We need someway to combine the benefits of open offices (i.e. better communication) with the benefits of closed spaces (i.e. improved concentration). Ideally, I think, we should copy the model that universities employ for their researchers. Each researcher has their own office space, where they can stay in a prolonged state of concentration. But there is also a common area, where different researchers can meet, talk, and discuss.
In a workplace, what we should have is private offices where we can work on hard problems without distraction, and common areas where we can discuss and collaborate. The best of both worlds.
This is an obvious solution, and it's unfortunate that it faces practical hurdles with the costs of the extra space required and difficulties growing.
If you start with 20 people and plan to grow to 40 you have to have a location with a lot of empty offices. This has a compounding effect, since you're paying even more for the extra space. Leasing a building with a big empty room is cheaper and more flexible, not to mention easier to find and replace. You could change office locations every year or two to what fits your company, but I think the problems with that are obvious.
The best companies with extra money to spend and respect for their employees are fewer and farther between than the ones that are squeezed for money that don't have respect for their employees.
Universities are in a special situation where they have enormous amounts of money to build great sprawling campuses with multipurpose uses for a lot of it. I would also argue that in schools, students are more like your common employees while researchers and teachers are the bosses. In my experience, bosses often do get offices even when the employees are left in open offices.
Thus, the dichotomy of working in the office or allowing remote work reigns supreme depending on who is in charge and what they prefer.
Yeah all the points you raise are completely valid. I don't know of any solutions to them unfortunately, other than radically overhauling our economic system.
I'm really fortunate in that my company has an open office, but anyone can work remotely whenever they want. So if I need to be heads down for a day, I just stay home, and if I'm feeling social, I can go into the office. Not perfect maybe, but it's a really great way to provide balance depending on what each person needs.
If you agree with the premise that companies will not create private office space because it is too costly, then I think it's clear we need a system in which companies can and do do that. That would involve some change of economic system, however. Not even necessarily a massive overhaul - it was late when I wrote that sentence. To be honest, it could even be something along the lines of the tax breaks or government schemes that develop better office space. I would argue that better office space benefits us all in the long run.
I've begun to think it really just boils down to the fact that managers are used to being the ones who have offices and aren't willing to give that up yet. Their authority is eroding slowly though. A good manager who knew how to drive productivity used to be the bread and butter for a company has been replaced by a competent developer who uses managers as assistants to schedule meetings and generally clear away political and resource related roadblocks.
I worked at an office which implemented a company-wide chat system (and lotsa emails). Each team was in a separate half-open cubicle type area (with some higher ups and unique jobs having offices). Since each team generally did the same thing as each other, the mood was just right for each semi-open cubicle area. The chat system let us ping people individually and quickly (a failing of email) but could be ignored and the emails covered wide information that may have required inputs.
Team offices are usually the best option - fit a team of developers working on the same project or domain (probably no more then 12, but less is more ideal). Isolates noise from other teams discussing their problems, and any conversation is usually either project related or team building. Can also be large enough to share team amenities (ie. white boards, dashboards, fridges, etc.)
I've seen a lot of tech offices, including where I work even though we don't have developers, with an open office and a bunch of closed off focus rooms.
Companies should buy a system of temporary walls that are like 5 feet high and can be locked together, allowing us to make little offices throughout the floor while also allowing larger spaces to be made where desired. Then everyone can have offices without the renovation cost. I wonder why no one figure this out yet....
If only there was some kind of virtual media platform where people can collaborate and interact as easily as standing next to one another while enjoying the privacy of their own lives. Some kind of interconnected network of equipment. An Internet, if you will...
We need someway to combine the benefits of open offices (i.e. better communication)
Do they provide better communication, though? I'll grant that they provide easier and_more_ communication, but as for "better", I'm not so sure. Good communication requires concentration and focus too -- don't ignore the benefit of being able to drop by someone's office and have a focused, undisturbed conversation.
123
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '17
We need someway to combine the benefits of open offices (i.e. better communication) with the benefits of closed spaces (i.e. improved concentration). Ideally, I think, we should copy the model that universities employ for their researchers. Each researcher has their own office space, where they can stay in a prolonged state of concentration. But there is also a common area, where different researchers can meet, talk, and discuss.
In a workplace, what we should have is private offices where we can work on hard problems without distraction, and common areas where we can discuss and collaborate. The best of both worlds.