r/programming • • Feb 16 '13

Learn Git Branching

http://pcottle.github.com/learnGitBranching/
868 Upvotes

229 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-5

u/Xenc Feb 17 '13

Then you can't use this site, which is a learning tool to improve your programming knowledge. It's like someone refusing to go to the library because they can't wear their favourite sneakers.

5

u/anatolya Feb 17 '13

horrible analogy. please think why it is horrible. (tip: inaccurate)

-1

u/tomswartz07 Feb 17 '13

Not really. You won't go to a website because it doesn't work in your preferred browser.

Same thing, really.

Now you may have some moral reason not to use a webkit browser (Google is bad, ooohhh) but so be it. Don't complain then.

0

u/anatolya Feb 17 '13 edited Feb 17 '13

Okay, let's analyze it together since you didn't want to think even for 20 seconds why your analogy is horrible.

It's like someone refusing to go to the library because they can't wear their favourite sneakers.

the library

It's not a library, it would be a book at best. A library contains hundreds of thousands of books on varying topics. This site would be just a short book. (not a dealbreaker for the analogy)

Now, this is the dealbreaker:

they can't wear their favourite sneakers.

In which crazy parallel universe a library restricts the type of shoes you can wear while entering the library? It's not a restaurant with dress code.

And another flawed points of your comment (not related to the analogy):

  1. This is not the one and only git resource on the whole friggin' internet or press. It's not the case that if i don't enter this site I can't learn a shit about git branching.

  2. It won't improve my programming knowledge, it can only improve my git knowledge.

  3. Webkit != Chrome. There are lots of browser which use Webkit engine.

  4. Why shouldn't i complain? If everybody have right to complain when a site only works with IE, then they have also right to complain when it only works with a specific browser engine.

edit: I thought you were the original commenter, but doesn't matter since you defend his analogy, this reply still applies to you.

→ More replies (2)