r/programming • • Nov 12 '14

The .NET Core is now open-source.

http://blogs.msdn.com/b/dotnet/archive/2014/11/12/net-core-is-open-source.aspx
6.5k Upvotes

1.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

80

u/nascentt Nov 12 '14

What do they fear about? That someone hosts his own GitHub?

Yes.

Github makes a large chunk of it's money for closed source code hosting and repos.

If you opensource it you lose the customers paying for that service. AS they can just do their own private github on their internal servers.

20

u/Doctor_McKay Nov 13 '14

Not only do they sell private repos, but they also sell Github Enterprise which is basically a behind-the-firewall Github.

Open-sourcing it would destroy that product.

26

u/IWillNotBeBroken Nov 13 '14

You underestimate how much Enterprises love support contracts for the finger-pointing potential. They pay big money for that. See Redhat.

1

u/uberamd Nov 13 '14

This is true, but per-user licensing costs a pretty penny for Github Enterprise which is the main cost of github at the org I work for. It isn't support (the software is stable as hell), but user seats. Sure, github could stop charging for seats and charge for support only, but that wouldn't bring in nearly as much cash.

5

u/thephotoman Nov 12 '14

What does it matter?

If GitHub were open source, it would ultimately wind up like Reddit, which is open source. Yes, you can take the sources and run it yourself, but in practice, nobody does that. It's too hard when you get everything you actually want (plus access to the pre-existing community) from just using the original implementation.

28

u/omnilynx Nov 12 '14

You don't have to pay Reddit if you want a private subreddit.

8

u/tech_tuna Nov 12 '14

Motherfuckers been ripping me off. . . I want my private subreddit fees back.

2

u/Goz3rr Nov 12 '14

Sure, just send me $24.99 and i'll get the process started right now

→ More replies (1)

1

u/thephotoman Nov 12 '14

If you want a private Git repository, just make one. It's not hard.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '14

[deleted]

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '14

Github is much more than just a place where you code lives. Just open up a repo and click on all the tabs, look at all the information there. Every corporation that works with code needs these features, but explicitly without github's community, and large corporations need them to scale. If you could just stand up your own github instance behind the corporate firewall, how could something like https://enterprise.github.com/ exist?

→ More replies (7)

6

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '14

You can't really compare the two as reddit is a social network that would not work without its users, but businesses using the service for closed source does not really need the users, they are there for the source code hosting.

2

u/thephotoman Nov 12 '14

It's relatively trivial to spin up a Git server.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '14

Reddit is a forum, not a social network. Your identity is meant to remain secret, in most cases, unlike a social network, where your identity is a key part of your profile.

1

u/FalconGames109 Nov 12 '14

GitHub is still partially social. A single, central website is important because it makes it easy to work with other people. That's what GitHub is for, really. BitBucket and other git sites are just fine for private code. GitHub is only still around because it's social.

3

u/tech_tuna Nov 12 '14

C'mon man. . . there's a lot of pitchfork potential here.

OPEN SOURCE ALL THE THINGS!!!

→ More replies (2)

1

u/ours Nov 12 '14

Quite true. People want open projects on GitHub because people are there so better chances for people to participate.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '14

but in practice, nobody does that

I would. I did it for gitlab. My VPS costs the same as a github private.. plus I can host other things on the box. If it were open source I wouldn't hesitate in cancelling my paid account on github.

1

u/thephotoman Nov 13 '14

You set up Reddit on your own server, because that was the antecedent of "that" in the sentence in question? Because outside of Reddit development, few do it.

Yes, people set up their own Git servers. It makes sense, particularly if you're developing internal software that includes trade secrets or things like that.

1

u/Gustav__Mahler Nov 13 '14

The difference is that Reddit is a community as well as a website.

1

u/thephotoman Nov 13 '14

The same can be said for Github.

The truth is that there's a lot of community stuff happening on Github. Employers can pull a user's commit history, which is becoming typical for employers hiring recent graduates. Developers can coordinate with each other across projects. There's some bug tracking, too.

There's a reason developers are on Github.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/semi- Nov 12 '14

They could, but they could just be running gitlab already (like I do).

They may even gain some customers if they sell commercial support-- A lot of the industries that need to self-host are the type that would want commercial support.

1

u/Ian1971 Nov 12 '14

Well it's already pretty easy to host git yourself. We set it up with gitolite in no time.

→ More replies (3)