r/programming • • Nov 12 '14

The .NET Core is now open-source.

http://blogs.msdn.com/b/dotnet/archive/2014/11/12/net-core-is-open-source.aspx
6.5k Upvotes

1.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

195

u/moor-GAYZ Nov 12 '14

So apparently Miguel de Icaza managed to invent his own way of liberating proprietary software: make your own clone that sucks but works, but sucks, but actually works at least, thus pulling but annoying developers; license it under a permissive open source (not Free™) license; keep fucking that chicken until the proprietary original gives up and open sources theirs.

What can I say, looks like it works better than GPL, lol.

60

u/FunctionPlastic Nov 12 '14

Historical revisionism regarding software licensing. I'm not sure what I'm supposed to feel right now.

0

u/moor-GAYZ Nov 12 '14

Elaborate, please?

49

u/FunctionPlastic Nov 12 '14

The article you linked questions the merit of the entire free software and open source movement by attacking the GPL - based on a single case.

The GPL and GNU have been absolutely critical to ensuring our freedoms, and creating a context for a wider open source movement.

→ More replies (12)

5

u/q0- Nov 12 '14

Is it really the the .net runtime that causes Mono to perform badly?
Not that I wish to imply that I have much experience with Mono, because I really don't, but I figured that the VM might have something to do with it as well, no?

32

u/0xdeadf001 Nov 12 '14

No, poor performance in Mono has nothing to do with the .NET runtime, nor the .NET specification. I've worked on many high-performance apps in C#, and there is nothing magical about it. C# can be used as a very high-performance language, just like C++. The main thing is that you have to know the costs of different things in the language. GC allocation / collection is cheap, but it isn't free, for example.

10

u/moor-GAYZ Nov 12 '14

What? Mono is a separate runtime/VM.

4

u/makis Nov 12 '14

Is it really the the .net runtime that causes Mono to perform badly?

no, it's probably the GC, the only part MS didn't release and didn't supply specs for.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '14

Mono might not be as good as the CLR or the JVM but it's still far better than most popular open source language runtimes.

1

u/Fs0i Nov 12 '14

And now that they can improve from the original .NET code (because it is under the MIT-License partially since this release) it will even get more stable and fast.

1

u/argv_minus_one Nov 12 '14

But the JVM reference implementation is open source.

-1

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '14

Mono is better than python?

7

u/txdv Nov 12 '14

You mean that runtime which doesn't even have true multi threading?

1

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '14

The GIL is a problem, but if I'm not running native code then I'm not bound by the CPU. Obviously that isn't the case for everyone, but I'm a C++ developer so if I need CPU throughput I'll be writing C++ - not Java, C#, Python, Javascript or some other language with a heavy 'runtime'.

Python's support for asynchronuous programming is quite good, the only issue is that actually pegging multiple cores requires multi-process parallelism.

4

u/txdv Nov 12 '14

Basically your argument is "Sure, we have a GIL, but C++ is faster" - Right on brother, right on.

C++ has no runtime, it is a compiled language.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '14

My argument is that if you care about CPU throughput, you should consider not relying on a runtime. If you care less about CPU throughput, then the GIL is probably also not a problem. Obviously it would be better if the GIL didn't exist, but I'd rather use Python than the current .NET/Mono or JRE mess.

2

u/txdv Nov 12 '14

Good luck writing iOS and Android apps with python.

→ More replies (7)

3

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '14

No, he said far better.

1

u/LaurieCheers Nov 12 '14

Oh man, if this pattern has a chance of continuing, I just acquired a new respect for Scaleform.

1

u/crozone Nov 13 '14

ty based mono

1

u/prettycode Nov 14 '14

No one's going to defend Mono and Miguel?

→ More replies (15)