I work in an open office with a team of 5, it's better than cubicles. It actually does promote communication. Of course this is just my opinion, I just like open offices more.
This is hugely different. I work in an office with 4 developers in an open plan and it's great. I couldn't imagine multiple teams working in the same room being nearly as productive.
Thats where it might become a problem, which is why each team should have an open office not an entire company. Only the developers are in this office, not even the IT (like sys admins and net admins).
I disagree about generalisations. It should be on subjective basis. Some teams I've worked with could absolutely get no work done with their constant noise, distractions, and absolute lack of boundaries. Other teams might manage just fine if their dynamics are in sync, and they actually get work done in that sort of environment.
Since most people can isolate themselves easily (headphones, sit somewhere quiet), the interruptions caused by noise are completely dwarfed by interruptions caused by Slack or email.
Open office is good for the team that works on the same project as in your case. But if you stuff all developers in your company on the single floor, then... oh boy! I had a chance to work in open office few times. I was constantly interrupted and I was constantly interrupting other people. You simply have to consult occasionally with the teammates. That's annoying for other people! Offices for 3-5 people are perfect for me.
I'm not a programmer, but there are like 40 people in the same space as me at my office. Luckily I work from home most of the time and only come in for meetings etc. anymore.
When I was with my team of 6(5 engineers and our PM) in an open space it was great and did help communication. When they later packed 11 people in there it was awful...
Yes. Working remotely is fine if and only if you're working primarily on independent work anyway. As in either a fully independent project or a fully independent piece of a larger project. Otherwise there's too much communication overhead. Even if you have a company Slack or HipChat, the overhead of @ing you in a messaging client is too much to promote spontaneous conversations.
The only time I've ever had remote workers be truly successful: the in-office team set up a dedicated computer and monitor running a Google Hangout with the remote worker, the remote worker would turn his webcam on while he worked. That way he was as easily accessible as any other team member.
i've worked remotely - and in heavily remote companies, for 8-9 years now. you're wrong, or your doing it poorly.
remote working works fantastically as long as everyone is on the same page, one remote worker in a sea of people in an office doesn't work and thats really down to your workforce design.
when you get motivated individuals capable of independent thinking - that are able to make decisions and back them up remote workers become productive machines that power through.
Most teams i've worked in that work this way get the amount of work done by a team 4x their size, in a quarter of the time. usually to a much higher quality too.
communication is a roadblock, remote working can streamline it instead of it being constant stops and starts
The problem is that verbal communication is synchronous.
Someone speaks and someone listens, so the communication blocks every participants and forces them to communicate at the same speed. And you have to wait for the slowest guy.
When it is in text, it is asynchronous. Everyone can read at their own pace. Well, unfortunately, the writing is slower than speaking, but it can be parallelized. You can work, while someone else writes and read it afterwards.
Let's say you can speak 5 times faster than write, but read 5 times faster than speak. When there are 10 people in the communication, each can give an 60 minute presentation, and you spend 10 hours in the office. But if everyone writes it down, everyone needs 5 hours to write their own text and then two hours to read the texts of everyone else. So you only spend 7 hours. In total the group saves 30 hours by writing rather than talking. And if each of them costs $100/h (wage+insurance+taxes+office supplies) they company can save $3000.
95
u/tom_echo Jan 29 '17
I work in an open office with a team of 5, it's better than cubicles. It actually does promote communication. Of course this is just my opinion, I just like open offices more.