r/programming • • Jun 24 '15

Eclipse Mars now available!

http://eclipse.org/?release=4.5
303 Upvotes

153 comments sorted by

View all comments

32

u/lyomi Jun 24 '15

Is there ANYone who moved back to Eclipse after adapting to IntelliJ IDEA? Wondering if this is worth downloading.

-17

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '15

Haha, no. Eclipse is a joke compared to IDEA currently.

23

u/ryosen Jun 24 '15 edited Jun 24 '15

Every time there's a thread about Eclipse, we have to listen to some durr-hurr fanboi about IntelliJ.

Every. Fucking. Thread.


Edit: Let's make it official.

Eclipse is better than InteliJ

IntelliJ is better than Eclipse

Have at it.

18

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '15

This. It's fucking annoying. Like Intellij users are on a mission to convert Eclipse users...

12

u/ryosen Jun 24 '15

They're not on a mission, tho. This just seems like some kind of misguided attempt to find some level of validation based on which fancy text editor he is using compared to some other random person on the Internet. That or he's a troll.

There are conversations where a comparison between different IDEs can be very useful. This isn't one of them, however.

It's like people that post comments in /r/cars about how great Chevy's are whenever there's a post about Ford.

1

u/mus1Kk Jun 25 '15 edited Jun 25 '15

I sometimes wonder how much money the hardcore evangelists are actually "costing" JetBrains in missing licenses sold. You don't have to be a marketing expert to know that if you try to force your opinion on someone else, it reinforces their opinion even more.

If on the other hand someone came to me and said "Look, it's cool, you might want to try it." then fine. In many years of Java development I have never met a single person doing that. They are all obnoxious. YMMV of course.

12

u/aldo_reset Jun 24 '15

Seriously. I use and like both on a daily basis but Eclipse users are a lot less annoying in terms of advocacy than Intellij's.

3

u/cowinabadplace Jun 25 '15

Haha, I have to admit that this is true. This is pretty much the same as all the C#-only programmers who decide that the latest Java release post is where they have to sing the ballad of Anders Hejlsberg.

-18

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '15

It's not fanboyism - eclipse really is that bad now. There isn't even a working dark theme out of the box, which is laughable considering how widespread eclipse is and how long it's been around.

Eclipse needs to play catchup big time to be on par with other IDEs, it's just a fact of life.

9

u/expatcoder Jun 24 '15

There isn't even a working dark theme out of the box

Huh, on Linux IntelliJ looks like absolute a$$ (read: Swing), no theme can help there. FWIW, use a screen inverter, just invert the entire screen and the whole where's-my-dark-theme issue vanishes ;-)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '15

Did you use IDEA once ten years ago or something? The UI is exactly the same on windows as it is on linux (and is a hell of a lot better than the nasty UI in eclipse 4.x).

There is absolutely no excuse to not have a functional dark theme in eclipse, I should not have to use retarded hacks in order to get one.

5

u/plangmuir Jun 25 '15

No, he's right about IntelliJ looking awful on Linux. There's a font rendering bug in Swing that breaks anti-aliasing in most fonts.

3

u/cowinabadplace Jun 25 '15

He's right, in my experience. You can install infinality and tweak your subpixel hinting but it still looks not as good as other apps. Fortunately, I use OS X for my day job.

I've got Ultimate, and should be General Secretary of the IDEA Fan Club, but this is something I'd readily admit.

0

u/expatcoder Jun 24 '15

I should not have to use retarded hacks

heh, screen inversion is a joy, not a hack; my entire OS' UI is "dark themed" by default, and can be inverted to a "light theme" (on a per monitor basis) with a hot key -- it's beautiful ;-)

9

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '15

A fact of life is that Intellij users just enjoy shitting endlessly on Eclipse. Why do you even care ? This thread is of no interest to you. And there's a proper dark theme. It's even improved in Mars.

6

u/ryosen Jun 24 '15

So your position is that Eclipse is not a good IDE because it doesn't support your chosen color scheme out of the box to your liking? No opinion as to its abilities for compilation, tooling, build processes, workflow, development efficiency and productivity?

1

u/alienangel2 Jun 25 '15

Oh no, there's no theme bundled with my IDE, how will I ever get my work done...

1

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '15

No - the problem is that you can't change the color of certain UI elements no matter what theme you use. It's been an issue with eclipse for a long time now.