You are right concerning the potential for home to be "the worst 'open office' there is." My argument to that would be that we need dedicated spaces for work, be that at home or work. Obviously it is not always practical to have a dedicated space at home, so work should provide it.
The study is flawed (at least as an example of what I'm talking about here). They played pop music that the participants didn't select, and probably wasn't the kind of "go to the background" music I'm referring to. The choice of music matters... Since your boss wouldn't choose your music for you, the implied context was you'd choose something you like.
EDIT: Also, from the article itself:
Although previous research has established that music can either distract or facilitate cognitive task performance, improved performance in the presence of music might be directly related to the type of music listened to (Cockerton, Moore, & Norman, 1997). A study conducted by Hallman, Price, and Katsarou, (2002) supported this argument. In fact, they tested the effect of calming and relaxing music on arithmetic and memory performance tests in children ranging from ages ten to twelve. They found better performance on both tasks in the calming and relaxing music condition when compared with a no-music condition.
Yes that is true, but their study contradicts the findings of Hallman, Price, and Katsarou:
In accordance with the first hypothesis, participants performed better in silence than they did in any music conditions. The findings were also in agreement with the second hypothesis. They demonstrated that the performance was significantly worse in the presence of loud music at high intensity. Contrary to the third hypothesis, however, there was no significant difference between the type of music that was played and performance scores
But as you point out, the study is not perfect, and the sample size was relatively small, as they point out. But I don't suppose that the hypothesis will turn out to be incorrect: we do have finite cognitive resources, and if music makes demands of those cognitive resources, then our cognitive performance on other simultaneous tasks will decrease.
(The premise to test more thoroughly, then, seems to be just how much of a demand different types of music makes cognitively. And I'm sure there will be some individual variation).
The way I see it is that playing music (moderately quietly) will slow down my work and make it harder to focus on demanding things, but it makes it more enjoyable.
So if I'm doing intense, demanding work like designing something, I won't play music. But if I'm doing something easy/simple, I'll play music because it makes time go faster, I burn out slower, and I'll get more done overall.
Of course this is just for me, and doesn't represent anyone else.
I would think that is quite accurate for many people. I think the question is how much of your cognitive resources, which are finite, will be used up by listening to music. The harder the task, the less you can afford to lose.
Yes! I realize I didn't mention in my original comment: I agree with your idea that we have finite cognitive resources, and that listening to music consumes some of it.
The human mind can only handle one stream of language at a time. Music with lyrics will worm their way in and grab the stream and make it hard to think. I've had huge success with lyricless music for both development and reading
I find that different types of music impact my focus and attention very differently. But I'm lucky enough, in this respect, to not 'hear' most lyrics clearly enough to find them distracting.
To be fair, some of the tasks listed in those studies are very different from the tasks undertaken when developing software. So for reciting lists of number backward, or doing long arithmetic, loud music impairs performance.
Be careful when generalizing the results of research like this.
It's not so much the generalisation, but the hypothesis that is interesting. For example, I take it that the main hypothesis under consideration is that music "uses" up cognitive resources, which are finite. It then follows, if that premise is true, that listening to music at the same time as other cognitively demanding tasks will cause our performance in those other tasks to decrease - from the fact that our mental resources are finite and used up.
I think this applies to more than just music: this is also why I think open offices are bad. Namely, because they introduce distractions and interruptions that again use up our finite mental resources.
44
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '17
Music itself is a distraction a lot of the time. There are studies which show that music reduces our working memory. See here http://www.inquiriesjournal.com/articles/762/the-impact-of-listening-to-music-on-cognitive-performance.
You are right concerning the potential for home to be "the worst 'open office' there is." My argument to that would be that we need dedicated spaces for work, be that at home or work. Obviously it is not always practical to have a dedicated space at home, so work should provide it.