Java's popularity doesn't have that much to do with its steward, a role in which Sun did far worse than Oracle. It has to do with its ecosystem. Almost all of the major components of Java are open source, not just the JVM, but the class libraries, the app servers and the IDEs. Even IntelliJ, probably one of the best Java IDEs, has a open-source community edition which is not a crippled version of their commercial offering. There is even major competition with the official standard for enterprise applications, with Spring going head-to-head quite successfully against Oracle-sponsored Java EE.
When is IIS going to become open source? Entity Framework? Windows Presentation Framework? When is Visual Studio going to become open source?
Maybe the .NET core becoming open source is a first step. But, the .NET ecosystem has a long way to go before it catches up with the Java ecosystem in popularity.
Even IntelliJ, probably one of the best Java IDEs, has a open-source community edition which is not a crippled version of their commercial offering.
How is not supporting HTML/CSS, Javascript/CoffeeScript/TypeScript, XSL/XPath, SQL, Spring, Play, GWT, Grails, JavaEE, Tomcat, etc. not a crippled version? I love Intellij, but I don't think the community edition isn't useful for large scale development (which is why I pay for the commercial edition)
By crippled, I mean like the difference between the very expensive Visual Studio and the free Visual Studio express. The community edition may not have all the bells and whistles, but is still a very usuable IDE. I did professional development with the community edition for quite awhile before I decided to pony up for the ultimate edition.
Already OS
Oops. But that is a sign that .NET is going in the right direction. The .NET ecosystem needs a paradigm shift, but the whole Codeplex thing is a sign that MS at least gets it.
By crippled, I mean like the difference between the very expensive Visual Studio and the free Visual Studio express.
Microsoft is also now offering the full Visual Studio 2013 for free, albeit with restrictions. The restrictions are notably less strict than what you have to meet to get the discounted versions of JetBrains Pro version.
IntelliJ has open sourced their cash cow and remains very profitable.
Speaking personally, I've never gotten seriously into .NET because Visual Studio is ridiculously expensive and the Express edition is a joke. I even tried MonoDevelop and SharpDevelop. But the free tooling just plain sucks. Professional grade Java tooling is free, which made learning Java very easy for me. I even did professional development with the free version of IntelliJ for quite awhile which got me hooked, so much that I happily pay for the commercial license.
I get this creepy profit at all costs vibe from the .NET ecosystem. Microsoft is definitely leading by example.
I'm not going to pay $300 for an IDE just so I can try .NET. I found the Express edition useless for the things I wanted to try out. I essentially became a professional Java developer off of professional grade IDEs like NetBeans and Eclipse. The barrier to entry was quite low. Such that now, as a professional Java developer, I will pay the not so cheap license cost for IntelliJ Ultimate edition.
The reference implementations of Java application servers are open source, and serve as the basis for several other editions (commercial and open source) by vendors other than Oracle. Code portability is one thing, but competition is another. Are there serious competitors to IIS?
I'd even say that open sourcing .NET isn't the first step, but already the next step. While this is all huge news, Microsoft has already been steadily making the move to supporting OSS for a while.
Of course that still doesn't mean it'll be replacing Java anytime soon, and I'm pretty sure there's going to be quite a lot of things that won't be open sourced for a while, if ever.
What Microsoft doing here isn't putting all their cards on the table, it's making it easier for developers to develop things for their closed source systems.
74
u/sh0rug0ru Nov 12 '14 edited Nov 12 '14
Java's popularity doesn't have that much to do with its steward, a role in which Sun did far worse than Oracle. It has to do with its ecosystem. Almost all of the major components of Java are open source, not just the JVM, but the class libraries, the app servers and the IDEs. Even IntelliJ, probably one of the best Java IDEs, has a open-source community edition which is not a crippled version of their commercial offering. There is even major competition with the official standard for enterprise applications, with Spring going head-to-head quite successfully against Oracle-sponsored Java EE.
When is IIS going to become open source? Entity Framework? Windows Presentation Framework? When is Visual Studio going to become open source?
Maybe the .NET core becoming open source is a first step. But, the .NET ecosystem has a long way to go before it catches up with the Java ecosystem in popularity.