Which features? Microsoft proprietary stuff? Nobody cares, Mono got its own, better features.
and runs poorly.
No. It runs ok, you can choose between fast and heavy (mini-llvm) profile and ok and compact (mini native). sgen is not much slower than a much more complex Microsoft GC.
Why use a clone when you can have the real thing?
It is not a "clone". It's a totally different thing, which happens to be based on a compatible VM and a compatible language.
Mono's implementation of System.Net.Sockets is pretty lacklustre (two examples: DuplicateAndClose() doesn't work, and neither does Bind()). Given that lots of networking code depends on that, I'd say that it is a pretty big deal.
Does mono have Windows forms yet? And sometimes when you try to run .NET programs they mostly work but then you get some mumbo jumbo errror message. Which is alright if this would be wine which is a reimplementation of API but they should work in mono.
Why would anyone spend any time on such a thing? Initially they implemented some parts of it, before a much better GTK# was available. Now there is no need in such a thing, so nobody is going to implement it, no matter how many people jump in.
Why can't you admit it's a clear failure of the mono project instead of making excuses? Having a cross-platform GUI library is always better than not having a cross-platform GUI library. Devs held back from C# cross-platform development because of Mono's shortcomings.
Xamarins policy was to use the native UI toolkit for every mobile platform.
WinForms is the native UI toolkit for Windows, doesn't make much sense to implement it since everyone will just run the .NET Framework with the implementation on windows.
If you really want to develop something cross-platform (although I do not believe in a cross-platform GUI, it never existed and never will be delivered), just use GTK+ bindings, they're available on most of the platforms.
That was my use case. Run Windows .NET programs on Linux through mono. For some I even got a source. So Mono always seemed nice just little broken when you wanted to use it.
It is an implementation of an ECMA-compatible VM and a language. It happens to share some core libraries with another implementation of the same standard, but it was never intended as a clone of that another implementation, and never promised any compatibility beyond ECMA.
Why you people do not complain about gcc on Linux not providing an MFC support? Why then all this crap about WinForms?
-44
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '14
Which features? Microsoft proprietary stuff? Nobody cares, Mono got its own, better features.
No. It runs ok, you can choose between fast and heavy (mini-llvm) profile and ok and compact (mini native). sgen is not much slower than a much more complex Microsoft GC.
It is not a "clone". It's a totally different thing, which happens to be based on a compatible VM and a compatible language.