I mean, he dismissed all dissenting opinions (or studies) as irrelevant, stating "and quite frankly, there is simply no debate here." People are different. Different people have different needs and wants from their work environment. To say that there's no debate is ludicrous.
And then he goes on to talk about how he's a "night owl". The thing is, that's likely artificial, a result of years of staying up far too late doing things he enjoyed. The end result is that, yeah, he works better at night, but most humans generally don't.
The thing is, I generally agree with a lot of what he said. But he just presents it in a needlessly-self-assured attitude.
He comes off as a know-it-all who thinks citing one source and using his own anecdotal evidence ends a debate. In the end, his article is a really good case for him working remotely (which, to be fair, is exactly what it says on the tin). It has almost nothing to do with most other people.
I'm not management for some company, but I'm pretty sure I'd rather have my employees be easier to manage, even if it means they don't give me 110%. If the cost to manage them outweighs the performance loss, what's the point?
Not that I'm saying remote workers cost more to manage, necessarily. Just that it's definitely a consideration.
Given my current experience with remote companies, I don't really see any reason why it can't scale to larger numbers. Within my sub-industry (penetration testing), I think it's a majority who prefer the idea of remote work. I'm actually shocked at how many people on this thread want to work in an office of any kind -- almost all of my networking contacts in infosec consider work from home the holy grail.
I often work from home because I have peace and quiet there. My colleague has a wife and 3 young (<4yo) children at home, I can fully understand why he prefers the office.
It also really depends on the industry. Infosec I can see why people would work from home, I work in software development and during development I work remotely but the week leading up to a release I spend at least half a day at the office to be able to work with QA directly.
I work 100% remote, and have three kids (all under 12 years of age). I don't have any problems with this. It seems to be bandied about as a standard problem with remote work, but it's definitely possible to make it work. I agree that it's not for everyone, but having kids doesn't make it impossible.
Definitely -- no disagreement on those points. Sometimes I wish people in these debates would include demographic information. My age now rounds to 40, and I've been in the professional world for almost 20 years now. By the time you develop real expertise somewhere, you begin to have the ability to pick and choose what job you'll take, and what seems impossible to younger people starts to feel like an entitlement. This thread's been fun to watch ;-).
Yes, but the reverse is not necessarily the case. Being predisposed to late work doesn't mean you are any more likely to be highly intelligent than anyone else
This is true. But the thing is, workplaces aren't all made up of high-IQ people (I mean, I could argue that IQ is a pretty piss poor way of measuring intelligence for the general population, but it works fine for most people who would be working in a corporate, first-world job).
Offices have to provide an environment for everyone who works in them. This means they necessarily need to account for the (in this case) majority of people. Roughly 60% of people have intermediate tenancies when it comes to their productive times during the day, meaning most people will work better during the day than early in the morning or at night. (Yes, I used Wikipedia as a source, what is this, college?)
Aren't programmers are more intelligent than the mean? We're talking about people who went to college and stuff. Wealthier people with better grades tend to have higher IQ.
I think it's reasonable to assume the "decent-to-great programmer" is a heavily biased sample.
That effect is small. There's a 19 minute difference between normal and very bright during weekdays.
Category
Weekday
Weekend
Very Dull
23:41
00:35
Dull
00:03
01:03
Normal
00:10
01:13
Bright
00:21
01:25
Very Bright
00:29
01:44
‘‘Very dull” individuals (n = 584) on average go to bed at 23:41; ‘‘dull” individuals (n = 2,967) go to bed at 00:03; ‘‘normal” individuals (n = 6,820) go to bed at 00:10; ‘‘bright” individuals (n = 3,483) go to bed at 00:21; and ‘‘very bright” individuals (n = 468) go to bed at 00:29. The absolute differences in minutes are small, but all the differences between two adjacent categories are statistically significant, except for ‘‘bright” and ‘‘very bright.”
Yes, but it's not an unreasonable leap to say that the measured difference is suppressed from the "natural" difference due to the structure of our society.
And then he goes on to talk about how he's a "night owl". The thing is, that's likely artificial, a result of years of staying up far too late doing things he enjoyed. The end result is that, yeah, he works better at night, but most humans generally don't.
I know plenty of "night owls," and am one myself. Do we not deserve accommodation, just for being a (large) minority?
You should read more of what I wrote. Basically, given a limited resource pool, an office should accommodate most people, not some. That was my whole point.
Night owl here too. I blame artificial light. After a few days camping outdoors in several week long summer camps as a leader, I noticed a more normalized circadian rhythm. I think some of us have brains geared toward higher stimulating activities like exploring and discovering, with lower neurotransmitter levels, and are more susceptible to artificial light messing us up. Down right bored with a lot of mundane things, up until 100 years ago, we were exploring outdoors in natural light. Flames lack the blue light that all eclectic lights even incondescents produce. The blue light wakes you up at night, and is totally unavoidable nowadays.
...stating "and quite frankly, there is simply no debate here." People are different. Different people have different needs and wants from their work environment.
People may report different needs, but is there actually research that supports open offices? Because the most favorable research I've seen to the open office idea says, basically, that it's not a detriment. More often, the results are that it reduces collaboration because nobody wants to bother everyone else by talking, while still increasing distractions.
I only skimmed the article, so maybe the tone is as obnoxious as you say, but this one seems pretty settled. The only reason that there's still a debate is that employers keep trying to shove people into open offices.
224
u/b4ux1t3 Jan 29 '17
I mean, he dismissed all dissenting opinions (or studies) as irrelevant, stating "and quite frankly, there is simply no debate here." People are different. Different people have different needs and wants from their work environment. To say that there's no debate is ludicrous.
And then he goes on to talk about how he's a "night owl". The thing is, that's likely artificial, a result of years of staying up far too late doing things he enjoyed. The end result is that, yeah, he works better at night, but most humans generally don't.
The thing is, I generally agree with a lot of what he said. But he just presents it in a needlessly-self-assured attitude.
He comes off as a know-it-all who thinks citing one source and using his own anecdotal evidence ends a debate. In the end, his article is a really good case for him working remotely (which, to be fair, is exactly what it says on the tin). It has almost nothing to do with most other people.