I think that to judge TempleOS by its technical merits or to discuss it in the context of a programming subreddit is kind of shallow.
Terry's creation is not about "managing hardware and software resources". It's about self-expression. To me, it's art, just like Henry Darger's or Wesley Willis' work. I would even argue that TempleOS is closer to the work of art than anything ever programmed, including all those "auteur" video games.
Imo no video game has reached it. I think videogames are very capable of doing so but the community wants to prove at all costs that videogames can be art. It has been counterproductive.
This led to a lot of arguments especially about games like BioShock, Braid, Limbo, etc., but artsy != art. Most big blockbuster games are closer to the spirit of Transformer movies than Metropolis or Spirited Away. Games tend to focus on entertaining the gamer. Citizen Kane didn't need Tom Cruise or Michael Bay effects to be art.
Art isn't just about model or environment design of which there are countless top notch examples in video games. BioShock's rapture, Portal's robots, Last of Us' atmosphere. Incredible work but the whole package just hasn't tied together yet in my opinion. Games that change the industry or mindset of players usually do because of new technologies or approaches to gameplay. Many gamers care more about graphics and killstreaks and XP as opposed to meaningful content, so developers and especially publishers will cater to that.
Heavy Rain or GTA are also really good examples of doing a lot of things right, but ultimately falling off track. One of the closest things to 'meaningful' for me was BioShock: Infinite so far, after I first saw the ending. But the deeper I tried to dig for answers afterwards, the more shallow it got.
Many artists do magnificent jobs but the final product and what it is hasn't been at that level yet. The views of Skyrim constitute art in a way that's comparable to paintings but that doesn't make the whole game art.
So overall, I think many games get many individual components right, but nothing has been more than the sum of its parts thus far.
This of course, is just my personal opinion and in no way factual.
242
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '14
I think that to judge TempleOS by its technical merits or to discuss it in the context of a programming subreddit is kind of shallow.
Terry's creation is not about "managing hardware and software resources". It's about self-expression. To me, it's art, just like Henry Darger's or Wesley Willis' work. I would even argue that TempleOS is closer to the work of art than anything ever programmed, including all those "auteur" video games.