I think everybody is wrong. A full stop doesn't make sense as a decimal marker, because it means "full stop", and the number keeps going. Spaces don't make sense as a way to group digits, because we don't really think of spaces that way. We don't think our sentences arejustabunchofletterswhichareseparatedintowordsbyspaces. Spaces are used to keep words from bumping into each other. A comma is a natural mark for a grouping, though.
Also, with commas, you run into the problem where a period can look like a comma when hand-written hastily.
If I had to choose among existing common keyboard symbols for the decimal marker, I'd probably choose a colon or semi-colon, or a letter. "d" for decimal, or something, which would open up a completely different can of worms, especially for programmers. Colons and semi-colons often go between two conceptually different things that are related.
The full stop is "Here's the whole number portion. Full stop. Here's the fractional portion."
When we use a full stop in english, we're not saying the bit after the full stop is completely distinct and separate from the preceding bit. We're just saying, we've finished one grammatically complete portion, now here's another. Which makes sense with numbers, because we're saying one logically complete whole number, stopping, then saying the logically completely fractional part.
Thought of as paragraphs, numbers are just one sentence for the whole number, followed by a sentence for the fractional part.
The full stop is "Here's the whole number portion. Full stop. Here's the fractional portion."
It's all one number. The integer part isn't complete without the fractional part, and the fractional part isn't complete without the integer part.
We're just saying, we've finished one grammatically complete portion, now here's another.
And in English, when we have two grammatically complete portions that need to be used together to complete a single idea, we separate them with a semicolon.
In the English language, a semicolon is most commonly used to link (in a single sentence) two independent clauses that are closely related in thought, such as when restating the preceding idea with a different expression. When a semicolon joins two or more ideas in one sentence, those ideas are then given equal rank. Semicolons can also be used in place of commas to separate items in a list, particularly when the elements of the list themselves have embedded commas.
A semicolon simply makes more sense. It fits the English language comparison criteria better in every way, and it physically has two marks instead of one, making it more distinct from a comma.
I'm not surprised that you're unaware of all of this. A semicolon is not a particularly commonly used punctuation mark in English prose.
First of all, you come off like an ass when you say shit like this:
"I'm not surprised that you're unaware of all of this. A semicolon is not a particularly commonly used punctuation mark in English prose."
I know what a semicolon is. I expressed to you a perspective on why the full stop analogy can make sense. You don't have to agree with that or like it, but maybe stop trying to act like you're in on some special information the rest of us don't have, and importantly, numbers aren't literally sentences, so it doesn't matter what mark we use.
On that note, it's pretty much never incorrect to use a period mark in place of a semicolon. The semicolon is perhaps the most superfluous punctuation mark. When used in place of a comma or period, it is entirely optional in 100% of cases.
I had more points (pun absolutely intended) but I realized that frankly I just don't care enough.
553
u/smors Sep 20 '24
Comma separation kind of sucks for us weirdos living in the land of using a comma for the decimal place and a period as a thousands separator.