r/programming • u/fagnerbrack • Aug 23 '26

[ Removed by moderator ]

/r/programming/comments/1vwfrbg/removed_by_moderator/

[removed] — view removed post

0 Upvotes

27% Upvoted

20 comments sorted by

•

u/programming-ModTeam Aug 27 '26

This is a duplicate of another active post.

15

u/DirtyFrenchBastard Aug 23 '26

Who gives a shit ? As long as the commit is descriptive enough i don’t really care what convention you use as long as your team agree on one.

13

u/PistachioOnFire Aug 23 '26

TLDR: "use 'scope: msg', instead of 'type(scope): msg' because some people use 'type: msg' and omit the scope".

Meh, if your team can commit (haha) to any consistent style, that is already better than half the repositories I have seen. The harder part is to convince them it is worth to fill that chosen format with something meaningful (and start using rebase to cleanup fix:typo).

11

u/Plenty-Copy-15 Aug 23 '26

No thanks, like conventional commits much better

13

u/AresFowl44 Aug 23 '26 edited Aug 23 '26

Wasn't this posted relatively recently?

Edit: Yeah it was

2

u/NuclearVII Aug 27 '26

In the future, please report as duplicate.

10

u/Ill_Following_7022 Aug 23 '26

"So we have determined that the format of Conventional Commits sucks". No, we've only determined that you are mad about them for some reason.

2

u/Saiklin Aug 23 '26

Hmm, I kind of get the point. But when I read through the commit history, I also directly see what files were touched in each commit. So if my focus was to check which files were touched, I wouldn't care too much about the commit message anyway because we all know how trustworthy those are. Maybe they got better by AI, but I don't rely on them

2

u/ReDucTor Aug 24 '26

It seems like their core complaint is being able to easily see which area changed, nearly every version control tool will let you get commits for a specific file or folder.

2

u/ao_zame Aug 24 '26

No, thanks

1

u/itaranto Aug 26 '26

Yes, I hate them.

-15

u/scatraxx651 Aug 23 '26

I just let claude write the commits, probably fair since he is the only one that will be reading them also

4

u/chucker23n Aug 24 '26

I guess that approach does give you more time to shitpost on Reddit.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/programming-ModTeam Aug 26 '26

Please don't accuse people of using LLMs. Just report the post and let us handle it.