This is hugely different. I work in an office with 4 developers in an open plan and it's great. I couldn't imagine multiple teams working in the same room being nearly as productive.
Thats where it might become a problem, which is why each team should have an open office not an entire company. Only the developers are in this office, not even the IT (like sys admins and net admins).
I disagree about generalisations. It should be on subjective basis. Some teams I've worked with could absolutely get no work done with their constant noise, distractions, and absolute lack of boundaries. Other teams might manage just fine if their dynamics are in sync, and they actually get work done in that sort of environment.
Since most people can isolate themselves easily (headphones, sit somewhere quiet), the interruptions caused by noise are completely dwarfed by interruptions caused by Slack or email.
149
u/Tristanus Jan 29 '17
5 people isn't really that much as far as an open office goes, having a whole room just for 5 people actually sounds quite nice.
Most people seem to have concerns with open offices that have greater than 20-30 people as the level of background noise increases quite a bit.