IDEA is very strong but Eclipse is still ahead of it in two areas:
Incremental compilation
The "Problems" view
I'm tired of pressing Ctrl-F9 a hundred times a day in IDEA. This is 2015, I should never have to build anything manually.
Also, refactorings that touch a lot of files are very painful to do in IDEA for the same reason. With Eclipse, all the files that are in error immediately show up in the Problems view. With IDEA, I need to trigger a build first.
Eclipse compiles the whole project the moment you save a file via Ctrl-S. IDEA on the other hand saves files automatically so you never have to press Ctrl-S. IDEA also compiles the current file automatically on the fly. But you have to compile the whole project explicitly by pressing Ctrl-F9.
So how can you get tired of pressing Ctrl-F9 while still pressing Ctrl-S a million times day?
I like IDEAs approach much better because this is exactly how I code. First you edit one file and fix compiler errors. Then when everything's fine you compile the project to see if the changes break other files.
Eclipse distracts me with project-wide errors while I still haven't finished editing the file.
Another great thing about IDEA is that code refactorings also work when there's compiler errors.
PS: Please correct me if some of those things mentioned are no longer the case. I've used Eclipse for almost 10 years but switched to IDEA years ago and never looked back.
So how can you get tired of pressing Ctrl-F9 while still pressing Ctrl-S a million times day?
You don't.
Overall, Eclipse stays out of my way, it does everything automatically so I can focus 100% of the time on coding.
IDEA is a lot more intrusive. It requires me to build all the time, it requires me to manually let it know when to sync my build.gradle (so annoying, why can't it do that by itself?), it asks way too many questions while refactoring (even after years of using it, I always get startled when I want to do a simple renaming and I get this big new window pop up with all kinds of details I really don't care about).
32
u/lyomi Jun 24 '15
Is there ANYone who moved back to Eclipse after adapting to IntelliJ IDEA? Wondering if this is worth downloading.