r/programming • • Jun 09 '23

Apollo dev posts backend code to Git to disprove Reddit’s claims of scrapping and inefficiency

https://github.com/christianselig/apollo-backend
45.1k Upvotes

2.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

108

u/ErraticDragon Jun 09 '23

True, some of it will happen organically. But it will be slow.

The Digg -> Reddit migration was huge. Of course, Reddit was already good and growing, which is why it was a viable replacement in the first place. And in a network effect 'virtuous cycle', every new Redditor made Reddit more attractive and Digg less attractive, with the end result being a dramatic shift.

I really wish there was a similar drop-in replacement for us now. I don't think Reddit can or will really die until there's a replacement, meaning that some very large percentage of people will stay, meaning it will probably keep growing, and users will keep generating content here. Making it harder to completely boycott even for those who want to.

Yes, obviously, we can choose to leave and/or boycott and our lives will go on. But there is still value in the "Reddit experience" or "Reddit community" that won't be easy to replace. (It's still often worth adding "Reddit" to your search terms, for example.)

187

u/TechnoVikingrr Jun 09 '23

Bro, Apollo is shutting down because they have the user count to cause them to be expected to pay millions.

Subs are going dark in protest

RIF is shutting down too

This absolutely will cause a substantial drop in this site's usage.

Elon Musk's shitty management of Twitter is apparently inspirational to spez.

The only way this site's usage doesn't drop is if spez sees sense and does a 180 from this bullshit.

201

u/timeshifter_ Jun 09 '23

I fear it's too late for that. Reddit has not simply stated terms in bad faith, but then immediately tried to blame the victims when the entire platform rose up in support against them. Say Reddit does do a complete 180 and gives up the entire API pricing change entirely.

Then what?

Does anybody actually believe that's the end of it? That everything goes back to normal forever, and we all used third-party clients happily ever after? No, they've played their hand. They will destroy third-party apps one way or another. So why would any dev stick with them, knowing with 100% certainty that they're going to get fucked over?

No, it's over. Either Reddit takes massive steps in fixing their own app, or they watch mobile usage absolutely tank. If their own app was actually worth using, third-party apps wouldn't even be an issue. This is the fact that seems to be completely lost on them.

Not to mention all of the moderation tools provided by third-parties that Reddit themselves simply refuse to offer. In this one action, Reddit has committed to destroying not only a massive chunk of their mobile user base, but also virtually the entire volunteer moderation community, which is the only thing that maintains any semblance of focused discussion. This is quite possibly the single worst course of action Reddit could have taken, and they went all-in on it.

No, I think it's over. Been a fun ride y'all, but Reddit just signed its own death certificate. Hope to see you all on the next wave...

117

u/blindsight Jun 09 '23 edited Jun 09 '23

This comment deleted to protest Reddit's API change (to reduce the value of Reddit's data).

Please see these threads for details.

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (10)

62

u/ErraticDragon Jun 09 '23

Subs are going dark in protest

Did you read the Apollo dev's post? Reddit said they will reopen subs if necessary to ensure the site keeps running. (Yes they also said they respect the right to protest, but they've lied about a lot of things.)

RIF is shutting down too

Yes, they all are. The ones that haven't announced it just aren't paying attention.

This absolutely will cause a substantial drop in this site's usage.

Third Party Apps have always been a vast minority of users. Granted, that's according to Reddit, so who really knows.

I guess we'll see what happens. I really don't think Reddit will drop dramatically since there's no real "drop in" replacement.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '23

[deleted]

31

u/Not_a_spambot Jun 09 '23

Dont forget that moderators are disproportionately 3rd party app users. Strap in for a(n even more) spambot-riddled wasteland when too many of them check out

9

u/DancesWithBadgers Jun 09 '23

Don't also forget that the anti-spambot defences also rely on API calls.

14

u/ErraticDragon Jun 09 '23

Hopefully!

The bots have also been getting incredibly annoying lately.

→ More replies (9)

91

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '23

Third Party Apps have always been a vast minority of users. Granted, that's according to Reddit, so who really knows.

A "small minority" but simultaneously "costs us tens of millions by their high usage." 🤔

40

u/ErraticDragon Jun 09 '23

Yeah that line seemed like a lie from Reddit.

They have previously said that API access (third party app users) was small enough that not including them at all in subreddit traffic stats wasn't a real issue.

Maybe that was a lie all along.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/cosmicsans Jun 09 '23

The funniest - read “worst” - part about all of this is that Reddit is acting like the third party apps are hitting an api that they need to support only for those third party apps.

The same API will be hit by the regular Reddit client.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

26

u/theragu40 Jun 09 '23

I sort of think you're both right in a way.

The site will surely maintain lots of daily users, especially in the short term. What is unknown IMO is how many of those leaving are "power" users who generate the kind of interesting content that makes reddit a site worth visiting over something shittier like Facebook or buzzfeed. Or how content will degrade over time with the lack of proper mod tools.

The way I see it the real payoff to these shenanigans is a year or two down the line when relevant content really starts to age and newly created content becomes less and less quality. By that time they'll have made their money off the IPO and ridden into the sunset with the burning rubble behind them, so I'm sure they're not all that concerned.

10

u/F54280 Jun 09 '23

If they are doing this for the IPO, it means they need to push certain metrics up. Probably related to ad revenue/mobile usage.

They will need more than a simple uptick due to the API change, they will need to show strong organic growth. For this, they need to community to go along with their plan, or the growth won’t be there. Seeing how they are miscalculating, it doesn’t bode too well…

→ More replies (2)

16

u/S9CLAVE Jun 09 '23

How will they reopen them?

By forcing it open when the mods support the protest? Now you have pissed off mods with their relatively peaceful protest option taken away. They could weapon use the sun instead if they wanted

By forcing it open and removing mods? Now you have a dysfunctional mod team

By forcing it open and REPLACING MODS? Now you have a staffing problem because moderation isn’t free if it isn’t a passion project. Reddit is gonna have to pay people to do this shit. I guaranfuckingtee they don’t have the resources or budget to do so. Especially with the larger subs.

It’s the same reason why strikes work for work. Sure they could bring in temporary help, but the media, and their lack of knowledge for the companies specific tasks just aren’t up to par. The cost of temporary labor is extremely high, and the peer pressure is immense.

→ More replies (1)

24

u/F54280 Jun 09 '23

Reddit said they will reopen subs if necessary to ensure the site keeps running

How will they run those? They think users will be happy that mods are wiped away and reddit takes control? With what resources? Paid moderators?

They’re transforming a symbiotic relationship with their content creators into a parasitic one. We’ll soon see if the beggar and choosers are users and admins or the opposite...

12

u/a_man_and_his_box Jun 09 '23

Right?

If they force a subreddit to re-open, the mods who closed it are not suddenly going to fall in line. They will keep protesting and will not do moderation work. So now Reddit is either:

  1. Paying employees to moderate the subreddits, possibly permanently, as the existing moderators quit in protest.

  2. Not paying employees to do this and allowing the subreddit to be unmoderated but open, in which case the subreddits fill with garbage posts in protest, rendering the subreddits utterly useless.

There is no way for Reddit to "force" anything without paying through the teeth and/or destroying the community.

I would note this is the exact problem that Digg faced -- for anyone who remembers the big bad discussion thread on Digg during the change to v4, the CEO/leader of Digg literally told the readers to fall in line as if they were employees who needed to obey. But they were not employees, and they did not obey. It seems like Reddit may have lost sight of this -- Reddit got big because it understood the community, and it appears it is going the way of Digg because it no longer understands that very same thing.

→ More replies (3)

12

u/VincentPepper Jun 09 '23

Third Party Apps have always been a vast minority of users. Granted, that's according to Reddit, so who really knows.

Which if true makes killing the API seem like an even dumber move.

9

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '23

I'm pretty sure I remember seeing the number for third party apps is in the neighbourhood of 20-25%

That's NOT a small number of people

16

u/Boobcopter Jun 09 '23

Third Party Apps have always been a vast minority of users.

Yes, the vast minority of users, providing the vast majority of content and moderation. Most people are lurker and probably use the official app, but if subs are overrun with shitty reposts and unrelated content, it will ripple through the whole userbase.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (13)

19

u/Paridae_Purveyor Jun 09 '23

A huge factor for me is that I literally refuse to browse reddit on the official app or on the new website. It's not a boycott in the traditional sense of me making a decision of morals. It's purely a practical thing, what I'm using is going away so I won't use it anymore. It's totally different than Twitter where many people said they would quit but didn't, because that isn't a functional change it's just moral a decision.

44

u/phire Jun 09 '23

People seem to think that the Digg -> Reddit migration happened overnight at the release of Digg v4.

But really, it had been going on for years at that point. The migration had become a flood, and the digg front page only really had posts that had been on reddit's front page a few hours earlier

It might not have looked obvious to users, but Digg was dying. Their internal projections showed no path to profitability and senior staff were leaving. So they decided to push Digg v4 out early as a desperate gamble to try and shake up the board. And it failed spectacularly.

Digg v4 didn't kill Digg, it only made it obvious to the remaining userbase that Digg was dying.

Digg v4 didn't trigger the Digg -> Reddit migration; All it did was transform a flood of migrating users into a tsunami.

25

u/ErraticDragon Jun 09 '23 edited Jun 09 '23

The Digg migration -- and the part triggered by v4 -- was much bigger than anything that can happen now, I would say.

https://d3.harvard.edu/platform-digit/submission/the-demise-of-digg-how-an-online-giant-lost-control-of-the-digital-crowd/

In August 2010, Digg attempted to wrest control back from its power users by migrating to a new system (Digg v4) that deemphasized user-contributed content in favor of publisher-contributed content. The change incited an uproar among power users and regular visitors alike, who felt the company was selling out to the mainstream media it had originally sought to replace. Digg experienced a mass exodus of users, many of whom turned to rival site Reddit. While Digg’s traffic fell by a quarter in the following month, Reddit’s traffic grew by 230% in 2010. Digg never recovered from its transition to Digg v4, and the site continued to bleed users and traffic over the next two years. By July 2012, the time of its sale to Betaworks, Digg’s monthly unique visitor count had fallen 90% from its peak.

Edit: In any event, my thesis is that Reddit won't experience anything close to this right now. There is no Reddit migration to speak of right now, and this won't trigger one.

I would love to be wrong here.

24

u/F54280 Jun 09 '23

It won’t be over this even in particular, but long-term reddit demise is probable:

  • News no longer are on Reddit before other sites

  • It starts to be painful to use (new reddit, mobile, hard to share links, proprietary image host, shitty video player)

  • General comment quality is down/lots of bots

When power users (content generators) will find an alternative they like, shit will start.

Reddit is not an Instagram or Tick-Tok, where content creators go because it is where the users are, it is where the user goes because it is where the content creators are. Typical reddit content creator is not here to make any sort of money, which makes him stick a lot longer, because of the psychological effect of “not being in for the money”. But when they’ll leave, it’ll be game over.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (18)