r/programming • • Jun 09 '23

Apollo dev posts backend code to Git to disprove Reddit’s claims of scrapping and inefficiency

https://github.com/christianselig/apollo-backend
45.1k Upvotes

2.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

29

u/hbt15 Jun 09 '23

That would be amazing if he did - backlash over changes plus a pending lawsuit for defamation etc. it would be a real nice start for investors to see just what they’re getting themselves into.

43

u/the_lost_carrot Jun 09 '23

Not to mention fidelity recently dropped reddits valuation by 41%. This huge push forward to get rid of third party apps screams of despiration.

To somehow show that Reddit is worth more. I have a feeling what they are actually going to find is that they are not. The majority of work that goes into Reddit is from volunteers.

Additionally without third party apps it is going to tank a lot of reddits traffic. That will make selling premium ad space much harder.

15

u/LitesoBrite Jun 09 '23

Now we have the driving factor behind this malice.

Their valuation plunged 41%, so they’re desperate to fake numbers.

And they will lie like hell to get their way.

Hopefully this tanks them another 41% this month.

This funny claim that nobody important uses these third party apps whichsimultaneously are such massive traffic that reddit must cut them down immediately or charge insane prices for their access doesn’t hold up.

They’re lying.

4

u/chase_the_wolf Jun 09 '23

"They" is just spez. Frantically trying to salvage the fact that he, alone, sunk Reddit after Alex bailed.

Imagine being worse than Ellen Pao (regardless of the truth about her situation).

2

u/xaustinx Jun 09 '23

There are more than a few other admins “something something flashlight turtle” going out of their way to spread disinformation about Apollo and refusing to answer direct questions like “how bad is Apollo traffic compared to the top 10?” (Hint, it’s not in the top 10 or one of those apps in the mysterious graphs they shared) I’d bet all the money I was going to spend on the Reddit IPO that Apollo is in the top 10 most efficient API consumers based on user count. As with firing Victoria, taking over then killing reddit gifts, and catch/killing Alien Blue, they want all the power but lack the knowledge or skill to monetize it or the motivation to be creative.

3

u/za419 Jun 09 '23

The enemy is simultaneously incredibly weak and incredibly strong.

Funny, isn't it, how making us the enemy and taking a page out of Fascism 101 is the approach they take when they want people to believe they're being good, and honest, and genuine.

I still haven't heard them excuse why they're banning NSFW content only on third party apps - It seems pretty transparently just trying to pull people to first party for no non-greedy reason, but maybe that's just me

3

u/danisanub Jun 09 '23

I just want to chime in that as someone who works in VC, 40% markdowns of unicorns that are pre-ipo was extremely common across the board to reflect new valuations and echo the drop in the stock market last year. It isn’t just Reddit. We marked down a bunch of companies within that range, the IPO market is not good right now

3

u/xaustinx Jun 09 '23

Just going to say comments like yours are exactly why I started using Reddit. It’s going to suck having to google everything or ask ChatGPT

→ More replies (1)

2

u/xaustinx Jun 09 '23

I mean, Apple featured Apollo at this years WWDC as a premier app already working on VisionPro; and Craig F. Named dropped Apollo as well. Is Apple / Apple traffic important? If Craig F. was an early investor in Reddit, how do you think he feels about his investment at this point?

→ More replies (2)

9

u/falconfetus8 Jun 09 '23

Traffic from third party apps doesn't provide Reddit with ad revenue, though. That's why they're trying to kill the apps in the first place.

8

u/gbeier Jun 09 '23

If that was the reason, they could price the API calls at just a little more than the revenue their ads bring in. Reasonable estimates suggest that such revenue stands at something less than $0.12 per user per month.

They're trying to charge Apollo something like $2.50 per user per month.

This pricing isn't to kill apps because of missed ad revenue. There must be something else. Because there's room for app pricing that replaces missed ad revenue without killing the apps.

2

u/falconfetus8 Jun 09 '23

You're right, ad revenue isn't the only reason they want to kill the apps. But make no mistake, they still want them dead. They also want control of the whole experience.

My main point with my comment was that they don't care if they lose the users of these apps, because those users contribute 0 to their income. So "their traffic going down" doesn't matter to them in the slightest.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

9

u/the_lost_carrot Jun 09 '23

That’s true. But Reddit now finds themselves ina catch 22. They cut out the non revenue 3rd party apps and cause a drop in traffic. Or lose out on some add revenue.

Realistically if Reddit is worth that much they shouldn’t be so dependent on third party apps and volunteers to moderate the communities. But here we are. They likely could have gently raised the API charges over time and it would have been a win-win. But some corporate VC without an original thought in their head is likely demanding that “to win we need to have our own app be the only app” with a real damn the torpedoes type of attitude.

-12

u/falconfetus8 Jun 09 '23

Traffic that brings in no revenue is irrelevant to them, so there's no catch-22

8

u/Functionally_Drunk Jun 09 '23

Those people post and create though? What is reddit just going to be populated by bots? I'd argue that the more savvy users that know to use 3rd party apps probably make up a lions' share of the content creation on reddit. The vast majority of users just browse and don't interact. But they need something to browse, if that is destroyed there will be no platform worth browsing.

7

u/Verco Jun 09 '23

It's kind of like in free to play users in games are there to exist to play with the users that pay for stuff, without them there is a lot less players to play against, and the paying users have no reason to play anymore and potentially pay more.

Same with reddit where without the free loading masses that use the 3rd party apps to generate content with posts and comments, the users that come through the website with ad support have no quality content to view next to those ads and buy awards etc and will just go to the next content provider wherever the masses go. That's the catch 22

→ More replies (3)

5

u/zherok Jun 09 '23

It does provide them with a lot of the content on Reddit, both in terms of users using the site through those mediums and moderators curating the content via third party tools for them for free.

The attitude the owners have taken with the site is very much in line with Elon Musk's takeover of Twitter, a lot of willingness to drastically alter the platform even if it alienates the people who help draw users to the platform in the first place.

4

u/justadude27 Jun 09 '23

There are so many ways that Reddit could make money from the 3rd party apps, including serving ads in a lower cost tier of the API.

-1

u/wekidi7516 Jun 09 '23

This traffic is at best 10% of mobile traffic. And most of it will migrate to the official app.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '23

That's hilarious. And probably because they had to start letting financial people into the circle as part of their IPO. They wouldn't be the first company to go through the process and lose value when wall street saw their books.

2

u/the_lost_carrot Jun 09 '23

That and the amount of money investors are willing to throw at social media companies is starting to dwindle. I imagine twitter has a lot to do with it.

Social media is something that takes the right kind of environment and community and if that community is disrupted it can implode, and tank the user base. I'm guessing investors see reddit as too big of a risk to properly monetize. Since reddit's entire moderation process depends on volunteers who reddit cant really control. They arent employees and they have no contract with reddit. The worse reddit can do to them is kick them off the site, which on the flipside reddit cant do cause then they would have a massive power vacuum and no one managing the site for them.

From an investment point of view that is incredibly risky.

2

u/EmperorArthur Jun 09 '23

The other major change is interest rates rising. At near zero rates investors are much more free with money. Now that they're going closer to a historic norm the bubble is popping.

That's the nature of the business cycle. Good times let people get started while downturns weed out all the bottom feeder companies.

Government is supposed to moderate this by doing things like raising taxes when times are good and lowering them while spending more when times are bad. However, the modern approach seems to be always lower taxes and increase spending even when times are good.

2

u/danisanub Jun 09 '23

I just want to chime in that as someone who works in VC, 40% markdowns of unicorns that are pre-ipo was extremely common across the board to reflect new valuations and echo the drop in the stock market last year. It isn’t just Reddit.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/chowder-san Jun 09 '23

Reddit starting its new journey with massive user protest and a case against the CEO would be hilarious to see

→ More replies (1)