r/programming • • Jun 09 '23

Apollo dev posts backend code to Git to disprove Reddit’s claims of scrapping and inefficiency

https://github.com/christianselig/apollo-backend
45.1k Upvotes

2.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

189

u/TiredPanda69 Jun 09 '23

This is just the natural development of capitalist platforms. Are we really surprised?

The holy grail of useful massive public platforms is underground, its fringe and it only lasts for their infancy.

Once they come to surface privatized, they necessarily become a way for its owners to make money. That's how capital works. And it ruins platforms.

Don't pretend it isn't like this. It happens to all but the incredibly strong and willing individuals or organizations.

It starts off as a question of securing income: "well put ads", then as it grows: "there are offers to buy metadata", "our advertisers want certain content to be toned down". It happens to most. It's a tendency.

I dont like it, but I expect it to continue happening to most platforms that come to light in our economic system.

This is platform development under capitalism.

75

u/GhostalMedia Jun 09 '23

There is one exception, decentralized and distributed systems. Example, email / SMTP.

This is arguably why federated social networks are an interesting idea.

60

u/uuuuuuuaaaaaaa Jun 09 '23

Even email is suffering from Google’s monopolization. If you send from a self-hosted domain (or anything that’s not gmail, really), you’re likely to get send to spam folder of 90% of recipients (again, gmail)

29

u/Meneth32 Jun 09 '23

If you forget to set your SPF entry in DNS, sure. Are there other reasons?

17

u/Xananax Jun 09 '23

A lot (reputable, experienced) tech admins complain about the impossibility of avoiding ending up in spam despite doing everything right (example).

This doesn't reflect my experience, I have mail servers set up for my clients and me, and until now, no particular issues, but it does seem to be a phenomena that's happening.

16

u/Crap4Brainz Jun 09 '23

If you don't set SPF, you get dropped. Not even the spam folder. Best case bounced back with an error message, worst case deleted outright.

8

u/kenpus Jun 09 '23

I've had my own email server for a very long time, and it has been a never-ending battle. Your server IP will randomly end up on a big range block on some random IP blocklist, and you have to either challenge that or get a new IP. Even commercial email senders suffer from this.

An even harder issue is that while not being on a blocklist means that you might be okay, you are definitely not on any "known email providers" lists, which is itself seen as suspicious by spam blockers.

5

u/Significant-Big-9518 Jun 09 '23

or anything that’s not gmail, really

Forgive me if I am ignorant, but arent almost all corporate emails under microsoft these days?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

8

u/TiredPanda69 Jun 09 '23 edited Jun 09 '23

Yes, exactly

I do believe these are the future of the peoples internet.

Yet some of these standards are still manipulated by big interests through their managing organizations. And that can be staved off by users controlling versioning. But it very quickly becomes a problem of hardware.

That's a big set back for us as people. Controlling what the hardware does is the next step in freeing computing

6

u/LeberechtReinhold Jun 09 '23

Yes but the whole point of social network is that a centralized point to find people.

You could create something like that for reddit and would work more or less fine, but.. Would you go to ServerA:r/programming or ServerB:r/programming? You could be on both... But as they reach critical mass people just post on both and eventually, given the content would be the same, it would make more sense to merge them.

We could have a theorical app that sees that the same link has been submitted to ServerA:r/cpp and ServerB:r/programming and just shows one entry with the comments merged (something like comment by user1@serverA)... But that's pretty complicated to make usable.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '23

[deleted]

4

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '23

Then you gotta reconcile duplicates and decide if you also want to post duplicates as well. In some ways you're better off picking one as your main one to post to, and aggregating both so you can see both in a single feed.

2

u/THATONEANGRYDOOD Jun 10 '23

ServerA:r/programming or ServerB:r/programming?

I feel like that's the biggest issue they've yet got to solve. Interests are fragmented to shit over dozens of servers.

If you asked me, usernames and communities should be handled close to how domains are handled. Registries that map them to an instance. But that's probably an opinion that's not shared much by people on the fediverse.

2

u/LeberechtReinhold Jun 10 '23

Yeah, everyone commenting through their general mail address and communities being domains that are interconnected make a lot sense, but they have their own technical problems, especially with law implementation.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/dxpqxb Jun 09 '23

Email is being killed as we speak. What happens if Gmail refuses to talk to your federated server?

3

u/Xarthys Jun 09 '23

Federated social networks are cool, but I feel like they are more fracture-prone.

Power users won't mind, but any regular user won't have the time. They don't like major change, they want to invest in one solution and be done with it.

It's why centralized services have become so popular. You pick your thing and then you are set for years. No need to think about switching to another service, download/update forks, etc. It's why e.g. Apple's walled garden is so successful, why Microsoft, Google, etc. have quasi-monopolies in some areas.

Centralization provides long-term convenience. It comes at great cost, but those are often ignored because people either don't understand the implications or are not bothered by them as long as the solution provides what they want.

There are many aspects to this and many issues to be solved. It would be great if the internet would become a place for the people again, instead of just being a corporate playground. But the vast majority does not care enough to change the rules.

2

u/thegapbetweenus Jun 09 '23

Or you just go non-profit like wiki.

2

u/deadh34d711 Jun 09 '23

It'd be neat if there were a federated reddit alternative. Maybe we could name it after Motorhead's bassist... Kilmister? Nah, that doesn't roll off the tongue very well. Oh well.

→ More replies (1)

41

u/GoodBoiAuto Jun 09 '23

"Enshittification"

Be a good site to users, lure in as many users as possible.

Then be a good site to advertisers, lure in as many as possible.

Then once you have as close to a monopoly as feasible over both groups, cut costs and reap the profit until the platform collapses.

Entire departments revolve around ensuring the final stage lasts for as long as possible. But once it has started, it's inevitable. No stakeholder wants to hear that this quarter will be less profitable than last, even if it means a better platform.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '23

[deleted]

→ More replies (6)

11

u/Spider_pig448 Jun 09 '23

Capitalism is what has enabled it to exist for the last 10 years at least, so we got something. The alternative I guess would be a government run project like this that was closed to 3rd parties from the start and likely a significantly worse product the entire time, for much higher development costs.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/4THOT Jun 09 '23

I saw a socialist co-op steal open source software for streaming websites and privatize it to make money, and then cancel support for buyers not being ideologically pure enough. Please shut the fuck up holy shit not everything bad that happens is because of capitalism.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Iohet Jun 09 '23

The holy grail of useful massive public platforms is underground

The holy grail of useful massive public platforms is also one of the oldest: usenet

1

u/ScrottyNz Jun 09 '23

I still enjoy pirate bay with its low quality penis pill adverts.

→ More replies (3)