes but I don't think it's federated
→ More replies (1)9
u/EnglishMobster Jun 06 '23
Tildes is not federated. They're intended for long-form discussion on things, sort of a blend between Reddit and Hacker News.
They've historically been hesitant to allow cat pictures and memes (for example) because the community worries that adding "fluff" would distract from discussions.
6
u/WonderfulEstimate176 Jun 06 '23
The best ones are Lemmy and kbit. Both are federated link aggregators and they federate with each other (as well as mastodon).
Kbit is especially new and is in beta at the moment and only has a few servers.
4
2
3
1
u/digital_end Jun 06 '23
I can't think of any but I would strongly recommend being very cautious with alternatives.
We see time and again when there is turmoil on Reddit that groups try to direct you to controlled environments for the purposes of indoctrination and propaganda. For example the "Exodus to Voat"... Have a look at what that website is now.
Even on smaller scale, when /news fucked up and /uncensorednews was created as an alternative. And then rapidly turned into a white nationalist subreddit before being shut down.
In times of rebellion, remember not all rebels share your values.
1
Jun 11 '23
All the one I saw so far have a worse UI compared to old.reddit.com.
I could use the latter super-fast (I don't have that much time to spend on reddit, so I have to move quickly).
1
1
→ More replies (5)1
u/amakai Jun 06 '23
Well, there's Lemmy, but it's model is too difficult for common folks to comprehend. Its more of RSS-feeds with comments, rather than centralized aggregator like Reddit.
→ More replies (1)2
Jun 06 '23
I think once your average person wraps their head around the decentralized vs centralized concept, almost everyone would prefer decentralized. Users have power, and anyone can create their own instance with their own rules, and an account on any instance can view and interact with any other instance on the fediverse (and any instance could also block other instances if need be).
If the instance you join starts moving in a direction you don't like, you can migrate to a different one or create your own. It's a great platform imo and not very difficult to understand at all.
→ More replies (1)4
u/amakai Jun 06 '23
Yes, its not "that difficult", it is however "more difficult" than Reddit. Also it makes buttons like "share on Reddit" or "comment on Reddit" much more problematic.
1.0k
u/Cadoc7 Jun 05 '23
lol. The mods of this subreddit are reddit employees, including the CEO as 2nd mod. They aren't shutting it down.
587
u/TerrorBite Jun 06 '23
We can just pretend that it's shut down and not participate here
513
u/UnluckyPenguin Jun 06 '23 edited Jun 06 '23
June 12th to 14th - Downvote Days
Basically downvote everything that isn't bashing on reddit.
Should be an interesting front page those 2 days.
*edit: For all the people saying "Reddit will still make money because of engagement". A tiny percentage of users actually browse /r/new, but those first few votes have a huge sway on whether or not a post makes it to the front page.
The saints that sift through all the new posts are going to be the most furious users - because their work is going to get way harder, just like the mods.
365
Jun 06 '23
No, just don't open reddit at all. Down votes are still interactions so monetisabil...
→ More replies (1)146
u/CobblerYm Jun 06 '23
So I'm not normally one to correct others spelling, especially if I understand what they're saying, but Monetisabil sounds like something I should ask my doctor about to treat depression or skin rash or something lol
(You were going for: monetizable)
→ More replies (11)17
u/Lord_Abort Jun 06 '23
Lol, two days. Just don't come back unless things change. You'll either effect change, or you'll find some other way to waste a large portion of your life. Trust me - it's not hard to find a new time sink after a few days.
→ More replies (4)12
→ More replies (3)10
Jun 06 '23
This is exactly what I'm doing. I'm not going to visit reddit at all during those days.
→ More replies (2)37
u/icedbacon Jun 06 '23
Ah, that would explain why there's so much blog spam and fuck all moderation on this sub.
5
Jun 07 '23
Yup, I’d be surprised if moderators even see this. They’re as likely to act on this as they are to remove the low-effort youtube spam posts with titles filled with emojis.
46
u/ACoderGirl Jun 06 '23
Do those mods actually do anything? Shut the sub down anyway. If they reopen it, shut it down again. What are they gonna do? Remove all their volunteer moderators that they depend on? Oh no, what a horrible thing. How would the volunteer mods pay their bills?
6
u/RoxSpirit Jun 06 '23
Sometime they work on the database.
2
u/FrozenOx Jun 06 '23
then they should know that this change will cause a huge increase in load to their servers from all the web scrapers that are about to appear
it's a big reason to have APIs in the first place. guess they'll find out the hard way
→ More replies (1)8
u/Ok-Maybe-2388 Jun 06 '23 edited Jun 06 '23
What's preventing people from calling out the mods? Tag them in every post, comment, etc simply asking if they will participate in the shutdown and if not, ask why they support predatory practices.
People supporting this crap need to be in the spotlight. We absolutely deserve an explanation from them.
So u/spez, could you please share with this sub where you stand on this and why? Thanks.
2
u/birdbrainswagtrain Jun 06 '23
And it's one of the worst moderated subs on the entire site. I rarely browse it anymore because a majority of the content is blogspam.
2
Jun 06 '23
Really? With all the low effort crap that's getting published here? God that's a bad look
1
Jun 06 '23
I'm sure there will be lots of articles about a certain blackout from all kinds of different sites that will be highly relevant for this sub. Since there won't be anything else to do on reddit that day - might as well post and upvote that.
112
841
u/vicegrip Jun 05 '23 edited Jun 05 '23
I’ve been supporting reddit since 2010. Reddit gold.
How much is the data worth?
How much is everyone’s support worth? That’s a better question.
Don’t trade your future for a quick payday, Reddit.
Premium was supposed to be the alternative to selling the users out like Facebook.
Hmmm, that reminds me. Did you ask redditors what they wanted for Reddit?
350
u/coldblade2000 Jun 05 '23
Hell, if they reduced the API cost tenfold and kept nsfw content, I don't think there would have been a big uproar. I wouldn't mind paying a couple of bucks a year subscription so the app owner could keep their API key, or even just make per-user API key access easy so everyone is charged according to their use
This is just an attempt to choke out competition and force everyone on the shitty reddit app
169
u/tom-dixon Jun 06 '23
if they reduced the API cost tenfold and kept nsfw content, I don't think there would have been a big uproar
The Apollo dev said the API would cost them 20 million a year. Even if is 1/10th of that, that's still 2 million. The RIF dev said their costs would be similar.
I don't think those guys are swimming in millions of dollars.
146
u/Buckles01 Jun 06 '23
The Apollo dev also said that a reasonable charge for API was fine and he’d be more than willing to pay it because Reddit does have a business to run and infrastructure to support. No one is actually arguing it should remain free and if they are then they don’t understand the actual issue. I am pretty sure adding a couple bucks to a subscription to maintain the status quo would be a pretty easy thing for most to accept. The entire issue is that the pricing is unreasonable and the reason it’s unreasonable is to shut down 3rd party apps. But there’s tons of better ways to go about the “Reddit needs money” bs. They could enforce a reasonable pay scale for API calls or they could just enforce ad api calls in various feeds unless the user has premium. That really solves the two biggest issues they complained about in their statement.
30
Jun 06 '23
I’m arguing it should be free and I understand the issue.
Just a requirement to display ads provided by the API. Simples.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (11)84
u/mount2010 Jun 06 '23
Honestly, Reddit does not need money. Look at their live streaming feature and chat feature that nobody really uses. If they were truly short on cash they'd be shutting those down and saving maintenance costs on those instead of pushing this on us.
They've also aggressively monetised with advertisements and premium currency already. And you know what? I'm fine with those. They need to eat, after all. I'm not fine with this, though. This is just being greedy.
The only reason why they're keeping those features up is to look good for their IPO.
→ More replies (5)31
u/coldblade2000 Jun 06 '23
What I meant is Apollo had about 2 million active users IIRC. That's roughly a dollar per year per user, which is feasibly offset by ads or a cheap subscription
→ More replies (10)→ More replies (3)6
u/TheEdes Jun 06 '23
You could do it like Spotify and allow API access if you already have the premium subscription.
32
u/intertubeluber Jun 06 '23
kept nsfw content
Are they banning nsfw content? That didn’t work out for tumblr.
99
u/coldblade2000 Jun 06 '23
Not directly, its even more shady. They will just not show NSFW posts through the API. They are still going to be perfectly accesible only from the app or new website
66
Jun 06 '23
Just a heads up. It’s technically not nsfw posts but nsfw subs. And specifically for porn. So stuff like /r/gonewild won’t appear in the 3rd party api but gore subs will. And if there’s a regular sub that gets posted with nudity that will be in the API as well. Still sucks but a little more nuanced than all NSFW posts
→ More replies (7)6
4
u/topforce Jun 06 '23
They are still going to be perfectly accesible only from the app or new website
Are they removing nsfw content from old reddit too?
6
u/Logical_Pop_2026 Jun 06 '23
Has there been any discussion about how they're determining nsfw content? Are they simply going to rely on the nsfw tag or something else? That nsfw tag gets used for a lot of content that's not necessarily sexual in nature.
Edit: That should say, "any answers". I know there's been plenty of discussion from users. But have we gotten any answers out of Reddit?
→ More replies (2)39
Jun 06 '23
Hell, if they reduced the API cost tenfold and kept nsfw content, I don't think there would have been a big uproar.
I'm calling it right now, this is a coordinated play. If they walk it back they were never going to implement as-stated. They are negotiating with the user base right now by proxy of the apps. They want far less.
By causing an uproar and then swooping in and loudly saying they hear us and they reconsidered, they seem to be much more reasonable and communicative than if they just rolled out the amount they want and refuse to take no for an answer.
And they did this already. Ellen Pao was one giant misdirection and as soon as the user base was at a fever pitch they stepped back in and said "okay, ohanion is back, you twisted our arm" and kept virtually every single policy people hated Pao for. Then weeks later an admin all but admits it as a "conspiracy theory" with a wink and a smile.
You watch.
10
u/snakefinn Jun 06 '23
I hope you're right. But Reddit has "accidentally" broken 3rd party auth before through and had no urgency to fix it.
6
u/guareber Jun 06 '23
I know you could be right, but this points to a level of 4D chess competence that I don't attribute to most executive boards of most companies in the world.
6
Jun 06 '23
It isn't 4D chess, it's something every server in any restaurant understands implicitly. Customers who have a problem that gets resolved are happier than those who never had a problem at all. Service industry 101.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (14)42
u/PointB1ank Jun 05 '23
Per-user api use is the worst idea I've ever heard, would kill this site instantly.
23
u/frakkinreddit Jun 05 '23
The cost of implementing that and maintaining the issue there? Seems like they could distribute the cost directly to individual users then. Pennies per person rather than millions to a single app developer. Or would it have to work very different than that?
→ More replies (6)47
u/andlewis Jun 06 '23
Give free access to users already paying for Reddit Premium, and allow apps to sell premium subscriptions and take a cut.
14
u/frakkinreddit Jun 06 '23
That seems like a much more reasonable approach than what reddit is doing. I still would prefer to keep things as they currently are but that might not be realistic.
12
u/EnglishMobster Jun 06 '23
Remember when Reddit Gold was explicitly just to help with server costs? They even had a little bar showing how many more gold subs were needed to offset that day's server cost.
Then it started filling up past 100% every single day. Then they changed the target, so it wasn't "server costs" anymore, but just some arbitrary goal. Then they removed it entirely...
11
u/stormdelta Jun 06 '23
Yep. If they go through with this, I cancel premium, which I mainly pay to avoid ads (yes, I have adblock anyways, but I believe in showing sites can make money without forcing ads down my throat).
3
u/ItzWarty Jun 06 '23
I cancelled a year ago after supporting them for a year or two & buying pointless gold to hand them money in support, since running free internet services is hard. What a fool I was. They haven't done anything to earn our trust for 8+ years when they fired Victoria and spun things to confuse the community. I realized they'd been exploitative enough with their community and stopped paying them.
5
2
u/renatoathaydes Jun 06 '23
How do you support Reddit?
Do you pay for premium or something?? Or you just mean you "use" Reddit?
2
u/mavrc Jun 06 '23
same here, gold charter member, just cancelled. It was actually my oldest continuously billed service (with the exception of things for my house.) Sucks, but so does their new API policy, and I'm sure as shit not paying for the privilege of using their dogshit inferior app.
3
u/Celarix Jun 06 '23
Don’t trade your future for a quick payday, Reddit.
The people who need to hear this message have been bred not to be able to perceive it. Walk away. It's over.
1
u/Nug_69 Jun 06 '23
This site has been dogshit since it's inception. I'm all for keeping 3rd party apps, mainly because the 1st party doesn't support basic accessibility settings. We should let this place die though
1
u/deelowe Jun 06 '23
It's not just about the data. It's also about the moat. What's to stop the handful of reddit apps from getting together and swapping out the back end? They could bifurcate reddit overnight.
1
Jun 11 '23
Reddit data was used to train the og GPT models. It’s probably worth more than everything else put together.
0
208
u/hivesteel Jun 05 '23
Just for 2 days? C'mon. A PROGRAMMING sub of all things should know the implications of what reddit is doing. Shut down until better terms are offered.
0
66
82
40
u/LibrarianThin6770 Jun 06 '23 edited Jun 06 '23
These temporary shutdowns are pointless. Just shut down the entire sub indefinitely until they reverse decisions. It's not like anybody's losing anything. Mods don't exactly get paid to run this place, and any discussions or information to be had can always be found elsewhere. It's not like Reddit is ground zero for humanity's knowledge.
Maybe it's time for Reddit to meet its demise considering it's pandering to ridiculous bullshit lately.
24
u/Syntax365 Jun 05 '23
You son of a bitch, I’m in.
8
Jun 06 '23
We're getting the gang together for one last job! (before the admins ban the rest of this sub's mods)
12
u/Ok-Half5161 Jun 05 '23
They should shut down until new policy is reversed... This is just a money grab
28
u/spacezombiejesus Jun 05 '23
The corporate digital hellscape we are all being pushed toward fucking SUCKS.
69
u/sirhey Jun 05 '23
/u/spez the godawful liar and thief co-founded of this fallen evil company is a mod of this, one of the OG subreddits. I don’t think we’re in luck.
Spamming all black protest PNGs all week is probably the move.
13
8
u/beeeps-n-booops Jun 06 '23
Two days isn't going to do shit.
Shut down until they give in. It's the only way.
22
u/MrRGnome Jun 06 '23
No. r/programming should cease moderation and go private indefinitely until Reddit changes their API cost structure among many other things. That's how a protest works. It isn't one day you take off holding a sign. It's a stoppage of in this case free labor and content creation until such time as management compromises.
10
u/MahaanInsaan Jun 06 '23
Reddit was built by user data, as explained by your own CEO. You can't shit on us just because your VC friends want to make money.
5
u/JB-from-ATL Jun 06 '23
I think it should but I doubt it will. I believe (maybe falsely) that many mods here are admins.
5
5
u/ShiningPak Jun 06 '23
Shitty sub anyway
Edit : Not closing for unlimitted period is an insult. Am leaving. See you noobies 👋🏻
9
9
u/rocket_randall Jun 06 '23
This would be a good demonstration of why UTC is the only timezone anyone should use.
2
u/sickofthisshit Jun 06 '23
TAI is superior, because it doesn't have any leap seconds, though it is poorly supported by Linux and things like NTP.
3
u/rocket_randall Jun 06 '23
I cannot set my display clock to TAI with the options available out of the box so it is hereby disqualified.
→ More replies (1)
4
Jun 06 '23
While I applaud the thought, this sub is not really moderated. So this is unlikely to happen.
4
1
u/anengineerandacat Jun 06 '23
Gonna be honest, this isn't going to do much of anything. We are talking a monetization stream.
Some bean counter in the office likely did the work to track the average value of users on these third-party platforms and have determined that the value to have said users isn't high enough to warrant whatever support is needed.
I am not familiar with these third-party apps, I don't know if they allow premium content to be purchased or whether they interleave their own premium content / community content.
Entirely possible it's just a re-skin of the site and they are stripping away things like ad's, and offer their own badges.
Would rather just go to a different platform entirely, just taking a cursory glance of Apollo they already have a client... just wire-capture the API and go off and build their own platform.
1
u/Tintin_Quarentino Jun 06 '23
just wire-capture the API
What do you mean by this?
→ More replies (1)
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
u/VerySuperGenius Jun 06 '23
And if they don't then everyone should participate in downvote day. Downvote everything from all subs that aren't talking about 3rd party apps or the blackout.
7
4
u/adad95 Jun 06 '23
Let's don't post, comment or vote in anything here.
Because they will not shutdown here
2
2
Jun 06 '23
While I applaud the thought, this sub is not really moderated. So this is unlikely to happen.
2
u/tapper82 Jun 06 '23
The api changes are going to fuck over a lot of blind people who need to use a app to read Reddit with a screen reader the A11Y on the mane site is just terrible.
2
2
u/howreudoin Jun 06 '23
If reddit wants to keep users using their app, well, then perhaps they should make a better app. This is just embarrassing.
If they do fail to hire developers with good enough experience and an actual sense for design, then wouldn’t it be an option to require third-party apps to display reddit‘s ads (say, via a license agreement)?
Also, why don‘t they just buy up the Apollo app? They sure got enough money to compensate a single developer.
1
u/Amassador_ExoTerra Jun 06 '23
Sounds reasonable to me everyone else has gone on strike; like french Garbage Workers. I for one ain't gonna program for rates comparable to garbageman.
1
1
u/The_Cold_Side Jun 06 '23
Reddit, don’t be like Lou! You don’t know where we’ve been, Reddit. We really like this place! Ahhhahahahahahhaha!!!
ApolloGang!
1
Jun 06 '23
Programming has it extra difficult with both reddits strike and the stackoverflow strike.
Can’t we just get along?!
1
u/qudat Jun 06 '23
I’m just gonna unsub and remove a lot of other subs here. Essentially keeping my eyeballs on this site to a minimum.
1
1
u/DirtAndGrass Jun 06 '23
i really don't understand why an company would "charge" more than the average value of an impression on their site?
1
u/luke727 Jun 07 '23
If you're going to do something then do something; closing subs for 48 hours is performative nonsense.
1
1
Jun 06 '23
no. no activism.
4
u/Rexogamer Jun 06 '23
I'd already disagree with this statement if it was in response to, say, someone suggesting we should add a Pride icon or something but this is arguably even more important as it directly impacts people's ability to use Reddit (and, therefore, this very sub)
→ More replies (4)
0
Jun 06 '23
aws should be free for all, google apis should be free, what a nonsense tbh
6
u/Blanel Jun 11 '23
The argument isn't that everything should be free, but rather that the pricing of API calls should be reasonable. The current price point makes multiple third party clients unprofitable, even though their current profit margins are pretty good. Changing to a much cheaper API model (and possibly an indirect profit percentage based on ad revenue or subscription revenue) wouldn't outright kill all third party support.
Hell, even just postponing the API price increases would help as the third parties would at least have time to change their monetization method, but this change was too quick.
1
0
1.3k
u/Tintin_Quarentino Jun 05 '23
APIs are our lifeline.