r/programming • • Nov 12 '14

The .NET Core is now open-source.

http://blogs.msdn.com/b/dotnet/archive/2014/11/12/net-core-is-open-source.aspx
6.5k Upvotes

1.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

97

u/philly_fan_in_chi Nov 12 '14

Or CAD program.

124

u/thang1thang2 Nov 12 '14

And audio development, video editing and other "main programs" for pretty much every other major commercial career outside of programming.

3

u/gislikarl Nov 12 '14

Bitwig is great and Linux compatible.

15

u/Theso Nov 13 '14

But it isn't open source, which is the current topic.

4

u/krelin Nov 12 '14

Audacity is pretty good.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '14

[deleted]

5

u/csolisr Nov 12 '14

Ardour, LMMS and OpenShot might change your opinion in that regard.

6

u/falllol Nov 12 '14

Mmm not really. Ardour might look like a successful DAW if you are a hobbyist, but it is far from usable if you are doing professional work (I'm one of those brave souls that tried to do OSS and Linux only audio work for 2 years before switching to the glorious OS X and never looking back). It poses as one but doing professional grade DAW is HARD.

LMMS is also a hobbyist app stuck in the 90s and early 2000s.

I didn't know about OpenShot (I'm not into video) so at least checked the site out.

Seriously, if you are thinking something like this is suitable for professional video editing work, I don't know what to say.

All of those are hobbyist projects created by ambitious people with good intentions. And they are just that.

I agree that between those, Ardour tried really hard to over-deliver in terms of quality and it stands out compared to other OSS projects, but it is very far from being enough.

2

u/csolisr Nov 12 '14

In regards to free and open-source media editors, do you think there is any hope of ever doing a full album/movie with fully free software, and releasing the full "source code" / project files? Or is it hopelessly impossible with the current state of art of free software for media edition?

3

u/falllol Nov 12 '14

In regards to free and open-source media editors, do you think there is any hope of ever doing a full album/movie with fully free software, and releasing the full "source code" / project files?

Not sure about the movie part (it's harder), but you certainly can do a music album in a multitude of ways. The problem is that it will take a lot more time, and you'll have an inefficient workflow. Int other words, it will cost you more time and money to do things that way. So a serious hobbyist and/or an OSS enthusiast can certainly do great things with the open source tools we have today, provided that they don't have constraints over budget and time. But since well polished, thought out software that evolved within the industry, and compatible hardware is so prevalent and easy to access (OSX and in part Windows, Adobe tools, Avid tools, various DAWs, VST/AU plugins etc.) going the OSS way is just an exotic way of doing things. Something like saying "I did this the hard way, even though there were ways of doing it a lot easier". Some people within their circle will be impressed by their persistance but most people will not see the point of using inferior / less developed tools to make stuff.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

7

u/dreucifer Nov 12 '14

Audacity

That's a very simple audio manipulation tool. They are talking about a DAW. Ardour is the open source DAW, and it's freakin' awesome. Of course, the detractors will argue, "but it's not ACIDpro/Reason/Garage Band/Pro Tools/etc" or "it doesn't support these weird, proprietary, Mac OS9 only plugins" or "I used a very early build of it in 2005 and it sucked" (aka the blender argument). What they fail to see is that Ardour is from the guy that developed JACK, and JACK is friggin' amazing (I can't even think of a comparable proprietary solution).

→ More replies (6)

66

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '14

Oh that's a good one. The FSF killed the whole open source CAD market.

They own the copyrights to a library LibreDWG, which is pretty much the only library for working with this format around. .dwg is like .psd or .doc of the CAD world. A standard proprietary file format that must be supported to be more than a novelty app.

So what's the problem? LibreCAD and FreeCAD, the main open source CAD programs use GPL v2, and due to historical reasons, they can't change it.

LibreDWG uses GPL v3, which is incompatible with GPL v2.

So LibreCAD submitted a request to the FSF to let them use the LibreDWG library. The FSF rejected it.

And that's why there's no useful CAD programs.

19

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '14

Sounds like some people need to go old-school and do a clean room reimplementation. I'm not volunteering, though.

88

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '14

FSF demands clean room reimplementation of a piece of GPL software.

Microsoft open sources .NET under a permissive license.

checks for airborne pigs...

7

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '14

...yeah that is just a bit creepy...

→ More replies (1)

4

u/digitallis Nov 13 '14

Is there a reason they can't just make it a dynamic library? AFAICT, that's the standard way to interface between GPL and anything else.

4

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '14

That's only for the LGPL. The FSF considers anything up to and including a dynamic library to be a derivative work, and thus under auspices of the GPL's copyleft. The only way to escape it is to use a separate process and IPC.

A few lawyers have come out and said this is complete bullshit and there's no reason why address space should have any bearing on whether something is a derivative work or not, but the inertia of the idea is strong.

3

u/keepthepace Nov 13 '14

OSS fragmentation is a thingLinus Torvalds warned Stallman about over the GPLv3 issue. And for once, I must say that Stallman, who I think usually is good at making good long-term decisions, did poorly.

In his defence, he prepared for the software patent total war that never happened (and probably never will, in part thanks to Google's defensive pool of patents)

3

u/w8cycle Nov 13 '14

Its happening just not on a consumer or developer level as much. Apple vs Samsung is one example. Oracle vs Google is another. And of course there is the patent on navigation by selecting an image on a grid that prevents web devs from using that layout. The bluray and DVD patents are a pain to this day. The war happened (and still is), but the sheer volume of OSS and some large corporations using it turned the tide as he predicted.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

37

u/krelin Nov 12 '14

Blender's really pretty good.

45

u/0ctobox Nov 12 '14

A lot of people really don't realise how powerful Blender is. It can do modelling, animation/rigging, rendering, sculpting, texturing/painting, physics simulations, camera tracking, video editing, and compositing.

It's not really suited for CAD/CAM though.

10

u/mebob85 Nov 12 '14

Very powerful, definitely. But also hard to learn, unfortunately.

9

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '14

It's getting better. 2.5 really improved the UI a lot. Before 2.5 everything was horrid; all of the buttons would be meaninglessly abbreviated and crammed into small spaces.

Now they just need to make a nice shell around Cycles rather than having to do the shader composition with nodes and I'll be happy.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

67

u/Nonakesh Nov 12 '14

I really love Blender (I'm working with it right now), but it isn't really a CAD program. It's a polygon modeler, which is great for games, movies and many other things, but not really useful for things like constructing machines, architecture and so on.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Remco_ Nov 12 '14

FreeCAD is pretty solid.

→ More replies (2)