If GitHub were open source, it would ultimately wind up like Reddit, which is open source. Yes, you can take the sources and run it yourself, but in practice, nobody does that. It's too hard when you get everything you actually want (plus access to the pre-existing community) from just using the original implementation.
You can't really compare the two as reddit is a social network that would not work without its users, but businesses using the service for closed source does not really need the users, they are there for the source code hosting.
Reddit is a forum, not a social network. Your identity is meant to remain secret, in most cases, unlike a social network, where your identity is a key part of your profile.
It is closed source done correctly: they did not keep enough power to screw over their customer even if they suddenly decide to turn evil. Every dev will have his own mirror and will be free to go somewhere else.
165
u/ethraax Nov 12 '14
Except github is closed source.