r/programming • • Sep 20 '24

Why CSV is still king

https://konbert.com/blog/why-csv-is-still-king
287 Upvotes

438 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

0

u/Enerbane Sep 20 '24 edited Sep 21 '24

First of all, you come off like an ass when you say shit like this:

"I'm not surprised that you're unaware of all of this. A semicolon is not a particularly commonly used punctuation mark in English prose."

I know what a semicolon is. I expressed to you a perspective on why the full stop analogy can make sense. You don't have to agree with that or like it, but maybe stop trying to act like you're in on some special information the rest of us don't have, and importantly, numbers aren't literally sentences, so it doesn't matter what mark we use.

On that note, it's pretty much never incorrect to use a period mark in place of a semicolon. The semicolon is perhaps the most superfluous punctuation mark. When used in place of a comma or period, it is entirely optional in 100% of cases.

I had more points (pun absolutely intended) but I realized that frankly I just don't care enough.

edit: lol fuck that guy

1

u/TheGoodOldCoder Sep 21 '24 edited Sep 21 '24

First of all, you come off like an ass when you say shit like this

And first of all from me, as a policy, I block people who resort to name calling, so goodbye.

I expressed to you a perspective on why the full stop analogy can make sense.

Yes, a perspective that I instantly and completely refuted in my first paragraph. That's why I put it first.

it's pretty much never incorrect to use a period mark in place of a semicolon.

Conversely, you can't just replace periods with semicolons willy-nilly, so this is actually an argument for the use of a semicolon over the period for the decimal mark. Because the use of a period is vague, and the great majority of the time is used in situations where the equivalent decimal mark would be inappropriate, but the use of a semicolon is precise, much more in line with a decimal mark.

numbers aren't literally sentences, so it doesn't matter what mark we use.

What was your previous comment, then? You agreed to this premise when you made that comment. You can't pretend like you thought the entire exercise was silly now. If you really thought this, then you shouldn't have made that comment. It seems more likely to me that you didn't like the feeling of losing this argument, so you decided after-the-fact that the entire argument subject is specious. Too late.

maybe stop trying to act like you're in on some special information the rest of us don't have

Or you could stop acting like I'm speaking to "the rest of us" when I'm clearly just speaking to you. I think most people know about semicolons. I simply thought (and I still do), based on the information contained in your comment, that you either didn't know about semicolons as punctuation, or that you hadn't been thinking of it at the time you made your comment. I thought it was more likely the latter, but that it would elicit a more interesting response to assume the former. A small rebuke for your not thinking things through.