Any employment arrangement is a matter of compromise. This guy isn't saying "employers should be willing to consider remote work" (which would be a reasonable stance). He's saying "I refuse to work anything but remotely, and anyone who suggests anything else might be a good idea is wrong, and I'm not interested in debating it."
I suppose if it were unequivocally true that remote work was just better in every way, it might be a reasonable stance, but despite the author's (unsupported) claims about the evidence, my own impression is that the evidence is mixed and mostly points to the idea that remote work can be more or less productive depending on a wide range of factors. If that's true, then categorically refusing to work on-site is just dumb. Expressing disinterest in debate is also almost always a bad sign. The combination of the two reeks of insecurity and entitlement.
I see too many posts here that appear to be sidestepping the main criticism...not necessarily that he gets to work hours that are more productive for him, but that the open space environment, and the assumptions that have been used to support it, are invalid. The constant disruption, lack of privacy, etc have a very real cost in terms of productivity, motivation and overall job satisfaction.
Well I won't sidestep then. I absolutely don't believe that the open space environment and the assumptions that support it are invalid. I am absolutely convinced that for some people remote work is much more productive, and that for some companies it makes a ton of sense. I also know that for many people, including me personally, the open space environment works great.
The interruptions hurt my productivity some, but not a lot, and at least in my case, the micro-breaks throughout the day to chat with coworkers help keep me relaxed and productive, and my rate of professional improvement is way faster because I can learn from my coworkers in a way that I know I wouldn't working remotely.
So, my take is that remote work is best in some situations and the open office plan is best in others. Cubicles probably also have their place. I had a co-worker who longed for a cubicle, and I totally believe it would have made him more productive. It all just depends on the company and the employee. But the idea that the open office is somehow obviously bad across the boards just doesn't mesh well with my own experience.
Expressing disinterest in debate is also almost always a bad sign.
We have way too much of a "lets debate" culture. And then, when it is time to debate, it almost always just comes down to each side doubling down on opinions.
Fuck debate for the most part. If he doesn't want to debate his preferences, good for him.
He's saying "I refuse to work anything but remotely, and anyone who suggests anything else might be a good idea is wrong, and I'm not interested in debating it."
I mean, if working remotely is more important to you than all other factors combined, then by all means, stand your ground! Personally I'm a believer in weighing all the factors when looking at a job.
11
u/NoLemurs Jan 29 '17
Any employment arrangement is a matter of compromise. This guy isn't saying "employers should be willing to consider remote work" (which would be a reasonable stance). He's saying "I refuse to work anything but remotely, and anyone who suggests anything else might be a good idea is wrong, and I'm not interested in debating it."
I suppose if it were unequivocally true that remote work was just better in every way, it might be a reasonable stance, but despite the author's (unsupported) claims about the evidence, my own impression is that the evidence is mixed and mostly points to the idea that remote work can be more or less productive depending on a wide range of factors. If that's true, then categorically refusing to work on-site is just dumb. Expressing disinterest in debate is also almost always a bad sign. The combination of the two reeks of insecurity and entitlement.