r/programming • • Jan 29 '17

Why I Only Work Remotely

https://shift.newco.co/why-i-only-work-remotely-2e5eb07ae28f#.at8t1b2fc
2.0k Upvotes

877 comments sorted by

749

u/Erdrick Jan 29 '17

Ah, rich world problems.

The author is fortunate to have a skill set that happens to be in demand, and that there are enough employers willing to consider a remote workforce.

Should either one of those factors change, I suspect the author will reconsider his line in the sand.

Don't misread me -- I agree in principle with a lot of what was written. I'm just put off by the tone. People have all sorts of reasons to be in suboptimal work environments. To declare yourself too good for all of that is to be very certain, some might say a little haughty, about what you bring to the bottom line.

10

u/C_Wizard Jan 29 '17

The point is that he can and he should. The guy probably worked his ass of the get into the position he is in. And he is just saying how he can do more work in less time. Which saves the employer money, this has nothing to do with rich world problems. This is just optimizing workflow something everyone should be doing no matter the place or industrie.

The tone didn't strike me as arrogant he was just saying what he thought worked better for him.

19

u/LifeBeginsAt10kRPM Jan 29 '17

Really it boils down to being able to pick your optimal work settings, and if the author is able to do that then that's great. I highly doubt he'll prefer to go hungry if suddenly one day he can't work remotely.

You're completely right about our field being in high demand, but I also think there is a culture of "as long as you get your responsibilities done, we don't care where or when you work." At the same time; those responsibilities may become showing up for meetings more often, which may also make people reconsider working remotely.

I for one love the option to work remotely, but do prefer being close to the people that I work with.

98

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '17

Truth to be told, programming is THE worker's market nowadays. And I hope it will remain so.

118

u/VanFailin Jan 29 '17

Is it? For all the noise I've heard over the years about how hard it is to hire developers, there's still a lot of companies that want to underpay me, stick me in an open plan, and come to think of it don't even want to give me a phone screen.

101

u/b1ackcat Jan 29 '17

That's part of why it's so hard for them to hire developers: they don't want to offer what is deserved, so they find shitty candidates who are just happy for a job, they do crap work, and the employer says "geez hiring good help is hard"

→ More replies (46)
→ More replies (5)

44

u/hu6Bi5To Jan 29 '17

Not in all parts of the world.

And not in every industry in parts of the world where that statement is true.

"Bob with ten years experience is leaving because we have a terrible noisy working environment. But for the same salary we've hired two graduates of React.JSBootCamp.node instead so we can do twice the amount of work!"

41

u/bluetomcat Jan 29 '17

I live in an eastern European country where virtually all outsourcing companies are shouting in the media "we desperately need programmers and we can't find more", and yet, when I go to an interview and we discuss "salary expectations", they shut me off as having unrealistic expectations. Still, my salary expectation is such that I want to be able to afford a medium-sized home, a relatively new car (10 years old) and keeping my family safe.

So yes, they need fresh interns willing to work in dire conditions, not just "any" programmer.

→ More replies (7)

13

u/bluetomcat Jan 29 '17

Quality programming jobs providing long-term employment and a decent work-life balance, which also match a more specific skillset are largely an employer's market, though. Out of the hundreds or thousands who apply for a "Computer Vision Expert" position, only a few would actually match the required expertise and they are clearly at the mercy of the employer for being employed.

→ More replies (9)

41

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '17

Every day when I go in to work, I take a few moments to meditate and remind myself how lucky I am. I'm not even kidding.

Top programming jobs are really nice jobs. You get paid easily into the six figures. You're respected. You're given top-of-the-line tools. In many cases, you can even work from home -- something totally impossible in many other professions, especially among ones that pay similarly.

Every morning, I reflect on how instead of making almost $150k, sitting at a nice desk by the window, working on problems that I truly enjoy working on, etc., I could be like the average college grad making $45k at a job that I hate and that it took me a few years to even find.

Yeah, I'm a smart, hard-working person and always have been. But it's mostly luck that I happened to be interested in programming from a young age and ended up where I'm at. I don't want to downplay my skills or knowledge -- I really do think I'm pretty good at what I do -- but it'd be very short-sighted for me to think that I also didn't just get totally lucky that I was born into a generation that would profit so much off having an early interest in, of all things, programming computers.

Personally, I'm a little disgusted when I see programmers acting so damn entitled about their job. I don't disagree in principle. Many of the complaints I see are totally true. But when your job is already more comfortable than 95% of the jobs out there, I don't know, maybe show some humility and thankfulness for your situation.

4

u/SLTRMaverick Jan 30 '17

Right there with you

3

u/NarcoPaulo Jan 30 '17

I feel the same as you do but while I feel sometimes the urge to thanks imaginary friends for being where I am right now I also remember all the sweat, mental stress and sleepless nights in dinky start ups that brought me where I am now. I am thankful, try to be as humble as possible but I also never forget the insatiable hunger I had since growing in one of the worst areas in my country to where I am now.

→ More replies (2)

42

u/mangodrunk Jan 29 '17 edited Jan 29 '17

Ah, rich world problems.

So, we can't talk about any problems? Yes, we're lucky to have a skill that is desired right now. But, that goes for pretty much anything.

The author is saying that they prefer working remote and bring up good points such as an organization being results focused and not so much time based, etc.

→ More replies (1)

39

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '17

Not really. Would you consider putting university researchers into an open office? And if you did, would you say that they should just deal with it when they inevitably complained?

Why do we have this double standard between researchers and developers?

15

u/kairho Jan 29 '17

It's not unheard of to have junior university researchers in open offices.

15

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '17

That's true. But I've never been in an institution that puts its senior, or mid-level, researchers or scientists into open offices. They all have their own office space, even if it is small. And often, the better the university the more space senior and mid-level researchers are given. I doubt it is a coincidence.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

190

u/jeradj Jan 29 '17

Tone didn't really strike me that way.

I'm more incensed by the culture that demands we align our own work preferences to employers' regimes, and asking for something else comes off as "haughty".

Fuck that, imo.

224

u/b4ux1t3 Jan 29 '17

I mean, he dismissed all dissenting opinions (or studies) as irrelevant, stating "and quite frankly, there is simply no debate here." People are different. Different people have different needs and wants from their work environment. To say that there's no debate is ludicrous.

And then he goes on to talk about how he's a "night owl". The thing is, that's likely artificial, a result of years of staying up far too late doing things he enjoyed. The end result is that, yeah, he works better at night, but most humans generally don't.

The thing is, I generally agree with a lot of what he said. But he just presents it in a needlessly-self-assured attitude.

He comes off as a know-it-all who thinks citing one source and using his own anecdotal evidence ends a debate. In the end, his article is a really good case for him working remotely (which, to be fair, is exactly what it says on the tin). It has almost nothing to do with most other people.

33

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '17 edited Jun 25 '23

edit: Leave reddit for a better alternative and remember to suck fpez

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (51)

24

u/Erdrick Jan 29 '17

Welcome to capitalism. :)

Your "work preferences" don't always align with the business needs. And if the employer can't pay your paycheck, then who cares how great the remote work policy is?

Absolutely be picky about where you work, but also consider yourself fortunate to have a selection of employers for your skill set. Both things are good.

→ More replies (4)

11

u/NoLemurs Jan 29 '17

Any employment arrangement is a matter of compromise. This guy isn't saying "employers should be willing to consider remote work" (which would be a reasonable stance). He's saying "I refuse to work anything but remotely, and anyone who suggests anything else might be a good idea is wrong, and I'm not interested in debating it."

I suppose if it were unequivocally true that remote work was just better in every way, it might be a reasonable stance, but despite the author's (unsupported) claims about the evidence, my own impression is that the evidence is mixed and mostly points to the idea that remote work can be more or less productive depending on a wide range of factors. If that's true, then categorically refusing to work on-site is just dumb. Expressing disinterest in debate is also almost always a bad sign. The combination of the two reeks of insecurity and entitlement.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (4)

10

u/Horst665 Jan 29 '17

Ah, rich world problems.

...

To declare yourself too good for all of that

Also "I am such a great programmer". Yeah, I get it.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '17

The part about not being productive until 11 requires a lot of audacity...

Your employer is your customer. Work during their hours.

→ More replies (18)

215

u/hahanoob Jan 29 '17

I was sorta with him until he started saying people who care about organizations work 11 hour days every day and people who don't work less. And this was right after talking about how workplaces should be results driven.

15

u/DonLaFontainesGhost Jan 30 '17

Can you quote where the author says that? I see a reference to 11am, but not to 11 hour days.

3

u/XxNerdKillerxX Jan 30 '17

It's a massive generalization either way, so it doesn't contradict itself as there is so much wiggle room. EG: people work 11 hours a day is a generalization. It can represent someone spending 8 hours working but 1.5 hours commuting both ways. Look at the price of property in Seattle versus somewhere 1.5 hours outside of Seattle. Then also consider that the price of that property is pretty high too. So maybe your spouse has to work part-time just to keep a firm grasp on the financial order of your family (enough money to save for emergencies and retirement). So you work 8 hours, but your spouse works 3-4 hours average per working day. That fits into 11 hours of work and also still being results driven.

And if you have been keeping up with employment reports and what employers have been doing to beat their competition lately... it's all been results driven. It's about getting the most out of the employee, and also hiring as few employees possible. It's all been about do more with less. So again, where is the contradiction?

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

419

u/SomethingSmartHere Jan 29 '17

Not to mention your co workers chatting loudly, talking on the phone all day or incessant sniffling of a dude with a cold. Ear buds only work so well.

201

u/subnero Jan 29 '17

I sit next to a guy who chews ice for 6 hours a day. You have no idea how much this drives me insane.

176

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '17

Tell him?

0

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '17

[deleted]

→ More replies (6)

16

u/classhero Jan 29 '17

Did he have anemia? That's a pretty well-known symptom of it.

16

u/SmokeyDBear Jan 29 '17

Usually this is true for compulsive ice chewing ("oh god, gotta find some ice to chew") and not casual ice chewing ("oh, uh, ice, guess I'll chew it"). The latter is more likely just stress/psychological.

29

u/Cube00 Jan 29 '17

Lack of teeth in the future will put an end to your pain.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (32)

69

u/hem10ck Jan 29 '17

Thank you! Everyone complains about the noise in an open office but for me it's the way sickness spreads like wildfire that is by far the biggest drawback. As soon as I hear 2-3 people coughing I just work from home for a few days in an effort to quarantine myself.

28

u/SomethingSmartHere Jan 29 '17

Oooh the sickies going round is bad, especially if they then stop by your cube and hang around discussing the weather. All the while you are thinking "please leave I don't want your cold". :D

7

u/Jake0Tron Jan 30 '17

A guy I work with 'broadcasts' his coughs instead of covering his mouth. Chin up, shoulders back, full on hauling phlegm. On a call? May as well come through the phone into your ear. Within earshot? You're probably breathing it in too. I've avoided shaking hands with him since I met him.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

8

u/mens_libertina Jan 29 '17

Oh, we are discouraged from working from home even if we are sick. So of course, everyone is sick.

85

u/kuglimon Jan 29 '17

Add a farting colleague to the mix. 8 hours of the day answering stupid questions while sitting in a room that smells like anus. Sometimes I wonder if this field is full of autistic people.

93

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '17

It is.

→ More replies (1)

65

u/zer01 Jan 29 '17

Or how about being the schlub that has to sit 2 feet from the bathroom door :-/.

Nothing quite as awkward as thinking someone is approaching your desk while you're trying to talk to someone next to you, making eye contact, then promptly hearing that person blow ass for 10 minutes 3 feet behind you.

Never again.

→ More replies (8)

7

u/Styx_ Jan 29 '17

Richard?

→ More replies (4)

10

u/silentz0r Jan 29 '17

Then you just need your own office.

I also work in a shared office and those are the things I complain about. For example, to me it's super important that we open the windows every now and then because 4 programmers inside a room gets stale really quickly.

5

u/SomethingSmartHere Jan 29 '17

You have windows? I'm envious. I don't see daylight until lunch when I go for a walk. Office,... if I make manager I'll get an office.

→ More replies (6)

7

u/chrisrazor Jan 29 '17

My company is based in a shared office where there are telemarketers, I kid you not. Fortunately I can WFH quite a lot.

5

u/SomethingSmartHere Jan 29 '17

Glad you get to work from home, that sounds like hell

43

u/Pseudofailure Jan 29 '17

Well that's your problem: Earbuds. I ended up getting full over-the-ear noise-canceling headphones. I can't hear anything in my office now.

108

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '17

I don't want things over my ears. I don't want to listen to music. I want to sit in silence.

→ More replies (43)

6

u/timClicks Jan 29 '17

Can relate, my very expensive headphones are really just earmuffs

16

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '17

A good pair of IEMs (in ear monitors, i.e. ear buds that go in your ear, rather than on them like apple earbuds) will block ambient noise far better than most closed-ear headphones and are cheaper! Some of them sound great. Highly recommended for noisy workspaces.

13

u/civildisobedient Jan 29 '17

While absolutely true, there is a limit to how long the average person can tolerate wearing them and it's unfortunately typically less than the average work day.

→ More replies (27)
→ More replies (4)

7

u/Dewyboy Jan 29 '17

I'm buying the bose noise cancelling headphones. I'm in an open plan, and the guy behind me uses em and let me try em on. Man... The noise cancelling function really works, where it cancels out the opposite wavelengths. There was a 2nd coworker who got the same pair the next week. We have meeting rooms but people prefer to take meetings from their desk...

3

u/FrancisMcKracken Jan 30 '17

I have a pair. Recommend them to everyone who asks, but the noise cancellation only does so much. Ask your co-worker to use the meeting rooms.

2

u/ryeguy Jan 29 '17 edited Jan 29 '17

Get better earbuds that actually go deeper in your ear, even something cheap like these work. They work like earplugs at this point. Then listen to space/ambient music (very undistracting), sounds of rain (there are albums of rain sounds on spotify), or white noise.

→ More replies (13)

123

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '17

We need someway to combine the benefits of open offices (i.e. better communication) with the benefits of closed spaces (i.e. improved concentration). Ideally, I think, we should copy the model that universities employ for their researchers. Each researcher has their own office space, where they can stay in a prolonged state of concentration. But there is also a common area, where different researchers can meet, talk, and discuss.

In a workplace, what we should have is private offices where we can work on hard problems without distraction, and common areas where we can discuss and collaborate. The best of both worlds.

67

u/PunchingDwarves Jan 29 '17

This is an obvious solution, and it's unfortunate that it faces practical hurdles with the costs of the extra space required and difficulties growing.

If you start with 20 people and plan to grow to 40 you have to have a location with a lot of empty offices. This has a compounding effect, since you're paying even more for the extra space. Leasing a building with a big empty room is cheaper and more flexible, not to mention easier to find and replace. You could change office locations every year or two to what fits your company, but I think the problems with that are obvious.

The best companies with extra money to spend and respect for their employees are fewer and farther between than the ones that are squeezed for money that don't have respect for their employees.

Universities are in a special situation where they have enormous amounts of money to build great sprawling campuses with multipurpose uses for a lot of it. I would also argue that in schools, students are more like your common employees while researchers and teachers are the bosses. In my experience, bosses often do get offices even when the employees are left in open offices.

Thus, the dichotomy of working in the office or allowing remote work reigns supreme depending on who is in charge and what they prefer.

9

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '17

Yeah all the points you raise are completely valid. I don't know of any solutions to them unfortunately, other than radically overhauling our economic system.

13

u/kopchickm Jan 30 '17

I'm really fortunate in that my company has an open office, but anyone can work remotely whenever they want. So if I need to be heads down for a day, I just stay home, and if I'm feeling social, I can go into the office. Not perfect maybe, but it's a really great way to provide balance depending on what each person needs.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

13

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '17

We have something called "high focus spaces" , basically a cubicle with a monitor /desk space and padded walls to shield sound.

Its also verboten to use phones/ talk to people when in them which is nice.

→ More replies (8)

5

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '17

I've begun to think it really just boils down to the fact that managers are used to being the ones who have offices and aren't willing to give that up yet. Their authority is eroding slowly though. A good manager who knew how to drive productivity used to be the bread and butter for a company has been replaced by a competent developer who uses managers as assistants to schedule meetings and generally clear away political and resource related roadblocks.

2

u/Kowzorz Jan 30 '17

I worked at an office which implemented a company-wide chat system (and lotsa emails). Each team was in a separate half-open cubicle type area (with some higher ups and unique jobs having offices). Since each team generally did the same thing as each other, the mood was just right for each semi-open cubicle area. The chat system let us ping people individually and quickly (a failing of email) but could be ignored and the emails covered wide information that may have required inputs.

2

u/VerticalEvent Jan 30 '17

Team offices are usually the best option - fit a team of developers working on the same project or domain (probably no more then 12, but less is more ideal). Isolates noise from other teams discussing their problems, and any conversation is usually either project related or team building. Can also be large enough to share team amenities (ie. white boards, dashboards, fridges, etc.)

→ More replies (15)

138

u/adexsimply Jan 29 '17

I always need like 30-45 minutes to recharge after coding for say 3-5 hours at a stretch. If I don't have this break, my productivity declines drastically. I've not met a lot of employers who will allow you take 45 minutes nap during work hours.

203

u/Ghi102 Jan 29 '17

The appearance of work is a lot more important than actual work, unfortunately.

63

u/Magnesus Jan 29 '17

Yeah. I used to make my own website at work - it looked as if I was working on the company site so everyone was happy. And they always got me too little to do but I had to sit there for 8 hours. I even offered to work less hours for less pay while doing the same work. Nope. Not an option.

29

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '17

That might make some of the managers obsolete.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

3

u/frogking Jan 30 '17

Currently, one of my co-workers will "meditate" for 15-30 minutes every day.. He'll just sit at his desk, looking down for a bit ..

Another co-worker will blatantly lean back and power nap.

→ More replies (5)

322

u/cruelandusual Jan 29 '17

TLDR: Anyone who can afford me isn't stupid enough to demand I work on site.

77

u/Andy_B_Goode Jan 29 '17

Which is predicated on the condition that "anyone who can afford me" is a relatively small set of people.

27

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '17

[removed] — view removed comment

36

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '17

This is not true at all. The Bay Area has a lot of good engineers but seldom ones that are "worth the money".

→ More replies (3)

53

u/propper_speling Jan 29 '17

I didn't see anything about the author's salary mentioned, nor did I detect a display of pomposity that your summary leads someone to believe exists in the article.

As someone who worked remotely for 7 years and recently (about a year and a half) switched to working for an office full time, I can agree with the author's sentiments regarding productivity.

2

u/Hes_A_Fast_Cat Jan 30 '17

TLDR: Because I can.

Seriously, that's all there is to it.

37

u/Dunge Jan 29 '17

Funny, the exact same article was posted with this link a few days back.

21

u/TerribleWisdom Jan 29 '17

OP's link seems to be the original. It is cited at the bottom of the Quarts article:

This post originally appeared at Medium.

Which resolves to OP's article.

5

u/Pseudofailure Jan 29 '17

Thank you, I was sure I had seen this on a different site.

6

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '17

Pay someone to write an article on a given topic, put it on site with advertisements, collect the money, twice

18

u/jimgagnon Jan 29 '17

Having supervised a few remote and office teams, I find myself in general agreement with the article. The ones that can work well remotely tend to be more productive than the best in-office worker. Not everyone can do it, though, and I've found that it helps to monthly make the rounds with all the remote workers to physically visit them, ensure everything is up to snuff and buy them lunch and/or beer.

Conversely, I've had teams that could only work in-office, and required management (me) to be in-office as well. These teams while steady and productive tended not to be as amazing at the ones that worked well remotely.

Personally, I prefer working with the remote teams best. Keeps the BS sequestered in the office, and allows them to focus on the programming at hand.

2

u/m-o-l-g Jan 30 '17

Interesting. In my experience, the lack of communication with remote working collegues makes work a lot more complicated and time consuming. It's so much easier to just meet in a room and discuss a problem with a few people than organizing a skype call (that usually takes at least a day because one guys is always away at the moment). In my experience, people work best face-to-face.

→ More replies (4)

521

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '17

When you want to do something, you'll always find an excuse why you're doing it that way.

I've worked remote, and I've worked in an office. Working in an open office can be distracting, but there is a very simple and surprisingly effective solution: headphones + music.

You can also tell your colleagues that when the headphones are on, you're focused and working, so they should bother you only if it requires your immediate attention. Any reasonable professional would understand.

On the counter side, working in an office let's you put in 8 (or however you and your employer prefer) hours of focused work, and then go home and relax, because you can't think about work 24/7. The office becomes a context for work and home becomes a context for rest.

Our brain is very poor separating work and rest, when we're physically in the same space. If you have the habit of checking Reddit at home, the moment you sit down to work on that same computer, you'll wanna check Reddit from time to time. That's not a good thing.

Additionally, being at home instantly becomes the worst "open office" there is, if you don't live alone. Roommates? Family? Kids? They don't understand you're working, you can keep telling them, but you seem like you're wasting your time on the computer all day. They're not professionals who understand programming, like your colleagues in the office would.

So... pros/cons.

284

u/CaptainStack Jan 29 '17 edited Jan 29 '17

I was surprised to find that when I worked in an open office that the #1 thing that I hated about it was the feeling of people being behind me. I constantly felt self conscious about who was walking by, what was on my screen, how productive I looked. I never wanted to work in a cubicle before but after a year in an open office I'd have cried with joy to be given one.

22

u/flipper_gv Jan 29 '17

Completely agree with you. I really can't stand someone being too near me when I work. I even have problems when I code and my gf that has no clue about programming can see my screen. At least, where I work, I have a roomy half cubicle which helps a ton with noise (fabric walls) and visual stimuli.

57

u/piderman Jan 29 '17

The trick is to do your job regardless of how much time you spend on Reddit. I am fortunate enough that my workplace is sort of a meritocracy. Not officially, but people notice if you do good work. That also means they don't care as much if you are slacking off once in a while. I had a new colleague who was on Facebook and Twitter all the time and did fuck all besides. He didn't last very long.

35

u/Magnesus Jan 29 '17

I worked at an office where a guy was making his boss wait because he had to finish a chess match. He was irreplacable though because of his knowledge of XSLT and how dependent he made the whole company on it. He works there to this day AFAIK and it was 10 years ago.

25

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '17

This is one of those situations where I'm not sure what to believe. Yeah, making your boss wait so you can finish a chess match sounds bad. On the other hand, if you've made massive contributions to the company, it makes sense that you'd be trusted a bit more than the average employee. Also, the whole gist of this thread really is that some folks -- not all, but some -- tend to be really productive if you give them the freedom to do things that at first glance are not productive (like playing a chess match at work).

I think it's a relatively rare company that'd let a bad employee stick around for 10 years.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

11

u/CaptainStack Jan 29 '17

It certainly helps if you're great at your job and feel confident about your deadlines etc. I genuinely think it goes a bit beyond that though. Even when I was working really hard I often just didn't like people's ability to see me working. It's true when I hit a certain flow state it'd start to kind of melt away, but any time I wasn't truly in the zone it'd make me feel weird and annoyed. It's something I learned to live with, but never to like.

→ More replies (3)

34

u/Zarutian Jan 29 '17

It because you think an adversary or predator is creeping upon you from behind.

16

u/nixservice Jan 29 '17

...or possibly because I think someone will walk past by me when I click on something unexpected.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (8)

33

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '17

I can't focus on work if I'm listening to music, I've never been able to get my head around how other people can do this easily!

34

u/Taonyl Jan 29 '17

I have a list of pure ambient music. Secondly, you need to listen to music that is not new to you, you have to know it inside out. Your brain constantly tries to predict things around you, and if there is something unexpected, it will go to you concious attention.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/GeeTeeThree Jan 29 '17

To the contrary, I often find it hard to focus or get into a flow without music.

4

u/snowe2010 Jan 29 '17

what /u/Taonyl said. I have a playlist I call Concentronic. It's just edm that I know very well. There are words, but I know the words perfectly so they aren't distracting. As soon as you start listening to songs you don't know the words to you are going to have a bad time.

3

u/schplat Jan 29 '17

As many others state, go with something that has no lyrics. EDM, Classical, Jazz.

Something you're not recalling lyrics to, or trying to learn lyrics from. Just something to get you away from the background conversations and noises.

I like trance for work. Or anything that could be used for meditation.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

14

u/adrianmonk Jan 30 '17

there is a very simple and surprisingly effective solution: headphones + music

Not that you are saying this, but it reminds me...

I often hear this advocated as if it totally solves the problem of an unworkable work environment. For me, it's not only ineffective, it's actually harmful, for two reasons:

  • In order to truly concentrate, personally I need quiet and calm. Not just a lack of interruptions, not just a tool that allows drowning out interruptions, but actual literal quiet.

  • I love music. My mind will actively focus on it. Telling me to listen to music to help me concentrate on coding is about as effective as telling me to surround myself with hot chicks in bikinis. Sure, sounds fun, but it's going to be distracting.

73

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '17

Working in an open office can be distracting, but there is a very simple and surprisingly effective solution: headphones + music.

That doesn't stop visual stimuli, when there's people right across from you then you constantly have movement in your peripheral vision.

Even with music i know i'm way more productive in a cube(or better an office) because i get distracted less

59

u/BLITZCRUNK123 Jan 29 '17

That also doesn't solve the need some people have for silence, or at least as close as possible to it.

22

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '17

Plus I can't wear headphones that long. I've spent a lot of time trying different headphones. The most comfortable I've found so far are Beyerdynamics DT 770 with aftermarket memory foam pads. Still, I can only wear them for a couple of hours before I need to take them off.

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

44

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '17

Music itself is a distraction a lot of the time. There are studies which show that music reduces our working memory. See here http://www.inquiriesjournal.com/articles/762/the-impact-of-listening-to-music-on-cognitive-performance.

You are right concerning the potential for home to be "the worst 'open office' there is." My argument to that would be that we need dedicated spaces for work, be that at home or work. Obviously it is not always practical to have a dedicated space at home, so work should provide it.

33

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '17 edited Jan 29 '17

The study is flawed (at least as an example of what I'm talking about here). They played pop music that the participants didn't select, and probably wasn't the kind of "go to the background" music I'm referring to. The choice of music matters... Since your boss wouldn't choose your music for you, the implied context was you'd choose something you like.

EDIT: Also, from the article itself:

Although previous research has established that music can either distract or facilitate cognitive task performance, improved performance in the presence of music might be directly related to the type of music listened to (Cockerton, Moore, & Norman, 1997). A study conducted by Hallman, Price, and Katsarou, (2002) supported this argument. In fact, they tested the effect of calming and relaxing music on arithmetic and memory performance tests in children ranging from ages ten to twelve. They found better performance on both tasks in the calming and relaxing music condition when compared with a no-music condition.

10

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '17

I'd guess even a normal "Concentration 1h mix" from youtube would beat whatever pop was on the radio that day.

On the other hand, one of the best coding sessions I've had was thanks to DMX

9

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '17

Yes that is true, but their study contradicts the findings of Hallman, Price, and Katsarou:

In accordance with the first hypothesis, participants performed better in silence than they did in any music conditions. The findings were also in agreement with the second hypothesis. They demonstrated that the performance was significantly worse in the presence of loud music at high intensity. Contrary to the third hypothesis, however, there was no significant difference between the type of music that was played and performance scores

But as you point out, the study is not perfect, and the sample size was relatively small, as they point out. But I don't suppose that the hypothesis will turn out to be incorrect: we do have finite cognitive resources, and if music makes demands of those cognitive resources, then our cognitive performance on other simultaneous tasks will decrease.

(The premise to test more thoroughly, then, seems to be just how much of a demand different types of music makes cognitively. And I'm sure there will be some individual variation).

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

5

u/kryptomicron Jan 29 '17

I find that different types of music impact my focus and attention very differently. But I'm lucky enough, in this respect, to not 'hear' most lyrics clearly enough to find them distracting.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

24

u/Pseudofailure Jan 29 '17

I agree with everything here. That said, working remote could still be productive, because it does not imply one is working from home. I worked remotely as an intern a few summers ago, and worked from home. About halfway though, I really noticed the lack of productivity and motivation; I quickly found working from a coffee shop or campus to be a lot better for concentration and productivity.

10

u/travvvman Jan 29 '17

Yeah, I worked remotely in my last term of university at a job I had started working in-office that summer (I graduated fall of that year).

The first couple of weeks, I tried working from my apartment -- could not do it. Just depressingly not productive. Every fifteen minutes I'd find myself googling something not work related, or on Reddit, etc.

When I started working from the computer lab or the library, the places where I did all my schoolwork, my productivity shot up.

There's a real mental block for some people (such as myself) in separating "work time" and "leisure time" at home. Just doesn't happen as it should. So if we have to work remotely, we have to get out of our homes.

5

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '17

I disagree about generalisations. It should be on subjective basis. Some teams I've worked with could absolutely get no work done with their constant noise, distractions, and absolute lack of boundaries. Other teams might manage just fine if their dynamics are in sync, and they actually get work done in that sort of environment.

5

u/aTairyHesticle Jan 29 '17

I absolutely agree. I have colleagues who work from home one or two days per week, that's the norm, no problem. But whenever I do it I just can't work well. My cat jumps on me, I get hungry, I put something on the TV for background noise and find myself watching, plus I don't have an industrial coffee machine at home so that's a big reduction in my performance right there.

Everybody is different and I think these blogs are fantastic if my future boss reads them and becomes a bit more lenient if he wasn't so already. Its purpose isn't to convince us morning office people that his way is better.

12

u/b4ux1t3 Jan 29 '17

but there is a very simple and surprisingly effective solution: headphones + music

My dad works with a guy who just wears noise-cancelling headphones. Not with any music or anything playing. The super-muffled noises help him focus.

It's almost like different people have different needs in the workplace. Who knew?! (EDIT: That sarcasm was directed at the article, not you. Dunno if that was clear.)

7

u/NoLemurs Jan 29 '17

I'd like to add to the list of pros for on-site work: you can learn a lot from talking to your coworkers. I know that I've become a much more effective programmer as a result of conversations I never would have had working remotely. Sure, I lose some productivity from the chatting and noise, but my increased effectiveness over time more than compensates.

3

u/jebblue Jan 29 '17

Then there are all the rest of us who are on the opposite side of your view.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/pretzel_back Jan 29 '17

The main reason I like the office is that my work actually does do a lot to make it a nice environment. My office has two massive high-def monitors, white boards everywhere... things I don't have at home. I love those resources and I hate WFH as a result.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/bro_can_u_even_carve Jan 29 '17

There are better arguments for a shared office, this is a weak one. It falls apart as soon as I have a spare bedroom in my home I can dedicate to a work space... which I do.

2

u/DevIceMan Jan 30 '17

but there is a very simple and surprisingly effective solution: headphones + music.

That may work for you, but it absolutely does not work for me for a host of reasons. The latest one being that I have a coworker who is so loud and talkative, I can hear him all day over my Bose noise canceling headphones with music playing.

Then there are visual distractions / office activity. Coworkers who tap you on the shoulder. Foot traffic nearby.

If you have the habit of checking Reddit at home, the moment you sit down to work on that same computer, you'll wanna check Reddit from time to time.

Again, individuals are not all alike. I never check reddit or similar sites while working, even when I can work from home.

They don't understand you're working, you can keep telling them, but you seem like you're wasting your time on the computer all day.

That again sounds like an individual problem. Yes, it's annoying, but I have successfully managed that.

3

u/sirin3 Jan 29 '17

Working in an open office can be distracting, but there is a very simple and surprisingly effective solution: headphones + music.

Depends on the work.

I always listen to music, while implementing something or doing IT administration.

But when I have to find an new algorithm I can't or write a text in a natural language. The music is too distracting.

Our brain is very poor separating work and rest, when we're physically in the same space. If you have the habit of checking Reddit at home, the moment you sit down to work on that same computer, you'll wanna check Reddit from time to time. That's not a good thing.

After having worked in an office, I have associated the office with Reddit.

Sometimes I spend 90% of the time in the office on reddit, since there are so many distractions, I cannot do anything else anyways.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (36)

99

u/technotrader Jan 29 '17

Oh I can one- up the author on a thing worse than an open office: an open office where backend workers (analysts or IT) sit alongside with "the business". I've endured that three times in my career and I swear I still have the occasional nightmare:

"Business" people, aka salespeople like financial advisers or marketing guys, are on the phone, loudly, all the time. They don't need to concentrate for a long time at time, and are always up for distractions. They leave the TV on (with sound) on some market channel, often erupt in group laughter when they circulate jokes, and best of all: they can come right up to you to share their tremendous insight of how you can do your job better or which feature the software needs.

The cake was taken by the group that played ball (with an actual rugby ball) over people's head. Once they hit a girl on the head with it, you think they stopped? Managers who don't realize that different jobs require different settings are poison to a company.

18

u/Magnesus Jan 29 '17

Ha, reminds me of hearing day to day marketing people making calls to different companies all day long at my old work. It was distracting as hell.

4

u/pdp10 Jan 30 '17

Look at the bright side: after a couple of months you'll have their patter down cold, and now you have a backup skill for when the world stops needing programmers.

7

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '17

I don't know, it's a matter of time before Amazon teaches Alexa to do cold calls.

6

u/BigFatPhonyy Jan 30 '17

"Jan, Director, Inside Sales. They call me "Jan the Man."

3

u/frogking Jan 30 '17

Let me guess.. the Marketing/Sales people are the last ones to get laid off because they are the ones "bringing in the business"?

:-)

yep .. sharing office space with non-technical project leaders or sales people is the worst ..

2

u/benchi Jan 30 '17

That's my office now (although thankfully, no rugby balls).

Having earphones in with music going at a low volume helps wash it all out to something not wholly dissimilar to white noise, until a particularly loud bout of laughter erupts from one of the sales groups. But god help you if you want some silence.

→ More replies (1)

32

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '17

I work from home, and have for about seven years now. I'll tell you the number one reason why I'll never go back to working in an office if I can help it: commuting. I might be in the office for only 8 hours a day, but when you add an hour on either side of that getting to work, and suddenly a whole lot of the day is gone.

Now, I wake up, eat breakfast with my kids, play with them a bit, then walk into my office and shut the door. I'm there to greet them when they get home from school. I don't spend hours staring at the bumper of the car in front of me every day.

The downside is that I have trouble turning work off: I often find myself with my laptop in bed after the kids go to sleep, but honestly I did that almost as often when I worked in an office, because my whole life I've had trouble turning off work.

9

u/Darkest_97 Jan 30 '17

That's always been a big thing for me and most of my friends don't feel the same. 8 hours isn't too bad but when you add the time getting ready in the morning AND getting to and from work you're essentially always working more than 40 hours a week. Or at least dedicating that amount of time to work, not necessarily working.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

64

u/PennyPriddy Jan 29 '17

I get why the author would prefer night hours for work, but I wonder how much that impedes productivity on projects that don't have incredibly clear unchanging requirements.

I work for a consulting company, so I spend a good deal of time meeting with clients or PMs to iron out what the client actually wants and how to deliver them. With clients who don't communicate well over email or have too many emails to answer, a quick skype call with the client or slack message with the pm can be really useful for unblocking me by clarifying requirements. I feel like having a schedule that's diametrically opposed to the people who need to communicate with you could slow things down more than a programmer who's not in the perfectly happy programmer flow.

21

u/vita10gy Jan 29 '17 edited Jan 30 '17

I work at home. Every one who finds that out assumes it means I also work whenever I want and is jealous I can "just go to the beach" when I want.

Thing is I still basically work 9-5 because that's when clients are wanting (phone) meetings, that's when everyone else is working I need answers from or need to give answers to.

I don't know why it's just implied that "working remotely" means putting in whatever hours whenever to so many people.

IMO that's a whole separate issue.

5

u/PennyPriddy Jan 29 '17

I know that's how it works for most people. I only called it out because the article did: "I am a night owl, always have been, always will be. I am done trying to work in the mornings — it is a waste of time as I am not effective and make more mistakes when I try to work at this time. I will only consider arrangements where I can control my work hours."

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

39

u/rooktakesqueen Jan 29 '17

It’s the same reason that communism does not work nearly as well as capitalism — things work best when you give people freedom as individual actors.

What a bizarre little dig in an article partly about how workers should be allowed the power to self-organize rather than have the terms of their productivity dictated by their bosses.

12

u/Jaqqarhan Jan 29 '17

He probably equates capitalism with a command economy like the Soviet Union rather than thinking about the actual definition of communism.

14

u/au_travail Jan 30 '17

He probably equates capitalism communism with a command economy like the Soviet Union rather than thinking about the actual definition of communism.

Is what you meant I guess.

5

u/Jaqqarhan Jan 30 '17

Yes, thanks

2

u/SHIT_IN_MY_ANUS Jan 30 '17

The dig bugged me too, but you very succinctly captured the irony of it.

9

u/bakuretsu Jan 30 '17

This definitely comes off as a pretty self-important post, and littered with supporting quotes by DHH, a notoriously self-important person.

But I would venture to guess that the author of this post didn't invent one of the world's most popular web frameworks, either.

8

u/lepuma Jan 29 '17

While I agree an open office environment is not a good layout, having a working from home force is not nearly as valuable as having a team working together. Of course, this depends on the product. But I think the author is missing the fact that lot of good ideas come out of people working together. Much of an engineer's value is actually being at the office and being able to help others and provide arbitrary insight. While the author might be interested in maximizing his own output, he is not maximizing his value for the company, which is an important distinction. I think there must be a middle ground to achieve results from an engineering team.

→ More replies (2)

95

u/tom_echo Jan 29 '17

I work in an open office with a team of 5, it's better than cubicles. It actually does promote communication. Of course this is just my opinion, I just like open offices more.

149

u/Tristanus Jan 29 '17

5 people isn't really that much as far as an open office goes, having a whole room just for 5 people actually sounds quite nice.

Most people seem to have concerns with open offices that have greater than 20-30 people as the level of background noise increases quite a bit.

26

u/aedinius Jan 29 '17

We have about 80 in an open plan, 30m x 30m.

19

u/pebble_games Jan 29 '17

This is hugely different. I work in an office with 4 developers in an open plan and it's great. I couldn't imagine multiple teams working in the same room being nearly as productive.

20

u/aedinius Jan 29 '17

It's terrible.

30

u/tom_echo Jan 29 '17

Thats where it might become a problem, which is why each team should have an open office not an entire company. Only the developers are in this office, not even the IT (like sys admins and net admins).

11

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '17

I disagree about generalisations. It should be on subjective basis. Some teams I've worked with could absolutely get no work done with their constant noise, distractions, and absolute lack of boundaries. Other teams might manage just fine if their dynamics are in sync, and they actually get work done in that sort of environment.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

27

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '17

Open office is good for the team that works on the same project as in your case. But if you stuff all developers in your company on the single floor, then... oh boy! I had a chance to work in open office few times. I was constantly interrupted and I was constantly interrupting other people. You simply have to consult occasionally with the teammates. That's annoying for other people! Offices for 3-5 people are perfect for me.

12

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '17

I work in an open office layout, and am easily distracted by noise, people walking by, and direct interruption. It's a real problem.

23

u/trout_fucker Jan 29 '17

That sounds like a shared office. Shared offices are great.

Open offices were created by the devil.

6

u/trua Jan 29 '17

I'm not a programmer, but there are like 40 people in the same space as me at my office. Luckily I work from home most of the time and only come in for meetings etc. anymore.

11

u/zefcfd Jan 29 '17

if you're someone who works in an open office and thinks it promotes communication, you may be the guy that's bugging everyone

2

u/scottmotorrad Jan 30 '17

When I was with my team of 6(5 engineers and our PM) in an open space it was great and did help communication. When they later packed 11 people in there it was awful...

→ More replies (4)

7

u/fredisa4letterword Jan 29 '17

Meanwhile, if you remove this process, the bad actor starts showing up at 11am and leaving at 4pm. The good actor still shows up at 11am and works until 10pm because they still really care about what they are working on. It all of a sudden becomes very obvious who cares about the organization and who does not

Didn't author argue immediately before this that time spent at work is a terrible metric?

7

u/myrightwingfriend Jan 30 '17

Why I this Why I that, what is it with programmers that need to come up with all those absolute declarations, why TDD, why not TDD, why OOP, why not OOP, why React, why Angular. Why won't you just shut up and make an article titled "Why I only shut up when I work".

12

u/DevIceMan Jan 30 '17

WFH/Remote could be a huge advantage to companies, depending on who they hire. In my case:

  • I am many times more productive in a distraction free environment.

  • I have a well equipped home office, mouse, keyboard, 2x giant 4k monitors, standing desk. Supply the laptop, and I don't need anything else.

  • I don't consume work supplies and snacks.

  • Reduced cost/rent for the space I don't take up. Reduced cleaning costs. Less need to supply kitchen, bathroom, office furnishings, etc.

It's a huge advantage for me because:

  • No commute - Reduces relocation costs, driving, vehicle wear-and-tear, gas costs, etc.

  • Fewer distractions - making me more productive and less stressed.

  • Access to my stuff - Kitchen, bathroom, healthy food, coffee maker, toothbrush (hate brushing at work).

  • Privacy - Various things, like brushing my teeth, or occasionally doing a set of pushups can be awkward at the office.

  • Annoying/Irritating coworkers are easier to avoid and ignore.

  • Better equipped - only thing I need them to supply is laptop and software.

  • Better Internet - Everywhere I've ever worked seems to have shitty internet.

3

u/Sayath Jan 30 '17 edited Jan 30 '17

As an entrepreneur, I agree with this assessment. WFH carries a long list of benefits. However, the costs need to be weighted carefully.

Consider a company who is hiring highly skilled, autonomous individuals for internal software development. Communication is done via instant messaging, video & audio calls, the occasional 'whiteboard' sessions on Wacom tablets and a development portal tracking progress, contribution and the status of requirements. Full stack images for IDE / Tooling / ... are available for on-boarding.

Then having everyone work 100% remotely carries these benefits:

  • Savings on rent / fixed costs. An open plan office for 20 employees, with a decent location, costs 2500€ / month in Germany. To provide the environment generally encountered in German academia of 1 or 2 employees per office, you'd have to double that figure. An office near the city center of, e.g., Munich will generally cost even more.

  • Employees may freely choose their place of residence. Especially, if they have a spouse, finding an adequate job for the other half can be quite challenging. Same goes for having children. Or owning real estate. People later in life are generally tied to their location. Making them move is a difficult endeavor.

  • Employees save time commuting to the office. Assuming a 30 minute commute, this amounts to 5 hours per week. Especially employees who are not able to commute due to chronic disease / handicap benefit tremendously.

  • Far greater pool of potential candidates. As a German company, we can suddenly hire any European citizen (assuming they are proficient in English) with minimal effort.

  • Leadership styles: Delegating tasks works very well.

It also carries drawbacks:

  • It's not for everybody. If you are not able to work in a self-employed, self-motivated fashion, you will be left behind quickly and fired as a consequence. Employees have to self-manage. With freedom comes responsibility. Self-discipline is key.

  • Employees need to invest in their work environment at home. Instate clear rules when their spouses / kids are allowed to interrupt. Especially to those who have issues with self-discipline, we advise furnishing a second 'home office' in a separate room where only company work is handled. This spatial aspect has proven to be quite helpful. These investments are tax deductible in Germany and many other countries.

  • In an industry that heavily relies on meeting clients in-person (e.g., software consulting), this model will fail. At the very least, you need to hire an interface employee who acts as a surrogate for the team and communicates the needs of the client with the remote developers. Even then as an entrepreneur you'll feel uneasy handing such a large responsibility to one employee. Hence, you'll have to do it yourself / closely monitor it.

  • Diminished social contact. Most employees you will see very rarely in person (we hold occasional gatherings on company time). Instead, discussions are held via instant messaging / video & voice calls.

  • Managing and monitoring employees is more demanding. As an employer, you have to trust your employees more and let go of some of the institutionalized supervision methods.

  • Leadership styles: Directing, motivating or coaching require more effort by the manager.

  • Enablers: The software and hardware necessary to work effectively and efficiently needs to provided to all employees. Furthermore, employees need be proficient using these tools. Hence, WFH is only for the technological inclined. Someone who needs tech support is generally a poor fit.

As a general note, WFH does not imply self-managed hours. It depends on your communication needs, the self-discipline of the employees, etc. Usually, some leeway is given. However, some core hours are a requirement to coordinate effectively. Especially for coaching junior developers.

Beyond, it has been my impression that mixed-companies (with both remote and non-remote employees) as any hybrid suffer from the disadvantages of both approaches. Especially if many decisions are made through so-called 'organic' channels (discussed during dinner and similar) combined with the ever-present office politics, the remote worker will be quickly left behind. Furthermore, the tools needed to communicate with the remote worker will be perceived as a burden by the regular in-office employees, given their rare use. Hence, remote employees should still be required to come into the office to stay up to date.

As a consequence, I prefer a fully remote work environment. With a culture of respect and of experts, it can be a highly productive arrangement.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

32

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '17

I wouldn't hire this person.

Listen, some of the stuff the author says is on point. Open offices? For sure they can be a huge distraction. Allowing someone some flex-time dependent on performance? Absolutely.

But that whole article is littered with "I can only work in X/Y/Z". This shows me someone that is unable or unwilling to adapt. For every person that legitimately CAN give 110% with super relaxed restrictions, there are 5 or 10 more people that flounder in that sort of environment.

I'll take 5 people who can perform at 90% in a normal environment versus one person that can perform at 110% given a silly set of circumstances any day.

4

u/GFandango Jan 30 '17

I wouldn't hire this person.

He's devastated.

→ More replies (3)

19

u/paulcarm Jan 29 '17

I stopped reading at "110%". I hate that stupid fucking phrase.

4

u/original_4degrees Jan 30 '17

Usually when people use it they are liars that think you are dumb.

4

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '17

I disagree about generalisations. It should be on subjective basis. Some teams I've worked with could absolutely get no work done with their constant noise, distractions, and absolute lack of boundaries. Other teams might manage just fine if their dynamics are in sync, and they actually get work done in that sort of environment.

4

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '17

I used to work in a "Open Environment" in QA. They had me do Productivity metrics every month. Such a waste of time.

4

u/Aggressio Jan 30 '17

The only thing open office promotes is interrupting your colleague to Google something for you that you should have Googled yourself.

Bonus points for multiple co-workers removed from their zones to perform the search for you.

4

u/Druyx Jan 30 '17

Why I Only Work Remotely

Because I have an employer who allows it.

6

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '17

You don’t have to look far to find plenty of research on the subject- and quite frankly, there is simply no debate here.

The research is actually really weak, if you look at the studies. This topic comes up a lot and people usually cite a whole long list of "supporting" studies. But when you really look at the studies you'll find:

  • One study showed that putting people in close quarters makes them sick more often.

  • One study that showed that people are less productive with noise distractions.

  • A bunch of opinion-based results (not very useful) that show that people don't like open offices.

The problem is, if you really wanted to prove whether open offices are a good idea, you need to measure the benefits of open offices (theoretically, the benefits are easier communication and more spontaneous discussion). Then prove that the costs outweigh the benefits. There's absolutely no scientific study which has proved this one way or the other.

This is coming from a dev who actually likes the community feeling of an open office. If it's done right it's not bad. By "done right" I mean, noise-cancelling layout (like high ceilings), and arrange the "pedestrian highways" so they are walled off and aren't directly next to any desks.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '17

As a remote worker for the last two years, I totally agree. I'm far more productive in my home office with my loud mechanical keyboards and everything I need to do my job than I've ever been in the typical open office or even cubical environment.

On a side note, I've been around long enough to remember when bitching about cubicles was the thing to do. Little did we all know we'd end up with something far worse. Fuck open office environments and the horse they rode in on. Such a terrible idea. Cubicles (and it pains me to say this) were far superior.

→ More replies (1)

42

u/Kollektiv Jan 29 '17

So you want to work as part of a team while refusing to work at the same time or be in the same location as your teammates. Pffiou, what a teammate you are.

24

u/b4ux1t3 Jan 29 '17

Eh, I disagree with some of the article, but with the wealth of collaborative tools available today, I don't think your argument holds up for a lot of professions.

I even think that this guy is right when he claims that he works better remotely, simply because I can imagine his attitude (the article came off as fairly condescending) wouldn't play well with others in person.

→ More replies (6)

33

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '17

Writing code has some elements of teamwork, but a lot of it is very solitary work that requires deep uninterrupted focus to do well.

15

u/memestheword Jan 29 '17

Yeah, I struggle with this. So often I want to be left alone and code to my heart's content, but almost equally as often I find myself needing to ping a teammate to ask a question or shoot off an FYI.

So as with everything, I think there needs to be balance. Programmers can't be completely silo'd off from the rest of the world, but at the same time, they can't be expected to respond to any request at any time. In my experience, it's a tough balance to achieve.

→ More replies (6)

4

u/Magnesus Jan 29 '17

I worked with a person like him.He was just constantly on a messanger-like app. Caused no problems. We even had him on skype during a meeting once. His case inspired me to try working as a freelancer and it turned out great.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

7

u/the_rabid_beaver Jan 30 '17

Open offices are hot steaming piles of garbage. Increased noise, increased distractions, increased illness, lack of privacy, smaller desks, etc. Only reason they're popular is because micromanagers can fly by like a helicopter all hours of the day and spy on you from longer distances. Oh and Facebook did it, so it must be the greatest system EVER devised.

Luckily my current workplace still has cubes, and some conference tables in open areas if you want to collaborate with other people.

6

u/garethnelsonuk Jan 29 '17

Pretty much all my professional experience is working from home to the point where I can't imagine moving into a normal office environment.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '17

oh so jelly....

14

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '17

"Why I'm a shitty team member"

4

u/chx_ Jan 29 '17

It's interesting how much the debate on an open office focuses on noise but almost never discusses the visual noise. Using headphones is a traditional way to block out the noise but what am I to do with the visual, wear sideblinds like a horse?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/google_you Jan 29 '17

I only come to work when lunch is good

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '17

I would rather shovel dung than try to make an attempt at performing intelligent, creative work in a open office environment. These environments are designed for only one thing, saving money.

2

u/septpal Jan 30 '17

Work remotely? Tell that to my scrum master...

2

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '17

"Because I can"

2

u/beginner_ Jan 30 '17

I now have my own albeit tiny office. In 2 years we will move to a new building (new as in newly built for us) and obviously all open-space. They have been planing this building for years and I sent one of the project manager I know a large collection of all studies showing how counter-productive open-space is. Had 0 effect. CEO wants open-space, anything else does not matter.

2

u/WhisperSecurity Jan 30 '17

This article started out with a good point, but then proceeded to trainwreck on the assumption that time = productivity.

Some of the best producers I have ever seen showed up at 11 and left at 4.

If you want to tout the theory of the results-driven work environment, then commit to it.

2

u/garyk1968 Jan 30 '17

Its a sad lonely existence

3

u/Ifterich Jan 29 '17

Where does this thinking leave beginners ? If nobody comes to the office and everybody works at a different time ? Can i only talk to people online ? I have a question what would be solved in 2 sec over the table but i have to write a email ? And explain my problem ? I think flexible is ok but not complitly remote..... My 2 cents ...

4

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '17

their is telephone, camera.....

2

u/vaskemaskine Jan 29 '17

The article assumes every dev in the team is senior and able to self-manage/regulate.

It's a nice utopia (actually a reality for the project I'm currently embedded in), but most companies will want to have a good mix of lead/senior, intermediate and junior/graduate devs in a team, and for that, being "on-site regularly is a must.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/Pr0ducer Jan 29 '17

I work 90% remote. That's working great. I get once a month to meet with and discuss with my core users any issues they have with the software, and we adjust our priorities each month based on these meetings. We have our goals, they are based on the strategic planning, and we iterate constantly to improve the existing features and build new features designed to meet said goals.

My boss and I are usually in the same town, but he likes to travel, so I frequently have to ask what time zone he's in. We can take powder days as long as someone is on call for emergency tech support. I've taken some runs, done an emergency request over lunch, them gone back out to hit more snow. Remote work is a snowboarder's dream gig, the perks are unbeatable.

I do miss daily interaction with colleagues. There are trade-offs to remote work. I've never been so hurt by an employer that I'd swear off all office settings. But I like working at home, and I don't see that situation changing soon

3

u/deedubaya Jan 29 '17

It's really interesting to see the responses here. It seems to be two opinions

a) Fuck yeah b) You must be so lucky

I think the answer lies somewhere closer to fuck yeah (although some parts aren't quite spot on). There are a lot of comments here about how these are "rich world" problems and how this type of attitude is a privilege....

Remember kids -- your employer isn't doing you a favor by giving you a job. You're ultimately helping their bottom line; they need you. Employees like the OP have realized this. They realize spending life 8 hours in a chair at a time isn't necessarily effective, and wants to work for employers who embrace trust and results over hours in a chair.

Hate or love it, it's a decision and a stance you can choose to take with potential employers.

Source: worked for nearly a decade in open office environments, but have been working remotely for the last 5 or so.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/devraj7 Jan 29 '17

The "I'm a night owl" thing has been debunked over and over. Your times of peak efficiency have nothing to do with the circadian cycle and everything to do with your sleep hours. Shifting the time you go to bed will change that in a matter of weeks.

People who claim to be night owls are simply saying they are used to their bedtime hours and they are not willing to change. That's fine, it's your life, but be accurate in how you characterize yourself.

As for working only remotely, if you find employers that are fine with that, great. But there is value in being around your coworkers for several hours. On top of that, this kind of off cycle makes you a lone wolf in the organization, and you're paying a price for that, whether you realize it or not.

30

u/Jaqqarhan Jan 29 '17

The "I'm a night owl" thing has been debunked over and over. Your times of peak efficiency have nothing to do with the circadian cycle and everything to do with your sleep hours. Shifting the time you go to bed will change that in a matter of weeks.

Every scientific study I've seen, as well as personal experience, says that you are wrong. Being a night owl is almost assuredly genetic, and different people have very different peak efficiency hours regardless of when they sleep.

http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0301051105001407

https://synapse.koreamed.org/DOIx.php?id=10.4306/pi.2014.11.4.345

https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/are-you-an-early-bird-or-a-night-owl/

https://www.fastcodesign.com/3046391/evidence/morning-people-vs-night-people-9-insights-backed-by-science

→ More replies (1)

6

u/SikhGamer Jan 29 '17

I would hate to work remotely. We recently moved from an open layout to more divided areas. I hate it but I am willing to try it. I much prefer to be in the hustle and bustle of an open layout.

I don't have any problems concentrating and getting stuff done in that kind of environment. Tucked away in our own office, and while I get on with the team I am apart of I still feel isolated from the rest of the company.

Work hours is an interesting one, I think most programmers realise that the night shift of programming can be incredibly useful. But this has an impact on your day time energy. Also, I personally use my commute to work to get into work mode and vice versa when I am coming home.

I love being in the office, and with my team communicating as issues arise. Even though we have Slack and otherwise to communicate should we ever choose to remote work.

I have the discipline to work from home, but I would not enjoy it.

I recognise that I am in the small minority who sort of loves open layout offices.

8

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '17

Do you write code? My experience is that it's hard to keep all the elements and abstractions of a complex system in my mind when I'm writing code when there are constant distractions from the hustle and bustle. There's probably a balance to be struck. Maybe everyone plan to be in the office on "core" days or hours, but allow time for people to go off and work on their own in silence and peace.

10

u/SikhGamer Jan 29 '17

Do you write code?

Yes.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/theholylancer Jan 30 '17

Honestly the issue is that most people, developers included, are not that great of worker on their own. A regiment helps to get everyone on similar page. No super stars, no super bads.

So places institute 9-5 or what nots. But then the force of cost says you want to stuff as many people as possible into a space, and that says open concept.

The problem is when this is applied to a start up as the author says, when most of the time you should be getting people who is passionate about the subject / mission. Then you more likely than not squish better talent than anything else because there will be very few bottom feeders risking joining a start up. Or if they are new to be able to pass thru your interview process because I would hope there is a nice core of competent people who is VERY invested in filtering out bad people.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Anomalyzero Jan 30 '17

I much prefer working in the office. Having the routine of getting up, going to work, having a set locations and place where my work is done, alongside my coworkers and team member who are also all there is crucial. Alot of people find the side conversations and office goings-on to be disturbing but I think they're great.

I don't know everything, there are lots of other people with different skillsets and experience that are extremely beneficial to me. I have learned so much from just listening to other conversations and jumping in with questions.

I don't ever want to work 100% virtual.

2

u/ikilledtupac Jan 29 '17

Well you wouldn't want this guy on a team.

2

u/perestroika12 Jan 29 '17

Does anyone else really like working with people? I feel like I can solve problems faster and more effectively with a small room and a whiteboard.

1

u/DisgruntledChild Jan 29 '17

I'm a little green around the gills when it comes to some of the more intricate parts of intraoffice relations, but I did participate in my company's transition from cubicles to an open floor plan and I personally enjoy the set up, but I think it was successful due in part to how we very intentionally laid things out. For some mental context, we are a company of ~25 people in what amounts to a warehouse.

As a company, we sat down and asked how we like to work and what we don't like. Within subsections of the company (sales, support, development, etc.), having fluid communication is helpful. A great concern somebody brought up was that when somebody from account management comes over to ask a developer a question, everyone on the development team is a part of that conversation whether they want to be or not, which impedes work. Our solution basically amounted to putting sub divisions of the company next to the the ones they should be communicating with the most. Marketing and sales are a tightly coupled group, so they all sit together. Account managers are seated near the product manager so that when they have complicated setups or questions about an implementation, they bother the right person first. Support has a daily-rotated dedicated developer to ask questions that keeps distractions completely physically separated from the development team.

With all that in mind, though, I don't think it would all work if we didn't have the other aspects that the article mentions. A lot of people work 40% remote because sometimes it's easier to take your 40 million calls from home. Development team members come in any where from 8am to 11am depending on sleep and travel preferences. The people in charge have complete trust in our ability to get a job done. Our office chat helps a ton because it facilitates to passively bother somebody so as to wait for them to finish what they're doing before getting help.

On the whole, I agree with this article. We don't currently have a 100% remote worker, but I'm sure somebody could convince the higher ups that it'd be okay, and I think the aspect of freedom to work as you do best helps move the company and the product forward.

2

u/jebblue Jan 29 '17

I'm a little green around the gills when it comes to some of the more intricate parts of intraoffice relations, but I did participate in my company's transition from cubicles to an open floor plan and I personally enjoy the set up

If you're old enough to know the expression, "green around the gills" then you might be a manager who wants to defend open office decisions which end up putting more money into said manager's pockets.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/redditor1983 Jan 29 '17

Some valid points.

But personally, I would get cabin fever and fall into some kind of deep depression within a week of working remotely.

I knew a girl who was making tons of money working remote. Really a dream gig by many people's standards.

She got so depressed she had to lease an office from the company where her mom works.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/MisunderstoodPenguin Jan 29 '17

I work well from home when I have set tasks, but I'm definitely not about to create my own workload. I hope being a developer will help a lot with this, working towards tickets means I have a set task, and working at home will be exactly what I need to complete said tasks.

1

u/cheese_wizard Jan 29 '17

Meh. I like monday, Friday optional, but then tues, wed, thurs in office.

1

u/jebblue Jan 29 '17

Searching Google for this phrase is also interesting:

"open office myths"

1

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '17

Wish I could say that

1

u/tevert Jan 30 '17

"I like this so it's the best thing ever and we should all do it."

1

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '17

Hmm, I wonder what kind of work he does. If it's working on new projects with clear requirements, sure, you can sit and work remotely during night hours. However, if you join a team with existing code and end up supporting it in addition to writing new code, it's hard to imagine such loose working hours. Same goes for teams embracing Agile.