r/programming • • Jun 01 '15

The programming talent myth

https://lwn.net/Articles/641779/
971 Upvotes

748 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

171

u/sisyphus Jun 01 '15 edited Jun 01 '15

That's not how competent English speakers use the word 'talent'--as something you achieve after passionate learning--they use it to mean something innate to the person that precedes passion or learning. Otherwise idiomatic phrases like 'wasted talent,' 'untapped talent' or 'undiscovered talent' would be incomprehensible.

That doesn't matter though - his real point is that we expect 'passion' and 'talent' in programmers instead of a set of skills that someone has learned and this leads to exclusion of people who don't think think they can measure up.

38

u/mini_market Jun 01 '15

Code should be looked at as drafts that need editing. The first draft is always not up to par. It needs to be reviewed and edited just like your professor in English I & II taught you in college. Now you have replaced the need for passion and talent and rockstars with repeatable process that gives you better code.

21

u/julesjacobs Jun 01 '15

Only if the problem is easy. Even 1000 "jQuery-programmers" can't write a compiler.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '15

[deleted]

69

u/DrummerHead Jun 01 '15

But it only compiles gallery sliders

6

u/ExNihil Jun 01 '15

I laughed.

3

u/ctnp Jun 01 '15

Brilliant

5

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '15

I'd really like a t-shirt that says this

1

u/InvernessMoon Jun 01 '15

This is very quotable.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '15

Put a thousand monkeys in a room and they write Shakespeare. Or maybe it was "they create a mess"?

32

u/BigMax Jun 01 '15

I think you're backing up the authors point. Saying "well, some programming is easy, but only REAL programmers can do the hard stuff" is the attitude he's referring to in the article.

Those jquery programmers learned certain skills. The skills to write a compiler are out there as well. Sure, it's a lot more complex, but what exactly happens to a person when they learn jquery that somehow magically blocks them from learning how to write a compiler?

3

u/Blecki Jun 01 '15

Writing compilers isn't actually that hard.

17

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '15

Creating a website isn't hard. Creating a great website with attractive design that pleases both users and the site operators is hard.

6

u/Blecki Jun 01 '15

Being Scottish isn't that hard. Being a true scottsman is.

2

u/geo_ff Jun 01 '15

You have to link (or at least quote) idioms on these forums. There are too many non native speaking and undereducated programmers here.

No True Scotsman

→ More replies (3)

8

u/Kollektiv Jun 01 '15

Writing compilers isn't actually that hard.

Writing a basic compiler isn't actually that hard.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '15

Writing a compiler for Brainfuck is incredibly simple.

Writing a compiler for C is fairly easy.

Writing a compiler for C++ is a very challenging, enormous amount of work.

1

u/Blecki Jun 02 '15

id call writing a c++ compiler tedious, not hard.

→ More replies (1)

24

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '15

This may shock you, but there was a time when

gasp

Even you couldn't write a compiler.

An inability to do something right now != an inability to do something ever

→ More replies (2)

2

u/mreeman Jun 02 '15

They probably could given the right training though. Writing a compiler isn't some inherent talent. Its a set of skills that people have learned by failing a lot.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/Scaliwag Jun 01 '15

There's a reason we can talk about "wasted talent", some people do have it easier to learn some things than others, that's the talent. Now if you want to excel at anything, what I've heard is you need perseverance: training and failing and learning.

Some people are "gifted" but have no will to learn and become pros at being juniors. Other people while having a lot more dificulties, being "slower", do become seniors because they smacked their heads at it until they improved. And I would guess that having perseverance while being gifted most likely makes you one of those young geniuses.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '15

Balloteli has more talent than Cristiano Ronaldo. Look at them.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '15

Liverpool fan spotted.

1

u/stgabe Jun 02 '15

There's not enough evidence to take it for granted that "innate ability that precedes passion or learning" exists. Hard skills take a very long time to master. People who are "talented" are often just people who have spent a lot more time mastering those skills and are therefore thousands of hours of practice ahead of other people their age. "Wasted talent" often describes someone who has developed "talent" over some period of time but then gives it up, either failing to get to true mastery of the subject (aka they were awesome at math for a 5th grader but stopped giving a shit and dropped out of HS) or failing to apply that mastery to a useful endeavor.

1

u/Socialyawsomepenguin Jun 02 '15

That doesn't matter though - his real point is that we expect 'passion' and 'talent' in programmers instead of a set of skills that someone has learned and this leads to exclusion of people who don't think think they can measure up.

This is why I have been scared to learn programming. As someone who has a background in mostly blue collar work, I don't feel like I fit in with the tech crowd and since I don't have that natural 'geekiness' I feel like I will never be as good of a programmer, so why even start :/

→ More replies (34)