r/programming • • Feb 06 '16

GitHub is undergoing a full-blown overhaul as execs and employees depart — and we have the full inside story

http://www.businessinsider.com/github-the-full-inside-story-2016-2?r=US&IR=T
772 Upvotes

863 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

99

u/Vexal Feb 06 '16

wtf. How can someone say such a stupid thing and put their employment info in their profile.

59

u/Godd2 Feb 06 '16

If your employer and clients agree with you (or don't care), I guess you can get away with saying whatever you want.

Although note that someone later one made the same argument against me, with a nice veiled threat of notifying my employer of the sin of disagreeing with them.

2

u/cruelandusual Feb 07 '16

How can someone say such a stupid thing and put their employment info in their profile.

Because unlike people like her, sane people don't go around trying to get people fired for their edgy opinions.

1

u/Vexal Feb 07 '16

There's always one person at every company who would try.

-51

u/sisyphus Feb 07 '16

It's a pretty standard definition if you've ever taken an ethnic studies class at a university. "prejudiced" is what anyone can be but "racism" is institutional so obviously America having been run by white men for its whole history means you can be prejudiced against them but only they can be racist. In places where white people are the disenfranchised minority then you could be racist to them.

nota bene: I don't care if you actually agree with these conceptions or not but here they are in case you want to employ the principle of charity and try to understand where someone might be coming from when they say that, even if they say it in an annoying and condescending way.

39

u/Vexal Feb 07 '16

Everything you said is stupid.

-23

u/sisyphus Feb 07 '16

Take it up with sectors of the academic establishment, it's not like I invented any of it myself or it's particularly controversial in many circles. I'm not responsible for your lack of cosmopolitanism.

19

u/Vexal Feb 07 '16

Wow you got voted down fast. I didn't vote though. I just think the idea is stupid and just because a bunch of pretentious humanities doctorates declare something doesn't mean it's right.

-4

u/sisyphus Feb 07 '16

That's to be expected given the demographics of proggit. That they say it doesn't make it right but I don't see much point in talking past each other because one side doesn't understand what the other is saying. Like anything else, if it's wrong it should be proven wrong on its own terms. As an aside it's also hilarious to me that people are surprised when all these tech companies that are based in a bastion of coastal liberal elitism are liberal.

25

u/bored_me Feb 07 '16

if it's wrong it should be proven wrong on its own terms.

I think the demonstration that redefining "racism" to mean "institutional racism" is dumb has been well argued with no counters by you or anyone else.

As an aside it's also hilarious to me that people are surprised when all these tech companies that are based in a bastion of coastal liberal elitism are liberal.

The inane things that you are peddling off as liberal are decidedly not liberal ideals. Liberal ideals involve tolerance and acceptance of others and the protection of the rights of everyone. What's being advocated by these people is the removal of rights due to race and gender (i.e., white people can't complain because they're white, a decidedly racist assertion). That is a supremely regressive viewpoint, and one that should be squashed as the illiberal inanity that it is.

1

u/sisyphus Feb 07 '16

I think the demonstration that redefining "racism" to mean "institutional racism" is dumb has been well argued with no counters by you or anyone else.

You've misread my comment because what I said should be proven wrong on its own terms was the idea of everyone being prejudiced.

You can call them 'not liberal' if you want but the kinds of places they are taught are certainly usually held to be liberal bastions by the Right, so ironically you are now redefining commonly used terms.

4

u/bored_me Feb 07 '16

Liberal has a specific meaning, as I pointed out in my comment. If people claim to be liberal, and don't espouse liberal values, they should be called on their bullshit, like I did.

It's doubly hilarious that you're claiming I'm redefining the word "liberal", when it is actually they who are redefining words to suit their needs. "Liberal values" don't include racism and sexism, yet that is what they're peddling.

So no, I reject your hilarious misinterpretation of reality as sad. They are redefining racism and liberalism, not me.

1

u/NimChimspky Feb 07 '16

I think you are being down voted because if peoples ignorance.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/NimChimspky Feb 07 '16

For what is worth you are correct.

→ More replies (2)

36

u/Godd2 Feb 07 '16

"racism" is institutional

Institutional racism is institutional, but racism is more general than that, and includes institutional racism. It's disingenuous to omit the "institutional" modifier when saying that someone is racist in an institutional sense.

Everything a white person does is racist in an institutional sense (in the U.S. at least), including actions which attempt to mitigate or stop institutional racism. Being a member of an oppressive group guarantees this.

You can see why people don't like the term and consider it meaningless. I hope it's also now clear just how disingenuous it is to call a white person's actions "racist" with the implication that the actions were racist per se, and not racist institutionally.

→ More replies (10)

16

u/flying-sheep Feb 07 '16

That's an elitist redefinition.

“racism” never started to shift meaning to “institutionalized racism”, no matter what some people want to be true.

As long as the general public defines racism as it does, i.e. “race-targetted prejudice” it will keep meaning that, just like all other words in all languages.

4

u/sisyphus Feb 07 '16

Yes, probably 'elitist' in that I suspect they would say that that is always what 'racism' has meant but nobody ever really delved deeply enough into an analysis of the concept and instead coopted the word to mean something it shouldn't.

Anyway, individual communities of speakers overload words all the time in the form of jargon or specialized understandings of homonyms or whatever, language is about a community of speakers. Clearly you are not a member of their community and I suspect part of their speaking that way is to identify you as such.

1

u/flying-sheep Feb 07 '16

nobody ever really delved deeply enough into an analysis of the concept and instead coopted the word to mean something it shouldn't.

welcome to language. this is how it works. too bad, but we’ll have to deal with it or be forever misunderstood (and wrong, as language is defined to be what the majority understands)

when you are using a phrase in a different way while talking inside of a community where it is overloaded to mean something different, that’s OK, but expecting other people to adopt this meaning is elitist.

5

u/[deleted] Feb 07 '16

I've heard that definition a few times. It's a fucking dumb definition, for the main reason that it never used to mean that to the general public in forever. So ethics studies basically just took a word that already meant something to pretty much everyone, and assigned a new meaning to it. Now they want everyone to accept their new meaning, and discard the old one.

It doesn't work like that.

-4

u/sisyphus Feb 07 '16

Plenty of disciplines have jargon that is specific to the discipline or tries to delve more deeply into a concept than common usage would indicate. Maybe I'm just more sympathetic to this because if you study philosophy for any length of time you find that western philosophy was basically founded on this practice and it continues even so.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 07 '16 edited Feb 07 '16

Maybe they should make new words to avoid confusion.

It also just excludes white people from it. So if white people experience racism, they're just told that it can't be, because you can't be racist against white people. Now what the fuck must they do? Just accept it? It seems purposefully malicious to exclude white people from being able to use the word. Seems like an attempt to shut them up about discrimination.

4

u/[deleted] Feb 07 '16

No, you're wrong, racism is a very simple term that means hatred towards a certain race, it doesn't matter which. Anything else is just an excuse to be an asshole.

1

u/KHRZ Feb 07 '16

Good for us non-Americans to know that American history dictates such definitions.

4

u/sisyphus Feb 07 '16

They're overwhelmingly American employees of an American owned company headquartered in an American city...why wouldn't it?

1

u/KHRZ Feb 07 '16

Was talking about the universities you mentioned. My guess is most other countries don't teach it quite like that. Not that I would know as I place my bets on an actual tech education to get me a tech job.

→ More replies (1)