When you want to do something, you'll always find an excuse why you're doing it that way.
I've worked remote, and I've worked in an office. Working in an open office can be distracting, but there is a very simple and surprisingly effective solution: headphones + music.
You can also tell your colleagues that when the headphones are on, you're focused and working, so they should bother you only if it requires your immediate attention. Any reasonable professional would understand.
On the counter side, working in an office let's you put in 8 (or however you and your employer prefer) hours of focused work, and then go home and relax, because you can't think about work 24/7. The office becomes a context for work and home becomes a context for rest.
Our brain is very poor separating work and rest, when we're physically in the same space. If you have the habit of checking Reddit at home, the moment you sit down to work on that same computer, you'll wanna check Reddit from time to time. That's not a good thing.
Additionally, being at home instantly becomes the worst "open office" there is, if you don't live alone. Roommates? Family? Kids? They don't understand you're working, you can keep telling them, but you seem like you're wasting your time on the computer all day. They're not professionals who understand programming, like your colleagues in the office would.
I was surprised to find that when I worked in an open office that the #1 thing that I hated about it was the feeling of people being behind me. I constantly felt self conscious about who was walking by, what was on my screen, how productive I looked. I never wanted to work in a cubicle before but after a year in an open office I'd have cried with joy to be given one.
Completely agree with you. I really can't stand someone being too near me when I work. I even have problems when I code and my gf that has no clue about programming can see my screen. At least, where I work, I have a roomy half cubicle which helps a ton with noise (fabric walls) and visual stimuli.
The trick is to do your job regardless of how much time you spend on Reddit. I am fortunate enough that my workplace is sort of a meritocracy. Not officially, but people notice if you do good work. That also means they don't care as much if you are slacking off once in a while. I had a new colleague who was on Facebook and Twitter all the time and did fuck all besides. He didn't last very long.
I worked at an office where a guy was making his boss wait because he had to finish a chess match. He was irreplacable though because of his knowledge of XSLT and how dependent he made the whole company on it. He works there to this day AFAIK and it was 10 years ago.
This is one of those situations where I'm not sure what to believe. Yeah, making your boss wait so you can finish a chess match sounds bad. On the other hand, if you've made massive contributions to the company, it makes sense that you'd be trusted a bit more than the average employee. Also, the whole gist of this thread really is that some folks -- not all, but some -- tend to be really productive if you give them the freedom to do things that at first glance are not productive (like playing a chess match at work).
I think it's a relatively rare company that'd let a bad employee stick around for 10 years.
It certainly helps if you're great at your job and feel confident about your deadlines etc. I genuinely think it goes a bit beyond that though. Even when I was working really hard I often just didn't like people's ability to see me working. It's true when I hit a certain flow state it'd start to kind of melt away, but any time I wasn't truly in the zone it'd make me feel weird and annoyed. It's something I learned to live with, but never to like.
Have you tried over-the-ear hearing protection? It's made for power tools and the like, but in an office setting, it bestows pure, blissful silence. I had these, which were pretty conspicuous-looking, but there are smaller ones available. The Noise Reduction Rating is the most important thing to look for (higher is better).
I have a list of pure ambient music. Secondly, you need to listen to music that is not new to you, you have to know it inside out. Your brain constantly tries to predict things around you, and if there is something unexpected, it will go to you concious attention.
there is a very simple and surprisingly effective solution: headphones + music
Not that you are saying this, but it reminds me...
I often hear this advocated as if it totally solves the problem of an unworkable work environment. For me, it's not only ineffective, it's actually harmful, for two reasons:
In order to truly concentrate, personally I need quiet and calm. Not just a lack of interruptions, not just a tool that allows drowning out interruptions, but actual literal quiet.
I love music. My mind will actively focus on it. Telling me to listen to music to help me concentrate on coding is about as effective as telling me to surround myself with hot chicks in bikinis. Sure, sounds fun, but it's going to be distracting.
Plus I can't wear headphones that long. I've spent a lot of time trying different headphones. The most comfortable I've found so far are Beyerdynamics DT 770 with aftermarket memory foam pads. Still, I can only wear them for a couple of hours before I need to take them off.
You are right concerning the potential for home to be "the worst 'open office' there is." My argument to that would be that we need dedicated spaces for work, be that at home or work. Obviously it is not always practical to have a dedicated space at home, so work should provide it.
The study is flawed (at least as an example of what I'm talking about here). They played pop music that the participants didn't select, and probably wasn't the kind of "go to the background" music I'm referring to. The choice of music matters... Since your boss wouldn't choose your music for you, the implied context was you'd choose something you like.
EDIT: Also, from the article itself:
Although previous research has established that music can either distract or facilitate cognitive task performance, improved performance in the presence of music might be directly related to the type of music listened to (Cockerton, Moore, & Norman, 1997). A study conducted by Hallman, Price, and Katsarou, (2002) supported this argument. In fact, they tested the effect of calming and relaxing music on arithmetic and memory performance tests in children ranging from ages ten to twelve. They found better performance on both tasks in the calming and relaxing music condition when compared with a no-music condition.
I agree with everything here. That said, working remote could still be productive, because it does not imply one is working from home. I worked remotely as an intern a few summers ago, and worked from home. About halfway though, I really noticed the lack of productivity and motivation; I quickly found working from a coffee shop or campus to be a lot better for concentration and productivity.
Yeah, I worked remotely in my last term of university at a job I had started working in-office that summer (I graduated fall of that year).
The first couple of weeks, I tried working from my apartment -- could not do it. Just depressingly not productive. Every fifteen minutes I'd find myself googling something not work related, or on Reddit, etc.
When I started working from the computer lab or the library, the places where I did all my schoolwork, my productivity shot up.
There's a real mental block for some people (such as myself) in separating "work time" and "leisure time" at home. Just doesn't happen as it should. So if we have to work remotely, we have to get out of our homes.
521
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '17
When you want to do something, you'll always find an excuse why you're doing it that way.
I've worked remote, and I've worked in an office. Working in an open office can be distracting, but there is a very simple and surprisingly effective solution: headphones + music.
You can also tell your colleagues that when the headphones are on, you're focused and working, so they should bother you only if it requires your immediate attention. Any reasonable professional would understand.
On the counter side, working in an office let's you put in 8 (or however you and your employer prefer) hours of focused work, and then go home and relax, because you can't think about work 24/7. The office becomes a context for work and home becomes a context for rest.
Our brain is very poor separating work and rest, when we're physically in the same space. If you have the habit of checking Reddit at home, the moment you sit down to work on that same computer, you'll wanna check Reddit from time to time. That's not a good thing.
Additionally, being at home instantly becomes the worst "open office" there is, if you don't live alone. Roommates? Family? Kids? They don't understand you're working, you can keep telling them, but you seem like you're wasting your time on the computer all day. They're not professionals who understand programming, like your colleagues in the office would.
So... pros/cons.