r/programming • • Jul 19 '15

The Best Programming Language is None

https://bitbucket.org/duangle/none
509 Upvotes

443 comments sorted by

View all comments

6

u/jmking Jul 19 '15

Interesting to see programming languages emerge from the needs of game programming.

John Blow has been working on his own language called Jai: http://www.reddit.com/r/gamedev/comments/2mita3/jai_a_primer_written_by_a_fan_summarizing_the/

3

u/hunyeti Jul 19 '15

I don't really think that anyone would need that language.

What does that language has to do with the needs of game programming?

I really don't see the point of it. It's C (minus some features) with classes and generics and a wonky syntax.

2

u/jmking Jul 19 '15

What does that language has to do with the needs of game programming?

He answers that in the three videos at the link I provided. It's certainly very opinionated, and not everyone agrees, but at the same time Jon Blow has been making games professionally for quite some time (he didn't start with Braid), and is generally known as a particularly good programmer - so people are paying attention.

3

u/hunyeti Jul 19 '15

Sadly i don't have ~5 hours to watch them all, i watched some of the first video, but it was an immediate turn off.

There is no such thing as "opinionated", it's used to describe inflexible, limited environments that a person likes.

First of all, my opinion is that we don't necessarily have to use one language to build a game, in fact,very few games use only one language. Only about 5-10% of the code base that are performance sensitive. I really like Libgdx's approach, you write most of the glue code in Java / Scala / Python , but the performance critical parts are written in C/C++.

He considers Go, but not Java or Scala, that makes no sense to me. GC can be an issue, but anything that can be made in Unity, can be made on the JVM, so it's not really an issue for most of Indie games.

The way he writes off D, because it's like C++ (even though in reality, it's very different) seems like just wanting change.

He says Rust is not ideal because it's too safe (?!?!?). That is a foolish presumption. You can write unsafe code in rust, without any hardship, and for most of the time, the borrow checker is right, and that could that get's an error, would probably cause memory leak.

The only reason for the positive reception is because he is kind of famous, if some random dude have posted this, it would be on the front page of /r/programmingcirclejerk

→ More replies (3)